xRECKONERx wrote:I never said it was a case. The main point of my belief that you are the SK is that it's not VPB, and there are plenty of strange occurrences which have me scratching my head. Mafia don't have a kill... seriously. There has to be a SK. C.C came out and counterclaimed ani D1, right?
Typical SK play - counterclaim the vig.
No mafia-kill theory seems very unlikable. Even more so from my point of view (more on that later). Also:
a) No, I counterclaimed him during D2.
b) About the bolded part... What? That kind of play makes sense for a Serial Killer only in LyLo or other thing like that. During D2 it would be suicide, not a typical SK play. What's more, you even agreed with me on that statement in your post 360:
xRECKONERx wrote:Col.Cathart wrote:What can I say? I was probably even more surprised by that flip than anyone else. I definitely wouldn't come out to CC ani, if I wouldn't be a vig myself, as his claim wouldn't blow away my cover in any way. I really thought he was lying.
Point taken.
Moving on...
Or, based on the kill order I explained earlier, I likely won't be able to kill tonight since I believe I am either 50% or my kills get priority only on odd nights or something like that. I didn't know ani didn't kill MMM... I've been operating under that belief for most of the past few days.
Ok, so let's go back to your theory. Now you know, that it was not ani who killed MMM, as he tried to kill Kerristar. So, if by your theory there is no scum-kill... Then who killed MMM? It wasn't ani, it wasn't me, and it wasn't you. So who, if not scum? Your theory holds no water, and that's why I think it's bullshit.
He... was? My interactions with Wrex didn't quite turn out that way.
He did a friendly bodyslam with my Shepard, told other Krogan to shut the fuck up and help Shepard with anything he wants, and really helped with Grunt's initiation.
Also, Jack is a romance option in the game, who became a psychopathic killer because it was outside of her realm of control... experiments were done on her and turned her that way. Thane is a killer/assassin by trade.
Still, a psychopatic killer (and the one that even in the game wanted to pulverize Miranda) with a pro-town role. And Thane retired from being assassin right before joining Shepard. He also swore his loyalty to him so it would against all of his moral codes to betray him.
I can swing the ball back all day in terms of ME2 flavor. We're going here into 'outguessing the mod' territory again though, so I suggest stopping this branch of conversation, unless you really want to continue it.
Fuck you.
I shot Fate
you fucker. This is pissing me off now.
Please, refrain yourself from any personal insults. This is only a game.
This isn't important. From a scum point of view, Kerristar didn't suspect me.
Last post of Kerristar before his death:
(...)
With the amount of killing roles in this game I find both Fate and VP's roles believable, their play also supports it. One of xReckx or Colonel is lying about their vig role,
more likely xReckx because his lying about his vig ability plus the 0% shot he keeps mentioning just looks like he is trying to hide behind the bastardization of the game. Whoa. Neighborizer...with xReckx? I can easily see Bv having chosen to "neighborize" his scumpartner, and they'll probably call their scumtopic their 'neighbor" topic.
BV doesn't even have to actually be a neighborizer, he can just use his quicktopic to cover for it, and the fact that its called neighborizer helps provide a sense of different factions, essentially distancing from xReckx.
Looks like he did suspect you after all. I missed that earlier. Re-reads are gold.
Doombunny wasn't attacking me, I just thought he was scummy (this was reflected in the votes I placed each day as well).
Mkay, I'm not going to argue with that. Doombunny didn't die though, so there is a room left for speculation, especially from my point of view.
Limerickx seemed like an outside chance for under-the-radar scum... and apparently you agreed, Mister Serial Killer.
Again, not going to argue with that, except that Serial Killer part, which I'm arguing with you since the very beginning of this day.
Kerristar's role
didn't make sense
as a town role in the grand scheme of things
Elaborate. I never doubted his role, and it was perfectly fine with his earlier play, especially the fullclaim vs nameclaim debate. Add to that his last post before death, and... Something starts to stink here with that kill...
and Fate was obvscum after the botched claim.
Tell me about it. I wanted his death since D4.
Nothing I did makes sense from a scum perspective.
As you can see, at some points it have. Other points are not provable (like those two failed attempts on Doombunny or who actually killed Limerick [or Fate for that matter]).
Preview EDIT:
Actually... Hold on. This is Limerick's
ISO. Check his last posts before death. Who was his last suspect? Yup, you guessed it. So there was a reason for Reckscum to kill him after all.
[b]Mini 934[/b] is [b]over![/b] Thanks to everyone participating.
[i]What the hell? That Colonel guy was awesome.[/i] - Fate