HAGGLE IV - Mafia Style - Guardian Wins

[Guardian]

Trade offer Guardian gives 2, 4 --> to andersonw for Cult Recruit(1) and Goon(1)

Fair?

[andersonw]

Actually, wizardcat has a point. I think I'll be trading with him. Sorry.

[Guardian]

You can trade with both of us .

[Wizardcat]

Okay, how about a seer and townie for a doctor and some rules?

My doctor stays (*growl*) but I'll offer up to five rules of your choice to compensate.

[Guardian]

Five rules for a Seer and a townie? That gives up the advantage of playing well very easily. Your prerogative Wizardcat.

[Wizardcat]

Five rules for a Seer and a townie? That gives up the advantage of playing well very easily. Your prerogative Wizardcat.

Well, I was hoping he'd up townies for something like that, but I'm a nice person. Despite whatever people who know me tell you.

[Guardian]

I know you're nice, but this is about haggling, not niceness .

Your attempt to get him to catch up to me and not let him catch up by advising him not to trade with me is the right kind of idea .

However, as an ECON major, I really do feel that free trade benefits both sides. Embargoes don't make sense because people will break them, those who break them will profit, and those who don't will be further behind.

[Wizardcat]

I agree and know what this game is about, but I felt guilty about declining the Doc. Seriously, guys, don't ask me for that; I'm not giving it up and I don't like having to decline to people.

Also, 'cause I think you're a monster at this game and will devour us all unless we try to work together against you.

<3?

[Guardian]

I think you are putting on a facade.

You just traded with me an hour ago, and are now advising andersonw not to.

<3

[Wizardcat]

Well, it's not like Rule 10 was helpful for you, considering you have neither of the cards in question.

[Guardian]

. I'm gonna go work on my paper. Peace gents.

[andersonw]

Five rules for a Seer and a townie? That gives up the advantage of playing well very easily. Your prerogative Wizardcat.

Says the person who offers 2 rules for a goon and cult recruit.


Okay, wizardcat, how about six rules for a seer and townie? 4, 5, 7, 10, 12, and 14?

[Guardian]

Wizardcat, that's folly. You should not make that trade.

[Guardian]

paper </3

[Wizardcat]

I think Guardian's right; I'm being too nice. Look at that guy just try to walk all over me! He also dares to not capitalize the w!

Um.

Trade andersonw: Rules 5, 7, 10, 12, 14 for Seer and Townie X2.

It's 5:3 ratio as opposed to Guardian's 1:1 and thus nearly two times a better deal. Especially considering what he wanted for them!

[dahill1]

Ok dahill give me something else for the seer you do not have .
Would prefer SKs,Werewolves

i have a lurker, some goons, a townie that i would trade
also rules

[Guardian]

trade andersonw: rule 1 for cult recruit

You want rule 1.

[dahill1]

oops ooba forgot to mention my cult recruit as well

[Andycyca]

Andycyca, I will trade rules 9, 11, 18 for 1, 2, and 3. I will also give you godfather and SK for kingmaker.

Yes to the rules

You'll have to outbid Guardian for the Kingmaker.

Looking for: Werewolves, Lynchers, Jesters and SKs

[Andycyca]

Cop (1)
Jester (1)
Kingmaker (1)
Lurker (1)
Townie (2)
Werewolf (4)

rules 1, 2, 4, 5, 13, 15, 19, 20

[Guardian]

trade Guardian rule 3,7,9 for Andycyca Cop(1)

[andersonw]

Trade to andycyca: rules 9, 11, 18 for 1, 2, 3

[andersonw]

I think Guardian's right; I'm being too nice. Look at that guy just try to walk all over me! He also dares to not capitalize the w!

Um.

Trade andersonw: Rules 5, 7, 10, 12, 14 for Seer and Townie X2.

It's 5:3 ratio as opposed to Guardian's 1:1 and thus nearly two times a better deal. Especially considering what he wanted for them!

Okay, sure, I'm probably going to lose this game anyways.

Trade wizardcat: seer and townie x2 for 5, 7, 10, 12, and 14

[andersonw]

Andycyca, I'll give you both of my SKs for kingmaker.

[Andycyca]

Confirm Trade: andersonw: rules 9, 11, 18 for andycyca --->rules 1, 2, 3