[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/ext/alfredoramos/seometadata/event/listener.php on line 114: Undefined array key 14080590 [phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/ext/alfredoramos/seometadata/event/listener.php on line 114: Trying to access array offset on value of type null Kemusan - Game Over - Mafiascum.net
In post 246, fireisredsir wrote:
LLD i don't exactly think is scum i think i probably won't be actually trying to sort her yet but she did this kind of highposting vibing as scum in PYP and i had a similar wary feeling about some things there. and i don't really love the std read
you don't even know what the std read is about lol
also I had planned to play this game high regardless of alignment becUss I wanted to play with my friends and not get frustrated at how cliquish dance games get so im here to be like, chill and solve
i can explain std stinky but it probably wont make sense to you unless you open your mind
being chill and solving is good
my mind is very open you can explain if you want
i think rh9 and std are both lightly towny so far fwiw
okay so like, follow me here
i draw town, sadge.png
i think "okay but what if i think like scum would and try to mind meld with the thread and if anyone mind melds me then STINKY"
i see FB, scum instinct says "call them town to position myself for later", STD does it.
stinky
then i see firered, fire AND fire. posting anime gifs.
"call both fires town for memetic value and get in on the take early so people value you as having called it, more positional value"
STD does it
STINKY
RH9 also does it, but sounds worse doing it
MEGA STINKY
could you elaborate on your scum instinct telling you to TR FB? like, haven't looked at STD's post but i'd like to know why it would be a scum thing
Post
Post #349 (isolation #3) » Fri Feb 09, 2024 9:46 pm
Postby Gypyx »
In post 274, fireisredsir wrote:
cabd also not passing the vibe check to me but i have even less baseline there and also probably extenuating circumstances
Kinda agree, i don't think it's necessarily scum but it just doesn't feel like regular town solviness he like, mostly seems interested about giving out his opinions but he doesn't have a lot of them?
In post 352, HolySpiritTurtle wrote:
My personal win condition is very similar but leave Ydra behind. I’m going to be honest, it’s not looking too well.
Doomed from the start, there are less ladies than gents so all the ladies get paired this day phase.
As I said, it ain’t looking too well.
not if we make this a transgender danse so that people may switch sides during pair selection
pedit : eh i mean, if he came back with the intent to dance with one of his buddies i could see it? He might also simply feel coerced into doing it, like "hey cabd why are you so shy about dancing with me"
granted maybe i'm overevaluating how ffery / cabd would naturally want to pair themselves, i'm not really up to date on the mafiascum social hierarchy
In post 383, fferyllt wrote:
Spiffeh that is a surprising amount of sync. Reminds me of WH13.
At this table who among the gents do you think aren't easily manipulable by a hypothetical scum LLD?
or we could do an LLD+scummy gent pair that way it will absolutely be doable to get them out?
are scum/scum pairs bad for town?
I think they were tried in a couple of early dance games and were worse for scum than town. But I wasn't paying close attention when this design was new and novel.
only problem with a scumpair is that either we vote it out day 1 or we need 2 town pairs to both be alive and recognize the scumpair is a scumpair in day 2
Post
Post #511 (isolation #24) » Sat Feb 10, 2024 8:13 am
Postby Gypyx »
In post 508, Cabd wrote:
Wait, we have a "side" of mafiascum now?
I missed this memo.
idk it certainely feels like there's a side that lays dormant, waiting for a once in a blue moon to join a large theme and make it the most banger game ever
i know you're not allowed to talk about your secret society, it's ok
In post 878, fferyllt wrote:
Of the unpaired gents so far, I'd most like to see Spiffeh, LavorManos and STD paired.
RCE and Fireisred at the bottom. I don't know what to do with RH9.
im a lady!
why do you townread spiffeh?
Extreme mind meld last night a la the first and so far only towngame I think I've played with Spiffeh is where it started. His ISO feels so pure. Which is not a word I use to describe my reads, but it applies here.
