Mafiascum.net

In post 2046, mastina wrote:

In post 2026, Ircher wrote:McMenno has so far done nothing constructive AT ALL this game imo. Why do you think he's town?

It's too early to tell for sure, actually. He's not town.
But the reason he's not scum is experience.

Have you

played

with McMenno before?

I have.
Tell me, what's the difference between here, here, here, here, here, here, here, and here.

Hint: 2 games scum, 6 games town. Which are which?

His posts aren't identical as both alignments, sure.
But they're pretty damn similar.

Fair enough.

Has no one considered Vax fakeclaiming to draw out a disruptive role to scum?

Proceed with rope

In post 2069, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:If we let this go what's stopping us from letting anyone who roleclaims go

There's 13 roles obv scum got some...

Pedit:@Ceph

Thats a bold scum move there SAD

Zito talk to me

In post 2076, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:

In post 2063, Papa Zito wrote:

In post 2059, SpyreX wrote:I really want someone to call him out but deep inside i know it won't Halen page 150 hoo

bro

What is this btw?

What is the spyrex post anyway?

In post 2126, Fate wrote:Has no one considered Vax fakeclaiming to draw out a disruptive role to scum?

Proceed with rope

Wellllll that's easy to fix
But lets be real you fake claim that one

I'm not caught up, but I want to post eavesdrop as it comes in:

peggy: maybe ?

In post 2126, Fate wrote:Has no one considered Vax fakeclaiming to draw out a disruptive role to scum?

Proceed with rope

It clearly isnt succeeding

In post 2126, Fate wrote:Has no one considered Vax fakeclaiming to draw out a disruptive role to scum?

Proceed with rope

Think before you speak.

In post 2130, Vaxkiller wrote:I'm not caught up, but I want to post eavesdrop as it comes in:

peggy: maybe

alice

?

Okay so like.

I know if these are real the scum posts are still troll and stuff, so like everything is WIFOM and probably waste of time to focus on these "leaks" (unless like an actual gem is caught).

BUT who are the people that usually post in all smalls?

UT, Mcmenno, hiplop? Sometimes Cephrir, Zito, Firebringer?

In post 2122, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:Umm.......

Unless obv he's scum.

So we're back to point 0, where his claim didn't change anything.

You still didn't get my point.

Well spell it out clearer for the dense people in the crowd.

I suck too much with words to get through some thicker skulls so I'll leave that to someone else who's better at sentence structuring.

LLD what did we learn from PYP?

I think he's scum.

In post 2138, GreyICE wrote:LLD what did we learn from PYP?

I think he's scum.

Who?

>actually trying to look for scumtells based on eavesdropped posts

In post 2140, Accountant wrote:>actually trying to look for scumtells based on eavesdropped posts

More time they spent on trolling cos of leaks, less time they spent to talk about something productive.

In post 2138, GreyICE wrote:LLD what did we learn from PYP?

I think he's scum.

In a giant game when the big wagon starts to disform, it's because town are apathetic about the result and scum are fighting to kill it.

Yeah I'm down.

In post 2141, GuyInFreezer wrote:

In post 2140, Accountant wrote:>actually trying to look for scumtells based on eavesdropped posts

More time they spent on trolling cos of leaks, less time they spent to talk about something productive.

I mean if that's your point, then we're back to square one,

Vaxkiller could be scum with the role and making the shit up himself, leading to no loss in productivity amongst scum chat.

In post 2142, Lady Lambdadelta wrote:

In post 2138, GreyICE wrote:LLD what did we learn from PYP?

I think he's scum.

In a giant game when the big wagon starts to disform, it's because town are apathetic about the result and scum are fighting to kill it.

Yeah I'm down.

Vote: Vaxkiller

The wagon started to disform because of the claim; not because of apathy.

I did mention that in that case he's just a glorified goon in a game filled with power roles.

OH WAIT

VOTE: UT

I think Accountant is scum

In post 2146, xRECKONERx wrote:OH WAIT

VOTE: UT

I think Accountant is scum

Why?

In post 2117, GuyInFreezer wrote:

In post 2110, GuyInFreezer wrote:

In post 2108, Untrod Tripod wrote:with a heavy dose of making-shit-up-as-I-go-along mixed in.

Man why did you have to say this now

I was baiting him for more

Oh btw the explanation.

In post 1933, Something_Smart wrote:everything he said about me is awful and sounds faked.

> Main reasoning

In post 1941, Something_Smart wrote:It's bad because he's calling me scum. Particularly, he's fixating on my first post and just writing all the others off as not influential to change his read based on that. He "still" wants me to die as if I've been his strongest scumread all game; for that to be true he had to have been hardly reading anything.

> "He

could

be town if he actually barely read anything."

In post 1942, GuyInFreezer wrote:

He "still" wants me to die as if I've been his strongest scumread all game; for that to be true he had to have been hardly reading anything.

And he did admit to hardly reading anything no?

> Presents that he actually barely read anything

In post 1944, Something_Smart wrote:but then he shouldn't be demanding that I be nuked because that's basically asking other people to follow his read that he admits is uninformed and terrible

he's trying to look like he believes in what he's doing when he doesn't

> changes to "he's scum because he barely read anything and pushing the read"

In post 1958, Something_Smart wrote:

In post 1955, GuyInFreezer wrote:

In post 1953, Something_Smart wrote:So I'm assuming that he can't honestly believe in a read that's based on not reading the thread.

I can. Why can't he?

because he explicitly cited having read ALL my posts as the reason for that read.

To be fair, it is possible that he scumreads me based on reading only what I've said. But to have me as his top scumread, to the point where he'd nuke me?

I don't buy it.

> Voila! He finally connected to this altered scenario into his original reasoning of "sounds fake" argument!

this is... super reachy to say the least.
and it's manipulative too, though it doesn't seem like that was intentional.

He's scum because what he said is faked. The reason it's faked is that he seems very convinced that I'm scum despite self-admittedly having not read. Him having me as his strongest scumread means that he either has a clue what's going on or he's making up crap, and it's obvious that he doesn't have a clue, so therefore he's making up crap.

In post 2148, Something_Smart wrote:and it's manipulative too, though it doesn't seem like that was intentional.

Completely intentional and is manipulative.
Town wouldn't have done what you've done here so yeah