Survivor: Civilization - Congratulations Boudica!!!
-
-
hiplop Jury Darling
- Jury Darling
- Jury Darling
- Posts: 12498
- Joined: March 23, 2011
- Location: full of self
-
-
D3f3nd3r he/himBest Social Gamehe/him
- Best Social Game
- Best Social Game
- Posts: 1368
- Joined: March 25, 2012
- Pronoun: he/him
- Location: Maryland
Borobudur or however that's spelled was a pretty good idea, I wish there was a little bit more clarity, but I did fairly quickly get to the point of "find the dude who can do the thing, he will only do it if you get to him from somebody else in particular". My problem was just that it took me too long to figure out who "the dude" and "somebody else in particular" were, that took me about 45 minutes to do.“The assumption of good faith is dead”
(profile pic by datisi)-
-
bippy Townie
- Townie
- Townie
- Posts: 8
- Joined: January 9, 2017
- Location: survivor genious
-
-
Aronis Just here for the Pagetop!
- Just here for the Pagetop!
- Just here for the Pagetop!
- Posts: 6580
- Joined: January 18, 2014
- Location: Somewhere
the pizza gift card was awesome, why would you be upset w/ that????In post 74, Iprobablysuck wrote:Yo i'm still pretty peeved that people got items and shit and I gotta Pizza giftcard X_X
Hope you enjoyed that Pizza Reck
Aren't hiplop and CC running a low twist game soon?-
-
Mina The Shipwright
- The Shipwright
- The Shipwright
- Posts: 3059
- Joined: October 1, 2009
Yeah, I didn't mind this with the techs, because I thought the flavour clued you into which ones were good. But when it's completely random, it feels like bidding on the right one is a crap shoot. Eight probably would have been the perfect number.In post 71, DrumBeats wrote:Yes Alex had a ton of money, but he also got lucky that people didn't bid heavy on the mystery prizes he was going for. When you have 8 mystery boxes that contain such drastically different rewards (pizza vs an idol), it's a crapshoot. At 8 items, every item is likely to be bid somewhat heavily on, so it stops one person from sweeping them.-
-
Mina The Shipwright
- The Shipwright
- The Shipwright
- Posts: 3059
- Joined: October 1, 2009
-
-
BROseidon Expert Marxman
- Expert Marxman
- Expert Marxman
- Posts: 8242
- Joined: April 18, 2013
We were told time.In post 70, hiplop wrote:
yeah, this was bullshit. challenge was weird but fine, lack of judging criteria is a major no-noIn post 69, DrumBeats wrote:I thought Borobudur was a frustrating but very interesting challenge. I definitely enjoy the idea of it but my biggest issue with it was that it wasn't clear how we were being judged. As I was playing I had to angleshoot about what would make more sense for the mods to judge it by, number of moves or time. That definitely had an impact on how I played it because I spent extra time trying to optimize my paths with the map that I had of it. I think it was fine for us to go in not knowing it was a maze, but I think we should've known how it was being judged.-
-
BROseidon Expert Marxman
- Expert Marxman
- Expert Marxman
- Posts: 8242
- Joined: April 18, 2013
-
-
hiplop Jury Darling
- Jury Darling
- Jury Darling
- Posts: 12498
- Joined: March 23, 2011
- Location: full of self
-
-
BROseidon Expert Marxman
-
-
BROseidon Expert Marxman
- Expert Marxman
- Expert Marxman
- Posts: 8242
- Joined: April 18, 2013
-
-
BROseidon Expert Marxman
- Expert Marxman
- Expert Marxman
- Posts: 8242
- Joined: April 18, 2013
-
-
Shadoweh Idol Hands
- Idol Hands
- Idol Hands
- Posts: 4276
- Joined: November 9, 2011
I still say the pizza giftcard should have been an announced item just to see who would bid on a real world gain versus a random box >.>
Most auctions have random boxes and the MS expectation is that they have varying results, usually a few empty/bad boxes and one idol somewhere. Civ at least guaranteed no one got literally nothing for their dollar. So that's more of an MS problem. The items didn't end up mechanically affecting the game other then Alex's, and Alex told quite a few people about his stash. It's kudos to him that no one targetted him before it was too late.
