Open 913 - This Game Started as an April Fools' Joke - Day 4

[Black]

bzzzzzt incorrect

[Black]

People accuse me of being performative all the time when I'm town. It's just how I post

[Black]

Unfortunately I think you are town so I'm just hoping you can find me as town as well

[Black]

I have another theory but I'm gonna sit on it for a bit and I'll explain why later

For the record this was me thinking someone was trying to frame me. I didn't want to reveal it at the time because I wanted everyone to check in. I figured scum would try to frame me but so far Daisy is really the only one who has acknowledged it, so I'm assuming Drew died for other reasons

[OopsieDaisy]

My gut still tells me Black's opening post today was performative. Drew was pretty sure Black was scum so I kinda feel if I were town!Black I'd be suspecting Drew was shot to frame me compared with a "that's so weird, why did Drew die" type of post.

What makes Black's posting there performative and mine not?

And since then, Black giving me town points for making a somewhat obvious point (that happened to paint Black in a better light) felt a little like it could be from scum hoping to want to keep me on side.

Yeaa I felt this a bit hence why I asked.

@Daisy re. your point in 855 I don't see Black pushing for the BR lim as clearing her, because it's relatively riskfree as scum. Either town BR gets limmed, or town ming or town Moros do.

The risk of some suspicion on Black after BR flips town (which isn't a big risk, as townies pushing a mislim on D1 happens often enough) is balanced by the fact that if Black were to be limmed we would definitely have limmed ming or Moros afterwards out of suspicion she was deflecting away from them.

Ahh so you're saying the risk of Black getting heat could've been worth it because on a flip associatives take us elsewhere and get a mislim for mafia through for basically free. It still doesn't feel worth it to me though. Like it still feels like a waste of effort because as scum you can just let the ming wagon go through and cause less of a fuss. I don't think letting yourself get limmed to create stronger mislim chances in the future is super worth it with the possibility of cops and vigs lurking around.

[experience]

I was SK recently. SKs want to scum hunt. I lost my game because I couldn't find scum and kept killing townies

i remember that game.

[halfasleep]

I'm interested in your townread on experience. You describe it as a gutread but how strong is it?

his iso just looks good to me. his thought progression in general looks uninformed in ways that are at least difficult to fake. for example, with his posts today, i think scum would be more cautious about openly jumping to the assumption that we have an SK over a vig.
i guess it's as strong a read as i've got in this game. which is to say, not nearly as solid as i'd like.

[imaginality]

I have another theory but I'm gonna sit on it for a bit and I'll explain why later

For the record this was me thinking someone was trying to frame me. I didn't want to reveal it at the time because I wanted everyone to check in. I figured scum would try to frame me but so far Daisy is really the only one who has acknowledged it, so I'm assuming Drew died for other reasons

That's a plausible thought progression as town. Reconsidering my read on you.

[Black]

I just realized Thomith hasn't posted in a week

[Alianna]

Elements has requested replacement.

[light_ganski]

a problem with SK spec rn is that the moros and CSF kills make sense coming from either an SK or a vig

also it seems improbable that *neither* scum or SK shot me last night if there's both but SK might want scum dead more than cop?

[Black]

I think in the current gamestate an SK would be trying to hit scum. There's still two scum left that they have to deal with and leaving the cop alive could help them with that

[OopsieDaisy]

I just realized Thomith hasn't posted in a week

Yea I'd love to hear from him

Elements has requested replacement.

:[

[light_ganski]

I think in the current gamestate an SK would be trying to hit scum. There's still two scum left that they have to deal with and leaving the cop alive could help them with that

that makes sense

[Alianna]

Thomith is being prodded.

[Alianna]

Thomith has requested replacement.

[OopsieDaisy]

crickey

[Alianna]

Enchant replaces Elements.

[OopsieDaisy]

actually has experience commented on teams at all? if not hey experience same question as im asking to thomith it creates good content trust

i did bring up agreeing with imag on possible teams.
tho rn, given ming flipped town, i need to re-evaluate

any progress on the re-evaluation?

[Enchant]

I heard this game is for fools so i couldn't miss this out.

[experience]

actually has experience commented on teams at all? if not hey experience same question as im asking to thomith it creates good content trust

i did bring up agreeing with imag on possible teams.
tho rn, given ming flipped town, i need to re-evaluate

any progress on the re-evaluation?

not really, except that i've decided that it's probably just a coincidence that moros was killed the same night that elements said she would vig it.
and now i'm no longer so sure that i can clear her from being sk.
tho for mafia, i am feeling pretty lost with the person who i'm most likely to vote rn being thomith

[experience]

tho it is notable that thomith was the first to consider sk existing

[Black]

VOTE: halfasleep

This iso leaves more to be desired

[Enchant]

Can someone catch up me

[OopsieDaisy]

Can someone catch up me

N0 ended with two leading wagons, Ming (flipped town) and Moros (flipped town). Then Black led a late push onto Black Ranger (flipped town) who became the lim for the following day.

N1 the day was mostly theorising about the previous night, with the Ming flip being seen as the best flip for information by a mile, so we did that.

There have been two kills each night so we're assuming sk or vig, kills are vig-like but it can always just be an sk hiding as a vig.

Light claimed cop on N1 and was not killed that night, got a mafia ping on CSF who was shot by the vig/sk and confirmed as mafia. Light did not die that night tho, and it was revealed today by Light that she's a one-shot cop.

Currently there doesn't seem to be a strong consensus as to where we should be pushing today. A couple people have said I'm a good lim, a couple Thomith. I'm waiting to hear more from quieter slots but I'm concerned I'm wrong about one of my townreads.