Mini Normal 2333 | woah that's a lot of 3's | It's Gypover !

[KayJayQueue]

I’m sorry everyone!!!

[Enchant]

Who the hell is Enchonker

[Gypyx]

Yeah so, a few points i would like to receive for feedback

- Obviously, the 3 goons, it definetly seemed like people were not expecting it, was it more of a failure on my part to not predict players would be used to the mafia having at least 1 PR, or was it something about the setup being too townsided for a 3 goons team, ironically giving them the win?

- Did anyone ever find use in the votes tracker associated to the votecounts? Should i do it again?

- And once again, Gypyx with failing to do flavor, i'd like any tips people have with that cause there's definetly something wrong with how i'm organized (ok and maybe going to the hospital in the middle of modding this game wasn't helping)

[KayJayQueue]

I liked the vote tracker and found it useful.

[Enchant]

I find vote tracker bad because it really shows mod is trying to help town faction with information.

[Enchant]

Mod should be unbiased btw.

[BlackStar]

GG everyone.

I almost tanked the entire game, but I’m glad we were still able to win in the end

[BlackStar]

Yeah so, a few points i would like to receive for feedback

- Obviously, the 3 goons, it definetly seemed like people were not expecting it, was it more of a failure on my part to not predict players would be used to the mafia having at least 1 PR, or was it something about the setup being too townsided for a 3 goons team, ironically giving them the win?

- Did anyone ever find use in the votes tracker associated to the votecounts? Should i do it again?

- And once again, Gypyx with failing to do flavor, i'd like any tips people have with that cause there's definetly something wrong with how i'm organized (ok and maybe going to the hospital in the middle of modding this game wasn't helping)

I thought it was really town sided, but I guess people not expecting 3 goons kind of balanced things out

[Gypyx]

That game reminded me of this masterpiece by Datisi

[Gypyx]

Yeah so, a few points i would like to receive for feedback

- Obviously, the 3 goons, it definetly seemed like people were not expecting it, was it more of a failure on my part to not predict players would be used to the mafia having at least 1 PR, or was it something about the setup being too townsided for a 3 goons team, ironically giving them the win?

- Did anyone ever find use in the votes tracker associated to the votecounts? Should i do it again?

- And once again, Gypyx with failing to do flavor, i'd like any tips people have with that cause there's definetly something wrong with how i'm organized (ok and maybe going to the hospital in the middle of modding this game wasn't helping)

I thought it was really town sided, but I guess people not expecting 3 goons kind of balanced things out

yeah, i maybe overtuned it during the review process, here's what it was originally :

Town Indecisive Rolestopper
Town Vanilla Cop
Town Lazy Reporter
Town 1-Shot Universal Backup
6 VT

Mafia Goon
Mafia Goon
Mafia Goon

[Cabd]

Another casualty of NRG's "oops all goons".

Town even had a vanilla cop again!

[Gypyx]

Another casualty of NRG's "oops all goons".

Town even had a vanilla cop again!

tell me the lore of the previous one

[Cabd]

Another casualty of NRG's "oops all goons".

Town even had a vanilla cop again!

tell me the lore of the previous one

Mini Normal 2181

[Gypyx]

This is so funny

[Dannflor]

i don't really think there was anything wrong with the setup

[Brian Skies]

Despite having 4 power roles, I did not think town had a lot of power in this game and can understand why you would want to put 3 goons. However, the number of power roles town had naturally makes one think mafia has as least one power role, even if it's a weak one. But this is all just my opinion.

I noticed the vote tracker, but I did not utilize it.

Kay, I wouldn't beat yourself up over this game. You were the most resistant to the idea of Enchant being cleared. And I probably would've screwed up in your place. This was also not a good game for me and I can understand if you just thought I was scummy.

[KayJayQueue]

Despite having 4 power roles, I did not think town had a lot of power in this game and can understand why you would want to put 3 goons. However, the number of power roles town had naturally makes one think mafia has as least one power role, even if it's a weak one. But this is all just my opinion.

I noticed the vote tracker, but I did not utilize it.

Kay, I wouldn't beat yourself up over this game. You were the most resistant to the idea of Enchant being cleared. And I probably would've screwed up in your place. This was also not a good game for me and I can understand if you just thought I was scummy.

I didn’t really think you were that scummy but Hu and Dann made it nearly impossible for me to think it was Enchant at the end lol The last couple days were extremely stressful for me trying to figure out the game. I’ve learned I’m not good at elo lol

[Brian Skies]

You were my strongest townread this game. But the setup discussion also made it impossible for me to think it was Enchant.

[Gypyx]

idk, i feel like i'm seeing a pattern with scum frustration that i'm not sure how to really resolve

anyways, the vote tracker was townsided but that kinda was the point? More raw info opens up other avenues of play, imo it maybe would have to be accounted for in setup balance (kinda wasn't here) but it's a really interesting tool and will lead to better play from everyone

[SmileyDude1]

ggs to the scum team, well played

[SmileyDude1]

Despite having 4 power roles, I did not think town had a lot of power in this game and can understand why you would want to put 3 goons. However, the number of power roles town had naturally makes one think mafia has as least one power role, even if it's a weak one. But this is all just my opinion.

I noticed the vote tracker, but I did not utilize it.

Kay, I wouldn't beat yourself up over this game. You were the most resistant to the idea of Enchant being cleared. And I probably would've screwed up in your place. This was also not a good game for me and I can understand if you just thought I was scummy.

+1

This pretty much sums up my thoughts.

[Gypyx]

reposting PT's since they don't stand out too much

private topics

Mafia Hideout - viewtopic.php?t=92447 --- released in (expired on 2024-04-26 14:45:32)
Mod PT - viewtopic.php?t=92421
Dead PT - viewtopic.php?p=14137233#p14137233

[SmileyDude1]

From the Mod PT:

just tried it 2 more times and got Random Nurse and Blackstar.

Game is solved, you can thank me later.

lol

If only I had followed the RNG

[Hu Tao]

That sucks. I feel like most people would’ve made the wrong decision there then.

But everyone can blame me lol

Not your fault, I would have done the same thing.

[Hu Tao]

Yeah so, a few points i would like to receive for feedback

- Obviously, the 3 goons, it definetly seemed like people were not expecting it, was it more of a failure on my part to not predict players would be used to the mafia having at least 1 PR, or was it something about the setup being too townsided for a 3 goons team, ironically giving them the win?

- Did anyone ever find use in the votes tracker associated to the votecounts? Should i do it again?

- And once again, Gypyx with failing to do flavor, i'd like any tips people have with that cause there's definetly something wrong with how i'm organized (ok and maybe going to the hospital in the middle of modding this game wasn't helping)

In retrospect I only realized that vanilla cop was mostly a negative role for us. But I wouldn't have thought that without knowing the setup. I guess if Brian was checked instead of enchant it would have worked out for town though. Came down to luck on who was checked really.

I enjoy the vote count tracker but if it's too much effort I'd say skip it.