In my opinion more weaker items is still better then less stronger items ie the idol brigades that happened in Eon and Nexus.I HATE YOU SO MUCH PLEASE GO JUMP INTO A FREEZING LAKE - Mr. Freeze
And this was like me realizing that you were a serial killer. - Hathor
"but I must declare my love to Edelgard here, i offer you the treasure I stole from Raphael, an idol LOL" - Shamir-
-
BROseidon Expert Marxman
- Expert Marxman
- Expert Marxman
- Posts: 8242
- Joined: April 18, 2013
-
-
grumpy
-
-
hiplop Jury Darling
- Jury Darling
- Jury Darling
- Posts: 12498
- Joined: March 23, 2011
- Location: full of self
i mean when youre talking about design what ends up happening isnt that relevant?In post 87, Shadoweh wrote:The items didn't end up mechanically affecting the game other then Alex'
things like super unclear "item stoppers" are extremely problematic. Poor definitions of interactions, etcthird best scummer of all time-
-
Cephrir he/himSurvivorhe/him
- Survivor
- Survivor
- Posts: 25291
- Joined: October 11, 2006
- Pronoun: he/him
- Location: Seattle-ish
I think this is meaningful enough to do sometimes, because of the way it sets up a 2v2v2 dynamic in the real starting tribes. I think that's something interesting that it can add.In post 39, xRECKONERx wrote:#1- I don't think we need the 24 hour starter-but-just-kidding period in games anymore. If we're gonna set a start time for games, then start the game at those times, I think. It has gotten to the point where I think it has lost its "surprise" factor and the issue it was trying to correct isn't really prevalent anymore"I would prefer not to." --Herman Melville,Bartleby the Scrivener-
-
D3f3nd3r he/himBest Social Gamehe/him
- Best Social Game
- Best Social Game
- Posts: 1368
- Joined: March 25, 2012
- Pronoun: he/him
- Location: Maryland
-
-
BROseidon Expert Marxman
- Expert Marxman
- Expert Marxman
- Posts: 8242
- Joined: April 18, 2013
-
-
Haschel Cedricson Mr. Know It All
- Mr. Know It All
- Mr. Know It All
- Posts: 2954
- Joined: May 14, 2007
- Location: Cascadian Subduction Zone
Woo, finally back from my vacation which means I have time to type a wall about the design choices of this game, and I guess twist philosophy in general. Some of this is pretty much paraphrased from things I said in the Spectator Station during the game, but hopefully there are new ideas here too.
First of all, there are two quotes that I want to bring up, one from me and one from Reck:Haschel Cedricson wrote:Expect a fun game with a few twists but nothing completely out of left field.
The former is something I believe to be true. If a gun was held to my head before the game I would have told you that on a twistiness scale of 1-5 this game was solidly a 3. And yet it's apparent that is not the consensus.xRECKONERx wrote:PSV would IMO be the best example of a "normal" game in our current site climate. Only twists were tribe swaps.
The latter, on the other hand, is something I disagree with entirely. As a player, I recall posting in my confessional that "vanilla" obviously only referred to the flavor because from a mechanics standpoint the game felt like anything but.
So why the disconnect?
I've been thinking about this a lot lately, and I think a large part of it is the fact that a moderator or reviewer sees the entire game at once, with each twist a small part of an overarching whole. Players, on the other hand, by definition encounter each twist doled out one at a time. It doesn't matter how the parts fit together when you have a 24 hour deadline and everything feels like it's just been switched up around you. And I think it's a fair point that right now we have this disconnect between players and moderators.
This game is a prime example of the whole-versus-parts dichotomy.
When this game was in the initial design stages, I wanted two Main Twists. First of all, I wanted to steal Death Row and bring it back because I thought it was a clever, newbie-friendly device that made the game more interesting. Secondly, I wanted challenge ability/performance to be important.
Now, if you are going to have Death Row/Terra Incognita, then a few things have to happen. You need people being eliminated two at a time for several rounds. You need a pregame talking period so people can start to form relationships with players who will later not be on their tribe for the main game. You need opportunities for crosstribe talk so that these relationships can continue. You need the main game to switch to single eliminations for enough rounds to whittle TI down to only two returners. Are these twists? Sure. But they aren't random; every one is in service to an overarching idea.
The same happens with the twist of rewarding challenge ability. The way techs were discovered not by the first person to find them but the person who did the best on the particular puzzle was part of that. And if you do that, you want multiple people to attempt the puzzles, which means announcing when something is able to be found. Challenge performance mattering also led to the gold/auction mechanic. And if winning challenges and doing well on them is supposed to be important, then that means gold has to be useful. And if gold is useful, that means there have to be items to buy.