What are you trying to accomplish in this discussion?
the confidence with which some people are throwing out townreads off fairly shallow things is very disconcerting to me (i think probably partly a playstyle difference idk. different generations and all) and i happened to be already responding to you so i was curious if there was any more depth to the read that i was missing or some player meta knowledge due to familiarity you may have
i think the you/spiffeh thread is interesting but moreso from the other direction. i wanted to get a clearer understanding of it from this angle regardless though
im probably more interested in knowing why skitter townreads him since her entrance thoughts aligned with mine in a lot of ways but thats one place we differ
let people express reads maybe ? i doubt she would just put spiffeh as town and then never reevaluate ever
In post 1051, Gypyx wrote:
honestly think HST is town for doing this weird thing where she talks about her reads without giving any names
That’s probably idiosyncratic behavior rather than a measure in alignment. Could be right for the wrong reasons tho. I should probably go check if hst has any scum games.
oh hey a new word
good argument actually i kinda just assumed this was a 1 time thing for this game, gonna check too
Post
Post #1055 (isolation #42) » Sun Feb 11, 2024 8:11 am
Postby Gypyx »
damn bell beat me to it
well i'm not sold on this being scum indicate partly cause fuck meta reads and partly cause since there's a lack of scumgames we can't really assume that's how scum!HST would look but i certainely would like her to elaborate as to the how and why then
In post 1057, Bell wrote:
Something feels wrong with this interaction.
But I can’t place my finger on it.
kinda recovering from crippling sadness by trying to cheer myself up and stuff, think that's what you're seeing
I see.
Internet hugs.
I’m not the best player to cheer someone up due to the dysthymia, own feelings of precariousness, and my general policy that everything that is said during a game of mafia has to do with mafia.
i mean, in some way it always is right? i'll agree with that, just think lighthearted chatter has it's place too if that's what you're doing against
it's fine also, not asking you to be a therapist or anything right now, just wanna talk with people
Post
Post #1077 (isolation #49) » Sun Feb 11, 2024 8:50 am
Postby Gypyx »
In post 1076, Bell wrote:
Sure.
I'm just letting you know my boundaries and it can be exasperating to talk with me, because I'm thinking thoughts such as I wonder if gyphx is utilizing this angle, the same way, that, for example, Guiltylion might. I.e., asking for sympathy.
and while I often think this kind of openness can be AI, I also tend to go on the wrong side of it because I tend to be sympathetic and consider things like whether a player would "cross" certain boundaries or whether their own sense of ethics would stop them (and for the most part, I've always been wrong because those lines get crossed and you get surprised and in retrospect, thinking about it from the sense that it is always game time, seems to be decent at correcting for these past experiences and mistakes).
Post
Post #1082 (isolation #50) » Sun Feb 11, 2024 8:59 am
Postby Gypyx »
In post 1078, Bell wrote:
Sure, sorry if someone asked you this already, but what do you think of Skitter and FireisRed?
They seem like the most readable people right now from the simple angle of posting density, but I'm bouncing off their posts when I try to read them.
Gonna be real with you i really didn't think about skitter's alignement yet, there's this weird mental block when i'm just unenthusiastic when getting to her
as for fireis i've got an accumulation of small townpings on them but i'm kinda waiting for her to answer my last thing cause i think that'll allow me to really get an idea of her mindset
In post 878, fferyllt wrote:
Of the unpaired gents so far, I'd most like to see Spiffeh, LavorManos and STD paired.
RCE and Fireisred at the bottom. I don't know what to do with RH9.
im a lady!
why do you townread spiffeh?
Extreme mind meld last night a la the first and so far only towngame I think I've played with Spiffeh is where it started. His ISO feels so pure. Which is not a word I use to describe my reads, but it applies here.
