The Hobbit Mafia - GAME OVER

[MMCL]

Sorry I haven't been around for quite a bit - I blame work, yaw and uraj.... anyways - I'd agree with the assesment of Argoti but I want to here from him first.

[Jaylen]

I've read over the last day or so, and I really cannot see anyone better than Argoti to vote for - that roleclaim sucked orifice - as mentioned before, it seems to be Galion the butler all over again, and we all know what happened there.

Vote: Argoti

[Tigris]

Okay, so a quick look at MoL's posts makes me inclined to disregard any vote he made as possible scum; however, he likely did not vote for anyone that he knew was not scum, but that does not help much.

Good News: no doc and only one cop who was likely to be keyed into SKs dead so far.
7 dead scum and hopefully no more then 5 remaining (3 spiders, 1 gobbie, and 1 sk), more likely 3 left, but who knows.
No gobbie kill since the second goblin was killed and no warg kill.

Bad news: Lurkers are still alive *glares at killers*, get it right, kill lurkers, stupid evil &*!^@&#@ =^-^=

Anywho, waiting for Argoti seems like an okay idea, but then again I'm discounting the possibility that Murk did not block someone on the first night (roleblockers hurt towns as much as help imo), but then again there was no spider kill on the first night for some reason, so . . .

My own personal goal is to get a couple of posts with content out of Lord Gurgi, so

vote: lord gurgi

, which might shift very rapidly to argoti if the mood strikes me.

[the silent speaker]

What second goblin death, Tigris?

[Tigris]

Interesting, for some reason I thought two goblins had died o_o, not sure why though. This switches some of my numbers above obviously, sorry

[Yaw]

As an important note, the thread title hasn't been updated yet.

The number to lynch is 9

. So watch your votes.

Good point, Tigris. Bard was likely to be keyed into finding Smaug (who died night 1), if we go by book roles. We're still doing incredibly well.

Lord Gurgi should be back from Ireland, so hopefully we'll be hearing from him shortly. At any rate, the vacation mitigates his lurkerness a bit, in my opinion. I'll re-evaluate that statement when I re-read, of course.

And MMCL, you've been quite the willing participant.

[Internet Stranger]

Slackers, thats almost 24 hours without a post. Lets get moving already.

[Tigris]

Argoti hasn't posted anywhere in a couple of days, so I'm willing to wait for a bit, besides, half the fun of mafia to me is thinking of possibilities within the game, which waiting like this allows.

I've been a fan of reading all of a single person's post in one go via the bottom choice. I've never been a fan of 1-2 line posts (as is likely obvious to anyone familiar with my style of play =^-^=.) Hence my vote, a couple posts with paragraphs is enough to keep me at bay for a bit ^_^

There is more to go on in this game, I just can't completely put my finger on it right now, meh maybe later.

So,
Night 1: Wizard (jeep), gobbie (nanook), Smaug(mr flay), and snapper (phoebus)
Night 2: Spider (rick), gobbie (argoti), and no marks (william)
Night 3: Evil slept in or something *shrug*
Night 4: Wizard (mol) and spider (corsato)

We already know that the trolls had a limitation, so I wouldn't be too surprised to find the spiders can only kill on even nights, but then again it would weaken them, so I wouldn't think it would be included. The wizard still strikes me as a newer player due to kill patterns and choices, although there is one possible strategy that could go along with attacking Jeep night onw, but at the same time I doubt many people would come up with/try it, it's too risky imo. The gobbie kills seem more informed (which I do not attribute to jedi for simplicities sake; however, the lack of kill two nights in a row is interesting to note. The spiders seem random for now and the other two methods leave much to be desired, but perhaps both were via Gollum, hopefully. I can feel I'm missing something to tie all my thoughts together, but (obviously) I can't discern what. Perhaps someone else can.

It's somewhat strange, there are a lot of mid-level players remaining, imo, whereas many of the newer players are dead as are some of the older. Oh and Yaw, I'm this close to trusting you, except for that tendency you are showing to agree with me/pat me on the back, those tend to make me suspicious of someone ever since Mountain Mafia. =^-^=, evil discer I have a few theories, but need a bit more to munch on to flesh them out (i.e. need people to post), so . . .

[mikehart]

Mod recieved this

Hey,

Lord Gurgi is having internet problems and so won't be at hobbit mafia right now, but he doesn't need to be replaced.

-pie

I have to tell y'all that i made an error. I apologize but lets say there will be an extra kill tonight. or i could kill the target. please let me know which y'all prefer

[Yaw]

If the target's supposed to be dead now, then I think it's best to kill him/her now. Otherwise the game just gets skewed. (Besides, it would be silly if we lynched someone who got killed last night.)

[Jaylen]

Yep, I'm in agreement with Yaw - it also seems fairer on the target; he/she can move along to other games right away.

*hoping it's not me*

[Flying Dutchman]

As long as it is not me let the kill go through.

[Internet Stranger]

I wouldnt worry FD, the deadman is probably Yaw

[PeaceBringer]

just kill the target

[the silent speaker]

Oh? And how exactly do you know this, IS?

[CoolBot]

Argoti seems the most reasonable choice, considering his claim.

I think you should kill the target, mikehart.

[mikehart]

As PeaceBringer was asleep last night he suddenly felt a blade enter his stomach.

PeaceBringer

was Dori.

[Argoti]

So you want to hear from me, fine?

I blocked FD last night, but since all the kills were made that's pretty useless.

I haven't posted much because well, my schedule won't allow it, but I'm working on it.

[Internet Stranger]

Now that was hilarious (Peacebringer death)

So Yaw, do we lynch Argoti or not?

[Yaw]

Argoti -- as long as you're revealing, what were the rest of the choices your role has made?

FD -- any comment on the claim you were blocked last night?

[Argoti]

I have no info from the previous nights, so I assume Murk either didn't block night one or mike doesn't have/want to give me that info.

[Internet Stranger]

I will do whatever Yaw says until I get a better idea. Or if Yaw's idea sucks, which means that then I go after Tigris.

[Yaw]

I can't see any reason for a mod to deny you info on night choices your predecessor made. In fact, I'd think that would be given to you automatically. Or that you'd push to have it as soon as you thought (as you did yesterday) that you were on the block for lynching.

I'm not buying this, but I still want to hear from FD before I vote.

[CoolBot]

Gee, Argoti, did you think to ask about the previous choices? It's not often a replacement gets amnesia. I don't even think we need to wait for FD.

vote: Argoti

[Yaw]

Eh, you're right. It's better if we don't reveal any more roles than we have to, and we don't really have to here. I was just hoping to be able to slip in a reread this day. Guess it'll have to wait for tomorrow.

Vote: Argoti

I'd like an official vote count, but from my skim I think this is the sixth vote.