A lot of people have expressed displeasure with 16 items being in the game. I understand that complaint. It was definitely something we talked about during the design phase, and something I specifically asked about during review. It certainly sounds wacky and unbalanced. However, here's the breakdown of items:
Florence, Buenos Aires, Rio de Janiero, Warsaw, Edinburgh, Capetown: These are the doublevotes/nullifiers. ALL these items do is either create ties or break ties. With six in the game the odds of multiple of these being played during the same TC were fairly likely, and indeed this is exactly what happened during TC 15. The general consensus around having an extra vote around these forums seems to be that it's an ability that feels important but isn't as useful as it feels it should be. Here multiple players, through their challenge performance earlier in the game, earned the ability to make/break ties. Is thatthatunbalanced? I don't think it is.
Kyzyl, Hong Kong: A challenge advantage. Again, these aren't super powerful rewards but as a player they feel really good to have.
Bucharest: The HII. Having an immunity idol in an auction is par for the course. You could probably bogey the course and still come up with an auction HII.
Sydney: The vacation. A powerful item with the drawback of not being able to influence the vote yourself. That's an interesting choice for me and I have no regrets about this item.
Vienna: Vote Revealer. Another standard low-power reward. Identifying Jules/Gilgs self-votes may literally be the most influential one of these items has ever been in MS history.
Algiers: Secret Subforum. This was supposed to be a top-tier reward. Obviously it wasn't used that way but it was supposed to be.
Singapore: The extra vote at FTC. Once again, looks nice but only breaks or creates ties. Also, you have to make FTC first.
Vatican City: A literal pizza. This was indeed a bit of a gag item, albeit one much nicer than "an empty box". This was borne from a conversation where I was lamenting that our MS auctions can't duplicate the ecstasy of seeing starving people bid hundreds of dollars for a burger and fries. I admit this doesn't really fit the challenge-are-important twist but this is one item out of sixteen and it was supposed to have no affect on the game at all.
Oslo, Jakarta: These items canceled out existing items. These reined in the power of a crop of mostly already relatively unpowerful items even more.
So yeah, sixteen items sounds like a lot. But they were all specifically designed to be mostly low-power minor boosts to reward people for premerge challenge ability, and they fulfilled that role perfectly.
In closing, I certainly understand why some parts of this game were less than enjoyable for some people. But hopefully everybody understands that this game wasn't designed by throwing darts at a dartboard; a lot of thought went into the goals for the game and how everything was supposed to fit together.-
-
hiplop Jury Darling
- Jury Darling
- Jury Darling
- Posts: 12498
- Joined: March 23, 2011
- Location: full of self
a lot of mystery items even if low powered (and many of these i *disagree are low powered)+ 2 returnees at the start of merge is massive.
so like
there are twists where it surprises the players, but they have power over the situation. Its a "twist" in a situation, but they have the knowledge of what consequences will happen if they do x thing. "You can not attend this tribal" "you are on exile for the night, you replace whoever gets voted out".
problem with death row/outcasts/etc is like...you make players pull a lever that looks normal and then surprise them with a result. That to me is a twist where the players have no autonomy. That, to me, is a bad twist.third best scummer of all time-
-
Cheery Dog Kayak
- Kayak
- Kayak
- Posts: 8038
- Joined: June 30, 2012
- Location: OMG BALL!
I think just having returning players sort of puts the twist level up a notch.
While it's completely fine most of the time for the people with those second chances, it's the people still in the game and working hard to remain there that will have it feel it's that level of difficulty.
Spoiler: Australian Survivor Season 2 spoiler
So it's not just that they lived through whatever twist, it's that they now have a chance of doing better than you, even after worked on having them eliminated in the first place.Holder of the Longest Continuous Weekly Mafiascum Post Record. 1 July 2012 - 16 Feb 2023
*It may be held by someone else if you discount the major downtime in 2012 and 2014, I'm not doing the research.-
-
hiplop Jury Darling
- Jury Darling
- Jury Darling
- Posts: 12498
- Joined: March 23, 2011
- Location: full of self
-
-
BROseidon Expert Marxman
- Expert Marxman
- Expert Marxman
- Posts: 8242
- Joined: April 18, 2013
-
-
BROseidon Expert Marxman
- Expert Marxman
- Expert Marxman
- Posts: 8242
- Joined: April 18, 2013
Also this game mostly just suffered from lack of editing.
Did the opposing tribe in the TCs need a vote, versus being available to PM?
Did we need 16 city-states instead of 10 or 8?
Did we need technologies at all, or did gold/auction by itself emphasize challenge performance enough (beyond what is important by default)?
Like just taking some stuff out would have gone a long way towards streamlining the game and making it feel a bit lighter/less twisty.
Copyright © MafiaScum. All rights reserved.
-