What are you trying to accomplish in this discussion?
the confidence with which some people are throwing out townreads off fairly shallow things is very disconcerting to me (i think probably partly a playstyle difference idk. different generations and all) and i happened to be already responding to you so i was curious if there was any more depth to the read that i was missing or some player meta knowledge due to familiarity you may have
i think the you/spiffeh thread is interesting but moreso from the other direction. i wanted to get a clearer understanding of it from this angle regardless though
im probably more interested in knowing why skitter townreads him since her entrance thoughts aligned with mine in a lot of ways but thats one place we differ
let people express reads maybe ? i doubt she would just put spiffeh as town and then never reevaluate ever
Post
Post #1150 (isolation #52) » Sun Feb 11, 2024 11:10 am
Postby Gypyx »
lotta posts and some thoughts, i think i need to cool my head before being able to make sense but i kinda wanna scrutinize StD
In post 1134, Spiffeh wrote:
Firebringer has truly run the gamut for me this game and is back to a pretty solid town read, mostly because of his interaction with LLD. I also felt his explanation for his ffery scum read without being asked feels like a townie who thinks he's right and trying to get people to see his perspective. I would expect scum!FB to lean more into his trolly, unhelpful nature as it takes a lot less effort to fake that, but his transition into really fighting to have ffery on everyone's radar was comforting to me.
Cabd's post accepting ffery's dance proposal is probably his towniest its and at this point I don't think scum!Cabd would so confidently vocalize his plan to leave before Intermission if he was just going to back out of it later.
SirCakez's posts were not great but I also think Cakez would try harder to seem town if he were scum? He definitely needs to contribute more substantially at the caliber in which is he is capable because a ffery scum read and a couple of maybe town reads aren't cutting it.
Catching up I was between inviting Gypyx and skitter to be my dance partner, but feel I could be more valuable at sorting Gypyx in a hood than I would skitter. Skitter is probably more capable of meeting my expectations as scum, and while I have only played one game with scum!Gypyx over two years ago, I have some level of confidence that I can sort her in a one on one setting (even though I hate neighborhoods).
Gypyx, may I have this dance?
I accept this dance spiffeh, or something idk i didn't read the setup
In post 1078, Bell wrote:
Sure, sorry if someone asked you this already, but what do you think of Skitter and FireisRed?
They seem like the most readable people right now from the simple angle of posting density, but I'm bouncing off their posts when I try to read them.
Gonna be real with you i really didn't think about skitter's alignement yet, there's this weird mental block when i'm just unenthusiastic when getting to her
as for fireis i've got an accumulation of small townpings on them but i'm kinda waiting for her to answer my last thing cause i think that'll allow me to really get an idea of her mindset
i was kind of annoyed by it tbh but maybe i read hostility into it that wasn't intended. it's possible im doing that a lot this game i dunno
i don't really know what to say about it anyway though. i wasn't saying she isn't allowed to townread spiffeh. i just wanted her to talk more about it because 1) if she's town im interested in hearing her thoughts because she knows spiffeh better than i do and 2) if she's scum i think it's useful to have more detailed thoughts on record and 3) what she says may help me determine her alignment. it's fine i guess if she doesn't want to explain her reads. it seems like she wants to be left alone for now. idk. the thing i said about people townreading others weirdly easily wasn't especially about her
i'm sorry, the rudeness was me kinda lashing out at you, this was uncalled for
ok that's fair i just misunderstood you point, think your reaction is towny
Post
Post #1692 (isolation #56) » Tue Feb 13, 2024 9:20 am
Postby Gypyx »
In post 1683, Cabd wrote:
No, but it does make me think that if she's mafia, her support staff is also the kind that went silent recently, which is pretty much exactly one of {LLD, STD}.
The hurry up and pair then peace out thing seems a little too on the nose to be a scum response to gaining a pairing, but I don't know how many other people subscribe to my state decay theory of the game.
honestly i'm going silent kinda cause i'm not really at the best of my mafia playing capabilities rn but also i've got a dance partner i'm happy about and i trust that'll allow me to catch up on that break i'm allowing myself
also like not to WIFOM it too much but remember that as scum i'd be aware that the burden sits on me to keep efforting away