Pick your Poison 3 (Game Over)

[Patrick]

Votecount

Incognito (5) -- Sarcastro, Mellowed Man, Dave, mr. incrediball, ashmite84
q21 (3) -- scotmany12, JDodge, armlx
Coron (1) -- Incognito
Ether (1) -- Elmo
Dave (1) -- Marmalade
Mellowed Man (1) -- Ether

Not voting: starkmoon, Inquisitor JL, Flameaxe, Coron, q21, babygirl86
18 alive, 10 to lynch.

[Sarcastro]

Okay, so why isn't Incognito dead yet? Q21 is also acceptable.

[Elmo]

Unvote

:

Ether

;

vote

:

Mellowed Man

- shameless bandwagoning to try and move the game forward in

some

direction. Might vote q21, by the by.

[babygirl86]

The more I think about it, the more I wonder if incognito planned this whole thing all along..... Get huffy and request replacement, get the town to second guess him and unvote him, and then 'realize he made a mistake' and request to rejoin. Something doesn't seem right to me here.

vote incognito

[babygirl86]

Oh and also before I forget I'm leaving for vacation tomorrow sometime and won't be back until sometime thursday so I won't be posting for a few days

[Coron]

Vote: Babygirl

best I have for now.

[Flameaxe]

Vote: Babygirl

Did you seriously try to use that at a reason for someone to be scum?

[JDodge]

Babygirl's reaction is reasonable. If I were a newbie, I would probably have thought along similar lines.

Anyways, about this whole claim-who-you-would-protect-if-you-were-a-weak-doc thing. When are we doing this again?

[Coron]

Babygirl's reaction is reasonable. If I were a newbie, I would probably have thought along similar lines.

Anyways, about this whole claim-who-you-would-protect-if-you-were-a-weak-doc thing. When are we doing this again?

Dunno, when we get serious about lynching people(not just pressuring) I'd guess.

[babygirl86]

I don't have much time to post since I'm leaving in an hour, but I don't feel like getting lynched before I have the chance to claim while I'm away. But I'm not sure I should claim yet. But anway.... No that wasn't my only reasoning for voting incognito.. It was my reasoning for REvoting him.... My original reasoning still stands

[Mellowed Man]

me best guess would be that at least one scum member voted for the vig power. Rereading, incog seems like he's trying too hard to defend himself with defenses that aren't really that good of defenses. I agree- everyone has been accused of being scum when they're town- it's happened to me every game I've ever played in. I'm not quite buying his defenses.

Vote Incognito

And that was your first reason?

[Mellowed Man]

By the way, I've been really sick, so no need to prod me. Incognito, my vote on Ether was a random vote, btw. =( I nebulously see what you are going for, but it was positively what I meant.

Regardless,

unvote, vote Babygirl86

[babygirl86]

yea it was. but as I'm on my way out the door I have a feeling I'll be lynched by the time I get back from vacation so I might as well do this now, even tho ugh odds are you won't believe me. But either way: I'm a cop.

[Ether]

...

Mellowed needs more death.

Sarcastro is horribly behind the times

and

he's stopped posting arguments. (Heh.)

I have strong reason to believe that Incognito's replacement request was serious at the time.

I, too, am walking out the door.

[armlx]

After this last post of his I definitely have to agree.

Unvote, Vote Mellowed

[Coron]

unvote vote: mellowed man

[Sarcastro]

Sarcastro is not behind the times! The times are behind Sarcastro!

So anyway, it's apparent that you're all going to chicken out and not vote for Incognito, so I will consider switching over to q21 or possibly this Mellow fellow.

Seriously, though, Incognito is scum. I don't see any reason for this slow exodus from his bandwagon.

[Mellowed Man]

I don't have much time to post since I'm leaving in an hour, but I don't feel like getting lynched before I have the chance to claim while I'm away. But I'm not sure I should claim yet. But anway.... No that wasn't my only reasoning for voting incognito.. It was my reasoning for REvoting him.... My original reasoning still stands

yea it was. but as I'm on my way out the door I have a feeling I'll be lynched by the time I get back from vacation so I might as well do this now, even tho ugh odds are you won't believe me. But either way: I'm a cop.

I think this is a pathetic claim; right when she is beginning to be bandwagoned, or pointed at as suspicious, she says "I can claim, but I don't know if I should since I'm going somewhere and might not be able to post!." Then, she does indeed claim just because I say her reason for originally voting Cognate was pitiful...

Of all the things she can say.. =(

[q21]

And if she really is going somewhere and won't be able to post? Would you like us to lynch a possible cop?

[armlx]

No reason to not believe the claim for now. If it gets late game and points don't start to add up, then we might know something is up.

[Elmo]

more mellowed votes plz!

[Incognito]

Mellowed Man, please answer the questions that I've asked. You haven't really fully answered them by mentioning that your Ether vote was random. I asked more specific questions than that.

[q21]

Vote Mellowed Man

For automatically dismissing babygirl's role claim.

[Patrick]

Xtoxm replaces ashmite84.

[Xtoxm]

Hey all.

Hey Incog!