Gistou (Over!)

[Cerberus v666]

Did the flavor mame you unable to understand the results of your night actions, or any of the flips?

If the answer to that question is no, then the flavor was optional (in the sense that reading everything she write was not necessary at all, but reading the original posts about the game were useful as they should be).

FA: Pretty sure you can't complain too much about factions getting wrecked by night actions when mine had *two* guilties on it AND had two members shot by OTHER SCUM TEAMS. Not town vigs playing well. Scum teams townreading us.

I'm simply amazed town was stupid enough that you guys lived past D3.

[A Song of Ice and Fire]

I mean yeah

we were unlucky as I said my faction lost the game night 1. yours lost it night 2 and wuldens lost it by your strongman shot ...

town basically did nothing in this game :/

[Cheetory6]

How many scum got lynched?

[A Song of Ice and Fire]

and the fact you two faction shot each other like that basically shot The coup de grace on us

[Firebringer]

How many scum got lynched?

2 I think.

[Cerberus v666]

Better question: how many scum got lynched without guilties on them.

The answer to that question is 1.

[Firebringer]

Did the flavor mame you unable to understand the results of your night actions, or any of the flips?

If the answer to that question is no, then the flavor was optional (in the sense that reading everything she write was not necessary at all, but reading the original posts about the game were useful as they should be).

Yes it did.
I don't know why you are arguing with this, we had an argument day 2 for the simple ideas of who was aligned with who.
We had to read the flavor to understand this better, or at least get an idea.

Flavor was necessary.
Don't pretend it was just "there"
Did you need to read it all? No. But it was instrumental to understanding the game.

Which makes it bad flavor.

[A Song of Ice and Fire]

How many scum got lynched?

Salt Squad (Isolationist)who luna had a guilty
Lady Lambdadelta (Wulden) who was outed as wulden by a race checker - not sure who?
Wayward Thinker (Isolationist strongman) who was obvscum as fuck - the one we are all angry at for his strongman uses and stuff
rb (who got culted as wulden) cuase he slipped miller
Tim basically gave up! and was wulden checked by TWIE

the game was over starting of day 4 ... I mean there was absoloutly no chance a bunch of bullteproof uncultable vigs and other conftown players with race checkers , role blocker and an alignment checker loose against a vanilla cult :/

[A Song of Ice and Fire]

How many scum got lynched?

2 I think.

How much of this game you read?

[Firebringer]

How many scum got lynched?

2 I think.

How much of this game you read?

I don't count the Isolationist as scum anymore. They are my friends.

[A Song of Ice and Fire]

Better question: how many scum got lynched without guilties on them.

The answer to that question is 1.

no its 2

although rb got confirmed as liar becuase he was race cheked as human night 1

but it was not a guilty it was his fualt mainly to claim miller like that

[Cheetory6]

Yeah from front page it looked like a decent number of scum lynches happened.

[Firebringer]

Yeah from front page it looked like a decent number of scum lynches happened.

Yeah, there was still more cross killing that happened though.

[A Song of Ice and Fire]

there were like 6 race checkers in hand of town and its allies and 2 alignemnet checkers ....

like ehhh

[Cerberus v666]

No. People are atupid. That's why the argument happened day 2.

Every single person who was unable to understand that all "eliminate threats" win conditions were town, WHEN THE MODERATOR USED 50% VERBIAGE TO DESCRIBE SCUM WIN CONDITIONS, was being INCREDIBLY DENSE.

ESPECIALLY AFTER YOU GUYS HAD 5!!!!!!!! TOWN ROLE CARDS TO LOOK AT.

Pedit: true, I forgot about rb. Cheetory: most of those lynches were driven by guilties, which sorta deprives them of any merit. :p

[A Song of Ice and Fire]

@Cerb I was culted then and I knew a scum wincondition I was just mudding the thread omfg

[Firebringer]

No. People are atupid. That's why the argument happened day 2.

Every single person who was unable to understand that all "eliminate threats" win conditions were town, WHEN THE MODERATOR USED 50% VERBIAGE TO DESCRIBE SCUM WIN CONDITIONS, was being INCREDIBLY DENSE.

ESPECIALLY AFTER YOU GUYS HAD 5!!!!!!!! TOWN ROLE CARDS TO LOOK AT.

Pedit: true, I forgot about rb. Cheetory: most of those lynches were driven by guilties, which sorta deprives them of any merit. :p

Your stupid.

[Cheetory6]

Just think it might be a little unfair to say that town was handed the game when they clearly didn't perform terribly.
To complain that town didn't earn the win because a bunch of scum died is to ignore that if town hadn't been lynching on the mark, they probably would have lost given how multiball this was.

[Firebringer]

@Cerb I was culted then and I knew a scum wincondition I was just mudding the thread omfg

This too lol.

[Cheetory6]

Cheetory: most of those lynches were driven by guilties, which sorta deprives them of any merit. :p

Gotta target the right person to get a guilty.
Gotta leave PRs alive for them to drive guilties.
Gotta not have the multiball factions muddying the waters with fakeguilties either.

*shrug*

Just think that people should have known what they were getting into with how this game was advertised.

[A Song of Ice and Fire]

Just think it might be a little unfair to say that town was handed the game when they clearly didn't perform terribly.
To complain that town didn't earn the win because a bunch of scum died is to ignore that if town hadn't been lynching on the mark, they probably would have lost given how multiball this was.

Town earned the win. I'm not saying otherwise

I have balance argues and some complains about how some scums played their games ... cuase thats why we lost the game! but thats fine

[A Song of Ice and Fire]

Cheetory: most of those lynches were driven by guilties, which sorta deprives them of any merit. :p

Gotta target the right person to get a guilty.
Gotta leave PRs alive for them to drive guilties.
Gotta not have the multiball factions muddying the waters with fakeguilties either.

*shrug*

Just think that people should have known what they were getting into with how this game was advertised.

there were 8 town investigators and 4 confirmed town in a 28 player setup

not sure what are you trying to say cheet. this town was op.

[Cerberus v666]

Oh, and the SS guilty happened for like basically no reason. Luna was outright townreading him, and just...checked him anyways.

Lol. So silly. Plays well enough to get both cops townreading him, and still gets copped.

Pedit: I'm talking about everyone else, not you guys obviously.

Cheetory, please read my comment about the guilties.

Peditx2: one of the guilties was scum on scum. The rest were from the race check, which SHOULD NOT HAVE FUNCTIONED AS A COP, BUT DID.

[Firebringer]

Just think that people should have known what they were getting into with how this game was advertised.

Probably.

[Cerberus v666]

I said this in the dead thread too, but just want to note that the town probably wasn't overpowered overall...considering they were arguably one roleblock away from losing.

Rach doesn't block you, you recruit her, you have a roleblock to stop a vig, you kill one and shut down the other, and have a good shot at winning.

Of course, you shoulda been dead on N3 after nos got lynched D3 after being caught killing me, but towns inability to work out that simple logical progression is another issue entirely.