Newbie 588 - Game Over!

[Mafiamurkrow]

AW BLEH. -has mysteriously disappeared for a while due to busynessism- I'm sorry for poofing. D=

Official Vote Count

Cat_Killer - 2 (Abstract Actuary, Mafiamurkrow)
camisade - 1 (Dave)
Mafiamurkrow - 3 (rolandofthewhite, goborage, Grum)

Not Voting - 3 (camisade, Cat_Killer, The World No.1 Noob)

5 to Lynch

[rolandofthewhite]

Well that wasn't helpful.

[camisade]

AW BLEH. -has mysteriously disappeared for a while due to busynessism- I'm sorry for poofing. D=

Ugh. Do you not have anything to say besides that?

vote: Mafiamurkrow

[Mafiamurkrow]

No. N oit wasn't. -fail- Just apologizing for being extremely dumb and not checking my bookmarks. But I changed my homepage to here, so all should be well in the future.

[rolandofthewhite]

Do you have anything to say in defense of your previous comments (or lack thereof)?

[rolandofthewhite]

Er, I guess not.

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

You asked for it.

Retractable deadline set for Saturday, April 19th. If discussion picks up to an acceptable level and stays there, I'll rescind the deadline.

-Vel

[Grum]

WELL I'M WAITING FOR MAFIAMURKROWS RESPONSE SO...

[Mafiamurkrow]

Huh...erm,

vote: no lynch.

I have no leads and no idea otherwise, so I can't really lynch anyone.

[The World No.1 Noob]

april 19th, well thats not too bad we still got 10 days to gather as much info as we can.

[Cat_Killer]

Mafiamurkrow seems scummy to me. See:

Unvote.

And...

Vote: Cat-Killer.

Why did you do this? You should probably post reasons when you vote, because if you don't it seems suspicious.

Okay, here's my reason.

First, I voted no lynch because I didn't really suspect anybody. But then...I thought it over and voted CK. Sorry, Cat-Killer.

That's... not a reason. Failing to adequitely explain his motives.

And why did you vote Cat-Killer?

Does it really matter? Besides, whoever I vote might get other people to vote for them too. And really, no need to know EVERYTHING...

Again, continuously avoiding the question. Add that to the terminal lurking and I think it's scummy.

I'm holding off my vote becuase that would put him on L-1, however, unless something changes my mind, I WILL be voting for him.

FOS: Mafiamurkrow

[Dave]

Unvote

for now

[Abstract Actuary]

Based on these two posts it looks like Mafia Murkrow is at L-1.

Official Vote Count

Cat_Killer - 2 (Abstract Actuary, Mafiamurkrow)
camisade - 1 (Dave)
Mafiamurkrow - 3 (rolandofthewhite, goborage, Grum)

Not Voting - 3 (camisade, Cat_Killer, The World No.1 Noob)

5 to Lynch

AW BLEH. -has mysteriously disappeared for a while due to busynessism- I'm sorry for poofing. D=

Ugh. Do you not have anything to say besides that?

vote: Mafiamurkrow

And at least one person who thinks he's suspicious enough to add the hammer.

Mafiamurkrow seems scummy to me. See:

Unvote.

And...

Vote: Cat-Killer.

Why did you do this? You should probably post reasons when you vote, because if you don't it seems suspicious.

Okay, here's my reason.

First, I voted no lynch because I didn't really suspect anybody. But then...I thought it over and voted CK. Sorry, Cat-Killer.

That's... not a reason. Failing to adequitely explain his motives.

And why did you vote Cat-Killer?

Does it really matter? Besides, whoever I vote might get other people to vote for them too. And really, no need to know EVERYTHING...

Again, continuously avoiding the question. Add that to the terminal lurking and I think it's scummy.

I'm holding off my vote becuase that would put him on L-1, however, unless something changes my mind, I WILL be voting for him.

FOS: Mafiamurkrow

And all Mafiamurkrow has to say is . . .

Huh...erm,

vote: no lynch.

I have no leads and no idea otherwise, so I can't really lynch anyone.

Seems like it could be scum saying "I'm not going to name any names as to avoid leaving any more trail." Anyway, I think it's time to get a role claim from Mafiamurkrow.

[camisade]

I'm back, but it looks like I didn't miss much...

Anyway, I think it's time to get a role claim from Mafiamurkrow.

I agree. Or just lynch her because I've gotten sick of her BS.

[The World No.1 Noob]

I agree with that, I'm not actually 100% sure she's mafia because her replies are too mafiaish, wouldn't a real mafia have thought up a better plan? But as camisade said her attitude is anti townie and its better to kill her to make things easier for the townies

vote: Mafiamurkrow

Fixed - Vel

[The World No.1 Noob]

ummm how to i make it bold?

[rolandofthewhite]

Like this:

Code: Select all

[b]Vote: ___[/b]

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Also, if you use the "PostReply" button at the top and bottom of the thread on the left side, instead of using the quick reply box, there are click buttons you can use for bolding, italics, underlining, etc.

- Vel

[Abstract Actuary]

Isn't that the hammer? If it is we just made a newbie mistake as a town. We should always give a player heading towards the gallows a chance to claim their role. Town power players (doctors, cops) should tell us their role. All vanilla players should never claim anything other than vanilla. This would give us a chance to back off of the wagon to keep the town power player alive, at least until night.

I hope that Mafiamurkrow was not a town power player.

[Dave]

I dont know if it was, becasue cat killer only FOSed.

[goborage]

We have 5: rolandofthewhite, goborage, Grum, camisade, and The World No.1 Noob.

Dave and Cat_Killer aren't voting. Abstract Actuary and Mafiamurkrow are voting for Cat_Killer (Mafiamurkrow didn't unvote).

It'll be fun analyzing the votes on day 2.

[Grum]

I don't know if this sounds hypocritical but #1 noob kind of strikes me as a scummy person due to the nature of that hammer a little too strong for suspicion. I wanted to hear the role claim first... guess we find out in a bad way...

FOS #1 noob

[The World No.1 Noob]

I'm simple civilian, not doctor or investigator.

[Dave]

Ok, my mistake

[Abstract Actuary]

I'm simple civilian, not doctor or investigator.

Not your role claim, Mafiamurkrow's. In general you don't want to ever claim your role unless you are about to be lynched and you are a town power role. Even telling the rest of the town you are plain vanilla helps the mafia.

Once Mafiamurkrow (or anyone for that matter) got to L-1 we requested a role claim (from him) so we didn't kill a town power role. Your hammer made that impossible.