In post 1148, BlueSnakelet wrote:
For scum to win, they only have to reach Elo with one townie that will definitively vote for another.
I have been flippy-floppy on my Delta read, and was, by your admission, hard to read. There was no guarantee that I would retain my scumread in the moment it matters.
You have
not
been flip-floppy on me though. You thought I was town the entire game. You didn't SR me until I had already accused you of being partners with mala
So going back to the start of D3, it wouldn't make sense for me to change my tune from Delta!scum to Blue!scum if I were actually scum. The play would've been to keep my mala/Delta stance and let you continue to TR me/sus Delta. Then I could take you two to this situation and we would vote Delta ez pz
Why would I purposefully choose the harder path to victory if I'm scum?
Yeah. There's just no way town!Blue carried this opinion all the way to D3 and then suddenly drops the possibility of it being Delta in 3p ELO. That never, ever comes from town!Blue here
In post 1148, BlueSnakelet wrote:
For scum to win, they only have to reach Elo with one townie that will definitively vote for another.
I have been flippy-floppy on my Delta read, and was, by your admission, hard to read. There was no guarantee that I would retain my scumread in the moment it matters.
You have
not
been flip-floppy on me though. You thought I was town the entire game. You didn't SR me until I had already accused you of being partners with mala
So going back to the start of D3, it wouldn't make sense for me to change my tune from Delta!scum to Blue!scum if I were actually scum. The play would've been to keep my mala/Delta stance and let you continue to TR me/sus Delta. Then I could take you two to this situation and we would vote Delta ez pz
Why would I purposefully choose the harder path to victory if I'm scum?
Harder path? Anyone reading the game can see that Delta voting me is more likely than me voting Delta. Are you saying that Scum!Black would not try to capitalize on Delta's deathtunnel?
This endgame is winning for you. That much is clear.
Let he who is with sin, and loves it, cast the final stone.
In post 1153, BlueSnakelet wrote:
Harder path? Anyone reading the game can see that Delta voting me is more likely than me voting Delta.
This was
not
more likely at the beginning of D3 and you know it. Before I decided it was most likely you/mala on D3, you SRed Delta and TRed me. So at that point why would scum!me switch to painting you as the partner when I could have just taken you and Delta to P3 and we vote Delta off? There was no indication you SRed me at all when I switched from Delta to you
In post 1153, BlueSnakelet wrote:
Harder path? Anyone reading the game can see that Delta voting me is more likely than me voting Delta.
This was
not
more likely at the beginning of D3 and you know it. Before I decided it was most likely you/mala on D3, you SRed Delta and TRed me. So at that point why would scum!me switch to painting you as the partner when I could have just taken you and Delta to P3 and we vote Delta off? There was no indication you SRed me at all when I switched from Delta to you
I admit my progression doesn't make sense. I was an unreadable black box (pun not intended) and you could not trust me to not change my mind at the last moment.
Delta was really transparent about his distrust for me the whole way. He even solved for BlueXMala even before Mala was declared obviously scum.
For you, supporting Delta and eliminating me is more likery to work than the other way around.
Let he who is with sin, and loves it, cast the final stone.
In post 1155, BlueSnakelet wrote:
For you, supporting Delta and eliminating me is more likery to work than the other way around.
I strongly disagree here. In a scenario where I'm scum and you're both town, I side with the person that TRs me and SRs the other guy. That's you Blue. It doesn't make sense for me to try to side with Delta, the person that has scumread me for a lot of this game, and trust that he will choose me over you. That's a lot more work
Also you never answered me. Why did you come into this situation thinking there's a 0% chance it could be Delta? That should be the main proof for Delta here that you're scum tbh
In post 1164, Black wrote:
And Andante could have lost this game for the town just by being so damn suspicious of me lol
I'll just take this as a sign that I did at least something right.
I think you played pretty well tbh. The only thing I would've done different was try to solve more on D3 and D4. Especially D4. If you had come into this situation trying to solve and figure out it's me or Delta I don't think this ELO would've been so easy
