Newbie 03 - Game Over

[Kerplunk]

vote: max22

Welcome to mafiascum! (shamelessly stolen from MeMe)

[Kerplunk]

unvote: max22

And all of sudden I'm one vote away from being lynched. This is very dangerous, because if I'm innocent, the mafia in this game can vote for me and I'm lynched. Therefore I urge one of you to unvote me.

Max, if you didn't vote for me because I'm suspicious but because the mod wrote the roles poorly, why don't you unvote me? I find that a bit suspicious, therefore:

FoS: max22

(Finger of Suspicion, if you think one is suspicious but not enough for a vote).

Also, Stimpy, you placed the dangerous vote on me without even saying why. It's always best to post your motivation when you vote for someone, especially if you vote for someone who then will be one vote away from being lynched. I want to hear reasons, why you voted for me so for now only a

FoS: Stimpy

.

[Kerplunk]

Please clarify your votes on me, Stimpy and max. Did I do anything suspicious?

[Kerplunk]

vote: Stimpy

, for not telling why he voted for me.

And

FoS: bloojay

. For not not unvoting his random vote, while he doesn't think I'm suspicious. Random votes are useless now.

[Kerplunk]

Talitha - She's acting all town-like and hasn't done anything suspicious, except voting for a townie, which resultated in lynching. But I did that too, so that's not a good reason. Still, it wouldn't surprise if she was scum, but we have two scum so we can first lnch the other. See no reason to lynch her.

max22 - Like Talitha said, most active newbie, good ideas. I think no scum.

QX - If I was newbie and mafia I think I should have voted for Stimpy, when he had 3 votes and thus getting him lynched.

nard054 - Was on the 'bandwagon' for Stimpy. I feel like he's the mostly likely scum.

Just my two cents.

Mod?

Was the mafia able to communicate with each other before the game started, really would like to know that.

And there's still a cop among us. He should figure out for himself if he has enough information to lynch a scum via logic. Don't come out, though if you haven't, because there's no doc anymore who can save you from a kill.

[Kerplunk]

FoS: Kerplunk

for asking whether or not the mafia was allowed to communicate with each other before the game started. You'd think an experienced player would know something like this, and it could all just be a cover up.

It started with a day, so basically you'd think that the mafia wasn't able to communicate with each other. But I could imagine that the mod would let the mafia PM each other before the game started.

So it's come down to QX, Talitha and nard. Still very afraid that Talitha is scum. If Talitha isn't scum, then QX or nard are scum. If Talitha is scum, then QX isn't and nard is. So, with my logic (if max is indeed the Cop), nard *has* to be scum.

vote: nard054

.

And QX random voted for nard054. This could mean both things, but my gut says that Talitha is the remaining mafia.

[Kerplunk]

unvote: nard054

. But maybe Talitha is scum and if we lynch QX and QX is scum, it would come down to a 3-player endgame. We surely wouldn't lynch Talitha. So it must be nard. We lynch nard and Talitha has won. Then again, Talitha don't has to be scum.

Arrgh.. difficult.

vote: nard054

. Because QX didn't voted the lynching vote for Stimpy yesterday.

[Kerplunk]

I just read my post, and it is kinda hard to understand. Sorry about that.

nard, but if your not scum, why did Talitha vote for QX and not for you? Scum voting for scum? Maybe Talitha is taking a gambit, but I don't think so.

confirm vote: nard054

.

[Kerplunk]

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO..!

Very good job, QX and Talitha. That's was a very smart move, Talitha to vote for your fellow comrad. I had my doubts, but I guess I'm still not paranoid enough.

Sorry, nard054.

BTW, fun games, these short ones.

*goes off and signs up for another immediately*