Mafia 48: Himalayan Mafia - Game over!

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Well, I haven't finished my re-read yet and it appears I won't finish it on time, so I might as well lay the HAMMAH! on.

HAMMAH!

-vote: Mr. Flay

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

What? The deadline is like a couple of minutes away. Might as well have a bit of fun.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Yeah, 'cause this type of game tends to have dramatic revelations and momentum shifts at the last moment.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Fritzler and me, you mean.

Anyway, I need to finish reading the thread and we need to ask ourselves why Fuldu got killed. I mean, he wasn't voting for Mr. Flay.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

I apologize to the town for my inactivity.

I personally think there might be much to gain from nightkill analysis at this point. It may give us significant insight into the workings of the mind of our final scum. I also personally think Lloyd is our final scum. He's also not the kind of guy I see throwing his scumbuddies under the bus, although I could be mistaken in that regard.

Vote: Lloyd

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Well, I took a nice good look at the last two nightkills. The most important detail here is really that both Fuldu and Dead Rikimaru didn't look all that innocent.

Fuldu cast suspicion on Mr. Flay, but wasn't on his lynch. Not a particularly good voting record. Very suspicious of creampuffeater.

Dead Rikimaru, again not a particularly good voting record, but did vote for Mr. Flay, a vote that could be seen as important, but just as easily as throwing his partner under the bus if you argue it correctly. Wasn't particularly suspicious of anyone.

What I'm thinking here is that creampuffeater was very unlikely to avoid the lynch with Fuldu still alive. Ignoring all the WIFOM, creampuffeaterscum would absolutely be in a better position, with a vocal opponent gone. Any other scum would be down a vocal opponent of someone else and down the possibility that they both would be lynched due to Fuldu's strong suspicions. Even if this nightkill would lead to a creampuffeaterlynch, that lynch was likely to happen even without this nightkill and this nightkill is taking away a possible follow-up in the form of a Fuldulynch. All in all, I think this most certainly is a real argument against creampuffeater.

Dead Rikimaru getting killed is not as helpful, but I don't see him as someone a more experienced player would kill. Dead Rikimaru was lynchable. I really don't see Fritzler or Yosarian2 sending in this kill.

I'm really thinking it's creampuffeater and if it's not, Lloyd. They're the only two people who I can really see as having sent in those kills.

Unvote, vote: creampuffeater

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Or we could just lynch cpescum? That would work too.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Okay, MBL, assuming I'm scum, can you concretely state how I would benefit from killing Fuldu? Framing him would seem unnecessary, I mean, he's doing a fine job of framing himself. Would lynching creampuffeater, Lloyd and Fuldu not seem the easiest way to a win? Please answer this question taking into account that I was not seen as particularly suspicious at the time of the Fuldukill.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Framing him = creampuffeater

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

I will point out that:

1. If Fuldu, a vocal opponent of creampuffeater, had lived, creampuffeater would have very highs odds of being one of the four final lynches.
2. If this had occured and cpe had come up as town, Fuldu would be seen in a very bad light, considering his push on cpe right before the deadline when Flay was lynched, despite having expressed suspicion of Flay previously.
3. Scum still had to survive 4 lynches at the time of the Fuldukill. Making creampuffeater look bad is not something I'd see as a priority taking that into account.

I may have misjudged the amount of suspicion me(broomhead) was under due to me replacing.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Vote: Creampuffeater

, it's time to lynch us some scum.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Somone hammah.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

I'm not worried about that, as I'm pretty sure cpe is the final scum. I don't feel like going through a lot of trouble for nothing.

Also, I'll be gone Tuesday-Saturdayish, so I'd rather just finish it.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Lynching people while they're away for no good reason = bad.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

No, MBL was.