Food Fight Mafia - WHO OWNS THE SCHOOL???

[Battle Mage]

Man, three shots to win and I still lost. But didn't I say BM-scum from the start? Can we see Role PMs please?

yeh i felt kinda bad for you in the end. You genuinely were the most protown looking player out of our group of 4, and really deserved something more, especially because you played remarkably well as town too.

And yeh, as in all my games, alot of people 'pegged me' as scum at various points in the game. But, its pretty irrelevant unless you actually get me lynched.

This game also highlighted a concern of mine which is allowing players to replace back in after being NKed. In this case, the SOLE REASON i NKed Gorrad in the first place, was because he was on to me. When i found out he'd been allowed to replace back in, not once, but twice, i was literally furious, as DGB will tell you.
In the end, i was lucky that it didnt change the shape of the game.

Ooi, who else other than Skruffs and I had BB notes?

Also, the double NK's were great fun. Cept on the first night, NEITHER WORKED. Had they worked, Gorrad and Skruffs wouldve been dead much earlier.

Jordan roleblocked me on Night 1?! You dirty bast...

Also, if Korlash had an innocent on Holy, who came up scum, why did he not twig that he was naive??

Oh and finally, thanks for modding an excellent game DGB. I love playing as SK, and i finally got the chance to play a full game as it.

BM

[Skruffs]

I SAID HE WAS SCUM I SAID HE WAS SCUM I SAID HE WAS SCUM

[Battle Mage]

-.-

[mneme]

I'm a little confused about that last night.

Shouldn't that be "Cake and BM kill mneme?" (korlash being A. Town and B. Dead?

I basically had the game pegged on the last night -- with BM and Cake town. Annoyingly, they didn't realize each other were, or my plan might have worked.

(if I'd realized what I did after the lynch -- that a 2/3 Admin/Soup split was -entirely- workable given that the Admin scum had Bad Behavior notes, which presumably gave them an edge -- I'd probably have pushed for a self-lynch, figuring Korlash was the townie most likely to come off as Town.

That said -- was BM immune to kills? If so, welll, the town was doomed the last night.

[The Fonz]

I SAID HE WAS SCUM I SAID HE WAS SCUM I SAID HE WAS SCUM

I did wonder why the hell BM was not lynched when he claimed there was a discrepancy between the way he was told BB notes worked and the way that Skruffs claimed they did, and that this meant Skruffs must be scum- and then backtracked on his claim? Jeez, BM, you really can get away with almost anything.

Man. Three months later, or whatever, and I'm STILL pissed at Tarhalindur.

[Battle Mage]

umm Mneme, neither me OR Cake were town.

[mneme]

BM: yes, that was the point. But you both targetted me, despite it being more or less obvious that you were both scum.

[mneme]

s/with BM and Cake town/with BM and Cake scum/

[Battle Mage]

I SAID HE WAS SCUM I SAID HE WAS SCUM I SAID HE WAS SCUM

I did wonder why the hell BM was not lynched when he claimed there was a discrepancy between the way he was told BB notes worked and the way that Skruffs claimed they did, and that this meant Skruffs must be scum- and then backtracked on his claim? Jeez, BM, you really can get away with almost anything.

Man. Three months later, or whatever, and I'm STILL pissed at Tarhalindur.

fyi, i did genuinely misread my role pm, and i genuinely though Skruffs was scum (because he had BB notes too).

BM

[The Fonz]

Funny thing is, you'd probably have been lynched if not for tar's 'innocent' result.

[cicero]

OK. Why did Jordan/Holy come up listed as a townie?

Holy(repl. JordanA24) - bashed in the head, Frances Bean Counter, aka"townie"

He was not a townie. He was my scumbuddy. Did you switch roles around and add the death millers (and make JordanA24 the opposite of a death miller) after Tarhalindur realised that the groups were given away in the Day One graphs as a damage control measure?

By the way, I was robbed as well. I was the Godfather of the admin scum and was nightkill immune. I was totally unsuspected for lynching as well. DGB apologised to me by PM. As I said to her then, no problem DGB. Shit happens.

Thanks for a fun game.

[mneme]

Hmm. So BM got your nightkill immunity, cicero? It looks like he survived at least one nightkill based on the night reports.

cicero+BM+Jordan/Holy = Admin Scum? (I knew Holy was scum! Just screamed scum!)

3 on 3 would have made a lot more sense (and would likely have resulted, assuming lack of death millers, in korlash and I madly competing to be the last day lynch -- which would have failed in the face of BM's apparent nightkill immunity, but hey.

[The Fonz]

You were fairly obviously town, mneme.

[mneme]

Fonz: well, I thought so -- which made BM's and Cake's reasons for killing me (rather than attepting the cross-kill) doubly wierd.

[The Fonz]

Your play was pretty good, but it was mostly the SirT 'no win condition' thing.

[mneme]

Hmm. Actually, knowing about the nightkill immunity, the only hope for the town -was- the no-lynch.

No Lynch, plus propper cross-kills: BM kills Cake. Cake fails to kill BM. Town lynches BM.

But the only way to predict that is to extrapolate Cicero's complaint after the nightkill with the last admin having a nightkill immunity.

[mneme]

*nod* that kept me safe (from lynching) pretty much the entire game -- but the scum didn't buy it when I mentioned it in the endgame.

[Gorrad]

My last incarnation was NK immune. What I don't get is why it wasn't a tie at the end. Was there a pre-set rule that Soup loses when all students are killed? If so, why wasn't the librarian subject to that same rule?

[mneme]

Gorrad: I think I understand why the Admin mafia won ties.

They have BB notes. So they can get an extra-kill by BB-note papering you.

What I don't understand is why you killed me. Did you really think I was more likely to be Admin mafia than the player with BB notes?

[Gorrad]

Soup already had a failure against BM

[Erg0]

Wow, investigated three times in the first two nights and he still won... nice job, BM.

[The Fonz]

Wow, investigated three times in the first two nights and he still won... nice job, BM.

Well, none of those cops could detect him, which made it substantially easier. In fact, I think they helped him- like I said before, without Tar coming out with his innocent on BM, BM gets lynched very early indeed.

[Erg0]

That's true, but it shows that there was a high level of suspicion on him from the start of the game. Once it became clear that there were mutiple cops of different flavours (namely when I died on night 2) an innocent result shouldn't have counted for much. I don't recall seeing anyone mention the breadcrumb I dropped for my innocent result.

[Battle Mage]

Hmm. So BM got your nightkill immunity, cicero? It looks like he survived at least one nightkill based on the night reports.

cicero+BM+Jordan/Holy = Admin Scum? (I knew Holy was scum! Just screamed scum!)

3 on 3 would have made a lot more sense (and would likely have resulted, assuming lack of death millers, in korlash and I madly competing to be the last day lynch -- which would have failed in the face of BM's apparent nightkill immunity, but hey.

I had NK immunity from the start.

@Fonz- Actually, i genuinely thought both Korlash and Mneme were scum.

Shows im better as scum than town. lol

@Mneme- I'd never have killed Cake in the end. In fact, had i showed up on time, i was going to hammer you, and NK Korlash instead. I killed you in the end because the Mod indicated that there could be 1 more day, and if i had less food than the remaining player, id lose anyway.
And actually, the BB notes seemed to be a detriment. Thats why i didnt use them. When Skruffs used them on me, i got an extra NK. I didnt really want to give other people additional abilities. lol

BM

[Mr Stoofer]

Stoofer's 5th Law