I think Juls was right the first time.
About Juls's vote on Spyrex: As my predecessor pointed out, it is a bit fishy for a doublevoter to suggest coordinating a masslynch, especially post 49. however, he revealed his ability to doublevote, so he can no longer use it to break the plan for the scumteam. I consider that a small town-tell for Spyrex.
The masspurge is a bad idea though, for several reasons:
1. The scum can probably daytalk, given the listing for a "Still, Small Voice" ability
2.
3. The scum probably have the ability to make a kill.
4. The doublevoter ability, luxomancy, and maybe other abilities.
Even trying to get, say, 4 or more purges in one day may not be a good idea. The scum may find it worthwhile to mess with the incanting at that point. I suspect we won't be able to purge more than 1 scum on any given day.
However, I think we should try to get 2, or maybe 3, subjects purged each day to increase our chances of hitting scum and to remove suspicious townies. This will require planning and holding everyone accountable for using common sense.
I don't think Moychandiser is a cult recruiter, because it doesn't appear to change the target's win condition. If someone receives a piece of Moychandise, then I think they should consider claiming that fact so that we know a Moychandiser exists.Jahudo wrote:It looks like the Moychandiser role is a cult recruiter
I think we shouldn't worry about the reporter or Moychandiser for now. They may exist, but neither should impact anything right now. Note that *claims* don't trigger the reporter's wincon.
I know, I just said we shouldn't worry about it. But I want to know. It would make the reporter survivor-ish.
LOLSpyreX wrote:Porkens-gate
I guess I'm old too.
Jazzmyn, Spaceballs is awesome, as long as you've seen Star Wars IV (though it might contain spoilers for V and/or VI.) The zombies are references to a different (completed, I hope) game. The wizard stuff is, I think, just Spyrex having style.
Did you mean VP and Zoraster? This seems like an out-of-nowhere comment.SpyreX wrote:To be quasi-fair it WAS in response to a prod as per the mod.
That doesn't change the fact that I wouldn't cry if we double string them up.
Notes on people:
VP:
Have you ever been town?
You haven't posted many reads on people (though you aren't the only one.) Would you, please?
Porkens and Rhinox:
In this context (post 53), I don't find his playing the newbie card scummy. This game has some potentially complicated rules. Rhinox looks like he's throwing mud at Porkens. And later, at VP/Zoraster.
The Orbots:
I don't really agree that being a hydra makes you more vulnerable to attacks, but I don't find that line relevant to evaluating your alignment.
Sotty7:
Sorry, Serialclergyman and Spyrex, but I don't find Sotty's post 67 scummy at all. Serialclergyman, do you find "cautiousness" scummy? How strong a scumtell is it?
I don't like to see an unremovable vote on someone when there isn't much good reason to suspect them. But it doesn't mean that Spyrex is scum.
The Spy/Serial link bit is weak. There was no genuine pressure on Spyrex. But it looks like sincere scumhunting on Sotty's part. And her follow through gives me a town feeling.
This paragraph makes me suspect Serial a little.SerialClergyman wrote:Honestly guys, this case is making itself. The only reason I'm still typing is because I'm trying to break this keyboard before the warranty is due. There should be no need for any further action except incanting Sotty.
So does this paragraph. Yes, the theory was reactionary and OMGUSy, and Spyrex wasn't under pressure. If you're a townie, Serial, why are you making a bargain to get someone whom you suspect off your back? You should care more about finding out whether Sotty is scum or not, and purging her if she is. This paragraph only makes sense if you believe Sotty to be town and therefore you're worried about her believing you to be scum.SerialClergyman wrote:I'm going to give you an out. Will you admit now that your theory was a little bit reactionary, a little bit OMGUSy and in the cold light of day he probably wasn't under the sort of pressure you initially thought he was?
Jazzmyn 163 is not much of an attempt to respond to Jahudo calling her out for not scumhunting. I expect more.
I'd like you to answer the same question.SerialClergyman wrote:O Great Wizard Spyrex, are you still on board the Sotty wagon out of choice or apathy?
I think it was SC / Spy scummm.SpyreX wrote:Its a little from column a, little from b. I'm not sold on the whole SC / Porkens are scummm business.
I don't like Zoraster 177. I haven't made up my mind regarding the recent Zoraster/Nachomamma/Mighty Orbots issue. Zoraster doesn't look great in it, but he's not screaming scum either. I'd like Troll to comment on it when he can. I'm also a little burned out from this long reading/writing session.