Mafia 75: Return of the Mafia! TOWN WINS (really late)

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Unvote

the vote from QuickBen at least until I catch up

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Unvote

the vote from QuickBen at least until I catch up

Shadowlurker is that you ?

And how many more players need to be replaced ?

Are you calling me a lurker? I just replaced QuickBen and the vote simply got transferred, so I unvoted, that's all.

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

SL is a banned player.

O.K. and no I'm iaretheman, but after weeks of inactivity, a very annoying computer dump, a new e-mail address, and a forgotten password I just decided to start over.

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Now that I have finally caught up, I'm going to say a few things on some of the topics that are still being discussed.

The Matt_S BW makes no sense to me... nothing he has done is overly scummy
Imat made a simply stupid decision to call a joke suspicious and FoS Rosso, although I do believe Rosso's stupid

kill

instead of a vote is annoying
Thenextepisode is a lurker, but I want more from him before I do anything about that (*hint*that means post more and join the conversation instead of cryptic posts*hint*)
Rosso is stupid,but I don't believe he has done anything scummy either
I do understand the nono votes, but I think TLP has done more, so...

Vote: TLP

for his vague posts and trying to jump on a BW with no stated reason, and then jumping off because of pressure. I take that as trying to avoid a BW on himself. And who said anything about a Day 1 Deadline yet?

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Sorry, I have to share a computer and could not get on for a while, but BM has valid points about Rosso, if you read my points after I caught up on reading you can see that I thought what he had done is simply stupid, but maybe he slipped once and is doing it more now to try and convince us he is just like that and isn't mafia. Anyways, I see Imat's point that TLP hasn't done anything overly scummy, so for now,

Unvote: TLP

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Yes! New page! Quick reply is back on the screen!

The 1 interesting thing I've noticed from that chart so far is antithesis has yet to make a vote.

I am waiting for someone to make a rational, well thought case against someone else. So far, all I have seen is copious amounts of 'I think you are scummy for miniscule reason X' sort of posts and a bunch of wagon hopping. To wit I can make neither heads nor tails of where a majority of people stand.

That, plus I think it is entirely possible scum might be encouraging this behavior so as to make it easier for them to hide behind this monolithic wall of inane nonsense.

You have a point, scumtells haven't come out, but I haven't seen you posting very much, and we need more serious conversation for scumtells to come out.

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

hey everyone i'm the replacement
can somone tell me briefly why everyone is voting for lloyd and/or the "highlights" so far

I'll tell you, the highlights are obvious if you read pages 1-30 along the way you will also learn why people are voting for Lloyd

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Stuff.

HoS: AntiThesis

Scum Slip Up Alert! Sirens! Big flashing lights!
lol

Why are you simply waiting for someone to make a case, which you can hop onto, as opposed to making a case YOURSELF. If you are town, get some fecking motivation. Your laziness isnt going to help the game. If you are scum, i look forward to an impending town victory. You seriously think we're just going to let you get away with tagging along to others logic?

Conservative scum is my favourite

BM

This is true, but no real evidence against him, but to go along with pressure on killa I'll go ahead

Vote: killa seven

for now...

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

I don't support a deadline, I do however think we need to find people who are unbelievably scummy, oEJo and Killa are the only two that relatively fit the profile. Anti still needs to explain himself, and I don't see where the problem is with Andycyca, can someone point that out to me? My vote stays with Killa for now.

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Agreed. And his miller mason comment confuses me. Although he said this proxy vote was just for a day, it might have been an attempt to get himself out of the spotlight.

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Mod:

I'm not voting killa, I don't even think I ever was, to make it clear.

Unvote ; Vote: Flameaxe

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Eh.. nevermind that last post, those two are in a different game I'm playing, apparently I'm not totally awake this morning to make it correct again

Unvote ; Vote: Killa 7

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Seeing as he claimed vig,

Unvote

, there isn't that much point, chances are he will die tonight unless he is protected, truthful or not, he will probably be mafia or vig targeted. I'm not voting yet, I still need to read more and catch up before I vote.

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Not vig

@Imat your logic is flawed

Heh, really we have to believe a counter-claim until we get more, maybe someone else will counter-claim against farside and killa. Anyways, since farside claimed vig,

Vote : Killa seven

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

who did you target and why did you feel it was a good move to kill Night 0 witout any information?

I want an answer to this question before I unvote.

I dont understand this post. If he claimed your role, i dont see how his target claim would affect whether you find him voteworthy or not?

Please explain.

BM

Nice catch, at this information,

Unvote

.

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

@BM Farside was a replacement, and, (I'm not re-reading atm) chances are she didn't have flavour sent to her. If your talking about farside not having flavour in her claim.

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

(SNIP)

@Antithesis- no its not possible, again, unless this game has the most dastardly setup ever. Maybe a Vig and a Dayvig would fit, but 2 vigs plus a cult, SK and Mafia?

That could be upto 5 kills on the first night, of which we only had 3. And 1 vig is claiming flavour, the other isnt.

So I'm 99.9% sure they arent both Vigs.

BM

Bolded mine. I have now re-read and have noticed that farside is willing to claim with flavour but killa has not responded about using flavour in his claim, so the question has less bearing on the game, unless you were talking about farside not wanting to claim with flavour (which isn't true).

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

uhm...ts and bm, vote counts are at:
http://www.quicktopic.com/41/H/nGY8JmZW6Lbht

What is this page 1 votecount business? I can't go back and do my vote analysis! OMG, how am I ever going to find scum....

thank god. Maybe now you can hunt scum like a normal human being?

You were not supposed to show TS (DGB) that, maybe s/he wouldn't have noticed. Scum!

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Heh, PresidentMaker... I also agree that killa should flavour claim first.

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

We are still looking for a replacement. Deadline is still in 3 days.

Request Deadline Postponement till a Replacement is found.

BM

2nd.

3rd. Don't need any more dead power roles.

4th'd. Not only do we need a possible claim from TLP (or said replacement) discussion, even if the day has been extremely long, is usually good, especially on the track we are going. Also, I support a TS vig if we don't get a claim from TLP and the extension isn't granted.

And, for clarification if a vig is NK'd their kill will not count, but if an SK is NK'd their kill will? Or would the kill count regardless of vig or SK role?

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Kill counts regardless UROE. Question is mildly interesting, but w/e on it for now.

I've been wondering since BM said if we let k7 live (which I don't believe will happen) he'd get an extra kill, but nothing about if we let him live and he was a vig and still got NK'd. I was just asking for indication whether or not the vig kill would count.

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

It was an honest question, I didn't know. And farside, I don't want to keep an SK alive, I'm just asking my question on if kills count regardless.

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

why not use me to kill who u guys want to kill vig 2 summy people instead of one. both of us cant be role blocked.

Please be quiet and except your death, whether you are a vig or not is regardless, the consensus (and obvious truth) is you are scum, SK in particular. Stop with the talking, and let us get something done with the rest of our day.

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

why not use me to kill who u guys want to kill vig 2 summy people instead of one. both of us cant be role blocked.

Please be quiet and accept your death, whether you are a vig or not is regardless, the consensus (and obvious truth) is you are scum, SK in particular. Stop with the talking, and let us get something done with the rest of our day.

EBWOP

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

V/LA till the 8th

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Sorry, was LA longer than I hoped, will read this toms prob.