Mafia 75: Return of the Mafia! TOWN WINS (really late)

[RossWilliam]

hey everyone. Started reading the thread, but I got to page five before realizing i wasn't taking anything in. I'm packed through with a head cold, but I'll get my thoughts of the game so far to all of you........................eventually.

[RossWilliam]

Random voting once official strategerie has started can be awkward and unwieldy though. Sometimes a scumtell, sometimes just awkward and unwieldy.

[RossWilliam]

i think the Charity votes are kinda silly. I don't think she's scum, she's probably just lazy. oEJo, if you aren't scum, you should have known better than to support a foolish notion like that without providing your own feedback. It's like showing your work on a math test, you don't do it, the teacher thinks you cheated.

vote: oEJo

[RossWilliam]

the wikipedia contains all this information

[RossWilliam]

armlx, could you maybe reword post 367? It kinda went over my head. I thought I was on my out of the noob catergory, but apparently I've got one foot in the door. I'm finding this game really hard to digest, and most attempts to reread usually end in skimming. I'll figure it out soon, though, no worries. I always get a little overwhelmed when I replace in

[RossWilliam]

i don't see the dubiousness. He's not saying much at all in that post, and it's pretty generic stuff. Not much thought in it, you know?

[RossWilliam]

ah, I see your point BM. But even so, he's new to mafia. New people are often in a state of trying real hard not to piss anybody off. This can often make them seem on the fence about many things.

[RossWilliam]

I think the fact that Imat FoS and didn't vote is enough to make his post legit. He probably agreed with what was said, but was still too unsure to fully commit, and therefore FoSed. If he voted, it would be a totally different story

[RossWilliam]

unvote, vote: Nano

The fact that he's a lurker is the straw that broke the camel's back, metaphorically. Scum enough to lynch, or at least pressure.

[RossWilliam]

unvote, vote: tlp

Clumsy play there, buddy. looks like it's costing you

[RossWilliam]

if your willing to claim sp free;y, your role isn't that special? I'm confused. Maybe I'm still newbie. What's a role fisher? is it a scumtell?

[RossWilliam]

ah. well if you're dangling it like so, I expect they'll deduce that you're not a power role. I don't see the point

[RossWilliam]

unvote, vote: Matt_S

willing to give you the pressure you want

[RossWilliam]

sorry, I was kinda M.I.A a little bit. for some reason this game goes over my head a little bit. I'm having trouble digesting it all

[RossWilliam]

I'm choosing just to trust those who have played with him before, and assume he's town.

[RossWilliam]

unvote, vote: TSN

The difference between TSN and I is that I'm a townie bandwagoner and he's a scummy one.

[RossWilliam]

I agree with Anti.

unvote

We should make an informal policy or something saying that every post with a vote in it should have at least a paragraph of reasoning. Minimal posts should be regarded as scumtells.

[RossWilliam]

wow, TSN, demanding much. Anti's sig can stay as it is until an admin of the site has issue with it. Farside's not executing her complaint in the correct matter.

Lloyd, i think you're being nitpicky. BM's intention is clear, even though his word choice is not.

[RossWilliam]

I think a meta of killa and a meta of rosso would reveal the same thing, that they both have irrational play styles.

unvote

[RossWilliam]

i feel like it's totally he-said she-said and i don't know what to believe. i'm leaning towards farside.