Micro 1091 - Bar Review (Dead/Spec PT)

[Prism]

Unfortunately this is in fact my fault.

Spoiler:

This all happened because one of the starting fakeclaims was a miller one, which cued them off to the fact that there was no miller. They figured there HAD to be a cop and were skeptical of Luke's claim as a result, but it literally doesn't even matter.

Let no good deed go unpunished. Never give the scumteam mechanical fakeclaims preemptively.

[Alisae]

Ego

[Alisae]

My death was unavoidable it is what it is

[Alisae]

I’m not typically a player that saves those slots I just pop in say who I think is mafia and hopefully that’s good nuff

[Bell]

Well, it sounds like you pointed correctly. I don't think, based on my estimation, it will be enough. It takes a lot to bring them down, usually multiple people need to piggyback off each other.

[Prism]

Welcome, Lukewarm, and thank you for replacing in!

[Prism]

GL is the way to go today I think though, now that we know that Ali/rh9 was town

Surely one of the VT claims is scum. Why don't we just go through them one by one?

Spoiler: Darth Pooky

[Bell]

My goodness, so many of Sk’s posts are going to bite them. They literally keep giving out two options and then keep choosing not scum.

[RH9]

My goodness, so many of Sk’s posts are going to bite them. They literally keep giving out two options and then keep choosing not scum.

Agreed.

[Bell]

Still we deserve the loss for making a silly assumption. So, I have no hate.

[Prism]

#2Millerz

[Lukewarm]

thank god, I was pretty bad this game. I would hate to be handling the elo.

[Lukewarm]

getting my track result really was a job scare into thinking I was actually going to have to play out this day

[RH9]

thank god, I was pretty bad this game. I would hate to be handling the elo.

You tried your best.
Don't be too hard on yourself.

[Lukewarm]

One thing that I can say about me losing my mind is that no one has pointed out that this is a Normal game, which I emphasized in 4 different places, and Beholder is a non-Normal role.

This is only 2% of my overall confusion but contextually it makes the other 98% so much worse.

I did point that out!

[Lukewarm]

there is some magical aura surrounding rh9 that makes luke specifically want to bend over backwards to find ways to townread his posts

I have in fact been guilty of that in the past, AND I went through that CORRECTLY this game, BUT then I convinced myself that I was repeating my past mistakes.

smh

[Lukewarm]

with luke i was more remembering the end of warrior cats and feeling like his reasoning had similar vibes here and wondering why that didn't seem to give him any hesitation

i admire the willingness to try again regardless of correctness, but it is at least a little more admirable to do it and also be right

THAT IS THE EXACT GAME I WAS TALKING ABOUT

[Lukewarm]

the repeated "we really shouldn't be talking about this but hey everyone remember that dunn definitely could have another doc shot" is like actually pretty good cover for giving a reason to shoot dunn tonight

I did not really believe that it was super likely, but thought that acting like I thought it was likely could potentially cause scum to not shoot me.

And the way RH and Meuh approached it was frustrating.

If THEY WERE RIGHT, saying it out loud felt anti-town. Like, if you think Dunn only has 1 shot, you WANT the scum team to think that he has 2 shots. Lets trick the scum team, and let them make a mistake with their night kill.

So saying "his play makes more sense to me if he has 2 shots" or JUST IGNORING THE POSSIBILITY was better imo.

At least Meuh was arguing that Dunn should be the elim that day, so :shrug: for that I guess, but it was still frustrating.

[Lukewarm]

This game in a nutshell.

Spoiler: Major Alignment spoilers

It says a lot that Datisi hasn't even read the game and is 2/2 purely off of asking "Does this make any sense if the mod is not sadistic?" Unfortunately, Datisi is in the dead PT and not the game.

Designing this game, with this playerlist, was supposed to be a performance art invitational, framed as a delightful dinner over a carefully cooked and curated meal.

Instead it's a bunch of children running around unsupervised with forks finding outlets in the dining room that I never even knew existed and raiding my Elmer's stash. Don't get me started on the random retconning claims the mafia PT was shooting around earlier that had me losing my mind.

My opening read was that Pooky was not really a miller based on his interactions with the Meuh Miller claim, and CATBOI TALKED ME OUT OF IT! I BLAME HIM

[Lukewarm]

My death was unavoidable it is what it is

While I don't think my mind was going to be changed at that point, I do think that if you had voted meuh instead of yourself, there was a really good chance that meuh was the elim.

She was at e-1, gl unvoted just so you could not hammer. If you put her back at e-1, GL would have reasonably considered hammering.

[Lukewarm]

I was actually the ONLY town player arguing for your elim

[Lukewarm]

wait.

I should have spoilered that.

[Alisae]

My death was unavoidable it is what it is

While I don't think my mind was going to be changed at that point, I do think that if you had voted meuh instead of yourself, there was a really good chance that meuh was the elim.

She was at e-1, gl unvoted just so you could not hammer. If you put her back at e-1, GL would have reasonably considered hammering.

If I was mafia I always take hammer there

[Alisae]

I didn't wanna just slam it

[RH9]

the repeated "we really shouldn't be talking about this but hey everyone remember that dunn definitely could have another doc shot" is like actually pretty good cover for giving a reason to shoot dunn tonight

I did not really believe that it was super likely, but thought that acting like I thought it was likely could potentially cause scum to not shoot me.

And the way RH and Meuh approached it was frustrating.

If THEY WERE RIGHT, saying it out loud felt anti-town. Like, if you think Dunn only has 1 shot, you WANT the scum team to think that he has 2 shots. Lets trick the scum team, and let them make a mistake with their night kill.

So saying "his play makes more sense to me if he has 2 shots" or JUST IGNORING THE POSSIBILITY was better imo.

At least Meuh was arguing that Dunn should be the elim that day, so :shrug: for that I guess, but it was still frustrating.

Sorry.