Wow, I forgot we also had a one-shot bulletproof townie. Yeah, at least one of bv/Natalie is scum, and I don't rule out the possibility of both (although doc is a risky claim at this point that could easily be countered by a real one).
In post 124, Kdub wrote:Thinking about it more, one of bv/Natalie almost has to be lying. There is no way the scum don't have a RB in this setup, given what we already know or can infer. If Natalie really is a doc and bv prevented her protect last night, you have to ask why wouldn't the mafia have roleblocked bv?
Maybe bv is the scum roleblocker.
In post 124, Kdub wrote:
Alternatively, Natalie why didn't you protect bv?
I didn't believe his claim. I didn't want to lynch him, but I figured he would die anyway if he really was town.
Kdub wrote:Wow, I forgot we also had a one-shot bulletproof townie. Yeah, at least one of bv/Natalie is scum, and I don't rule out the possibility of both (although doc is a risky claim at this point that could easily be countered by a real one).
Natalie wrote:What about Klazam? Why isn't he lying?
We don't know the details of what info he has yet, so I'm waiting to hear from him. However, independent of Klazam's info, do you believe a 9-player setup can plausibly have a one-shot BP townie, a doc, and a jailkeeper?
In post 120, Natalie wrote:Whoa whoa whoa get your votes the hell off me.
I'm the doctor. The "First Aid Clown" to be exact. I protected Majiffy last night, but I guess it didn't work since bv jailed me.
I don't know what Klazam is reporting, but my flavor did mention that everyone perceives me as scary, but I don't know if that's a hidden miller or if Klazam is straight up lying.
That fact that bv is still alive makes me think might be a scum roleblocker.
VOTE: bv310
Salamence20 wrote:Gut is telling me Natalie/KDub.
VOTE: KDub
Second scum is right here.
So you protected an unclaimed player over a claimed power role?
Also, if Klazam is telling the truth, this means that I was blocked last night. I can see JK + Scum RB a hell of a lot easier than I can see Cop+Doc+JK+RB, especially in an OGML setup.
Yes, because Majiffy was obvtown and your claim was fishy.
How would Klazam telling the truth affect whether or not you were blocked? If you were blocked, that means I wasn't blocked and Majiffy should've lived.
In post 130, Natalie wrote:Yes, because Majiffy was obvtown and your claim was fishy.
How would Klazam telling the truth affect whether or not you were blocked? If you were blocked, that means I wasn't blocked and Majiffy should've lived.
If I was blocked, then you were free to NK Majiffy, is what you mean. If I wasn't blocked, and you were blocked, that means his soft-claimed investigation would have failed.
In post 130, Natalie wrote:Yes, because Majiffy was obvtown and your claim was fishy.
How would Klazam telling the truth affect whether or not you were blocked? If you were blocked, that means I wasn't blocked and Majiffy should've lived.
If I was blocked, then you were free to NK Majiffy, is what you mean. If I wasn't blocked, and you were blocked, that means his soft-claimed investigation would have failed.
What are you talking about? Majiffy died, so obviously I didn't perform the kill. I'm the doctor, and you're scum.
Now, I don't know natalie, and the "you aren't liked thing" is a bit odd, but claiming a doc while there is a claimed JK around and a flipped bulletproof is not the most common choice for scum, I'd say. Further, it would seem something a mod would put into a game, doesn't it?
In all his randomness, I think salamence might be right.
vote kdub
Surrender, imagine and of course wear something nice.
So let's get this straight. We have a claimed doctor and a claimed jailkeeper, we've already had a bulletproof townie flip, and you guys are just fine with that? What combination of scum powers can possibly balance that on top of an innocent child and maybe more?
In post 143, Kdub wrote:Nice case you've got there Salamence.
So let's get this straight. We have a claimed doctor and a claimed jailkeeper, we've already had a bulletproof townie flip, and you guys are just fine with that? What combination of scum powers can possibly balance that on top of an innocent child and maybe more?
There is no way bv and Natalie are both town.
This is bull. This whole post breaths scum who knows what's actually going on. Same with his earlier posts in reaction to natalie's claim.
Surrender, imagine and of course wear something nice.
