Newbie 2129 - Postgame

[Cook]

that’s game. that’s the end of it all

[Cook]

the very last hammer in a newbie

and town fucking dropped the ball

[Cook]

god damn it i should have trusted you smiley you were posting way way more

[Cook]

((

[SmileyDude1]

*Sigh*, yeah my reads were not good this game.

I take responsibility for the loss here

[SmileyDude1]

GG, Hold

Well played on your part

[Cook]

i had a thought while we were in elo

you can sort of scumhunt with votes in elo

if someone votes someone else and scum does NOT quickhammer, then either you are voting scum or scum is voting you

[Cook]

so scum, reasonably, cannot vote first if both town players trust each other enough

[TheHoldSteady]

i had a thought while we were in elo

you can sort of scumhunt with votes in elo

if someone votes someone else and scum does NOT quickhammer, then either you are voting scum or scum is voting you

so scum, reasonably, cannot vote first if both town players trust each other enough

right. the reason i held off on voting was because i knew as soon as i did one of you would know i was scum. so i was avoiding giving one of you the 50/50.

[Alianna]

4.FINAL

Votecount 4.FINAL

Cook (ELIMINATED): SmileyDude1, TheHoldSteady

Not Voting (1): Cook

With 3 players alive, it took 2 votes to secure an elimination.

[Alianna]

Cook has been eliminated. She was a

Vanilla Townie

.

At this point in the game, nothing can prevent the town from being eliminated. SmileyDude1,

Vanilla Townie

, is endgamed. TheHoldSteady,

Mafia Goon

, survives and wins.

Congratulations to the mafia team of TheHoldSteady and humaneatingmonkey for winning the last newbie game in Mafiascum history!

[Alianna]

Role Assignments

Cook (formerly flowrbucket, patchwork, CCGeek) -

Vanilla Townie

MagicalSteve -

Vanilla Townie

TheHoldSteady -

Mafia Goon

SmileyDude1 -

Vanilla Townie

humaneatingmonkey (formerly SevenEyes) -

Mafia Roleblocker

SzmarzLeek (formerly KawaiiMikuStan) -

Vanilla Townie

Merlyn (formerly Civil Scum, HighPrincessErinys) -

Vanilla Townie

iamveryhappy -

Town Doctor

Doctor Drew (formerly The Bulge, brassherald) -

Town Cop

Night 1 Actions

iamveryhappy uses doctor ability on The Bulge.
The Bulge uses cop ability on TheHoldSteady.

SevenEyes uses roleblocker ability on The Bulge.
TheHoldSteady uses factional kill on iamveryhappy.

Night 1 Resolution

iamveryhappy dies.

The Bulge receives the message: "Your investigation on TheHoldSteady failed and returned no result."

Night 2 Actions

Doctor Drew uses cop ability on humaneatingmonkey.

humaneatingmonkey uses roleblocker ability on flowrbucket.
humaneatingmonkey uses factional kill on Doctor Drew.

Night 2 Resolution

Doctor Drew dies.
Doctor Drew receives the message: "Your target, humaneatingmonkey, is aligned with the

mafia

."

Night 3 Actions

TheHoldSteady kills SzmarzLeek.

Night 3 Resolution

SzmarzLeek dies.

[Alianna]

Private Topics

Mafia PT
Spectator PT
Mod PT

[Alianna]

This thread is now open for postgame discussion.

[DkKoba]

szarmrzleek.. what sites have you played on for mafia? just curious

[Doctor Drew]

Best repp in ever......conversely, worst repp in ever lol.

[Merlyn]

*Sigh*, yeah my reads were not good this game.

I take responsibility for the loss here

lol this was a team loss, we all share blame. This many rep outs certainly doesn't help

But above all, the loss is due to some excellent work from the scum team! GG all, and congrats to two very deserving folk in THS and HEM

Very cool to have played for a brief time in the last Newbie Game

[humaneatingmonkey]

everything i said was bullshit btw

[humaneatingmonkey]

THS, congrats on winning the game.

[Cook]

Best repp in ever......conversely, worst repp in ever lol.

who and who lmao

[Cook]

i love how the cops collectively found the scumteam and just were too roleblocked or too dead to do anything about it

[Doctor Drew]

Best repp in ever......conversely, worst repp in ever lol.

who and who lmao

Me lol

[Cook]

yeah good cop check though

[Alianna]

i love how the cops collectively found the scumteam and just were too roleblocked or too dead to do anything about it

Yeah, was sad.
Every night action in this game was actually mechanically optimal. N1 doctor healed cop, cop checked scum, scum roleblocked cop and killed doctor. N2 cop checked scum again, scum killed cop.

[Cook]

i think iamvh could have been a little more subtle with the doctor. that might have kept town PRs alive for a bit longer.

also town's dayplay was not helped by the fact the town as a whole had to read

nineteen separate people

over the course of the game.

four of those occupied mafia slots.
fifteen of them occupied town slots.

there was ultimately a lot more consistency on the mafia side than the town side