Sounds good to me.goborage wrote:@ everyone: In order to promote discussion I think we should all post the most suspicious people on our lists and the reasons for them.
Wow, quick to jump on ratting on the noobiest player! Not bandwagoning or anything, but that's mafiaish!Abstract Actuary wrote:Wow, quick to jump on anything done by the town's top suspect. Not bandwagoning or anything, but that's mafiaish.The World No.1 Noob wrote:wow quick to apologize, not band wagoning or anything but that's mafiaishI wish to apologize for my previous behavior. I'm sorry.
The first bit was fine but the second half of the post came out of know where (wait does anyone else think that I was hinting at myself being doc at all) I wasn't at all hinting at myself being a doctor, but then again he might just be trying to catch mafia so I'm not overly suspicous.i thinks hes saying that if mafia claim doc and the doc claims doc then they will both be targeted by town for lynching and if the doc shows up as doc when lynched then the fake is shown as just that... fake. then town lynches the fake. he then asks is it worth the docs death for one mafias or is it not.
the answer is usually no...
the evidence is clear last night the doc saved some one for all you know he/she saved you... what your asking makes you a likely target however as it seems your interest in the doc is only because you might be it.
if thats the case you have already made yourself clear as a doc yourself wondering if you should reveal yourself as doc... but then if you claim it some one else might say their the doc... so you best hope your right about that question... why cuz you practically just did state it... IMO anyways correct me if I'm wrong...
I agree that Dave only seems to pop in like Lassie when his name is called. IMO the "Awesome" reaction isn't really a scum tell. The same reaction could be a townie who doesn't know better. And "trying to fade into the background?" Please, he already has.The World No.1 Noob wrote:Well for Dave I Dave I agree with RTW's statement earlier - He seems to be popping in when he's needed and then disappearing. Also, a really exuberant reaction (e.g. "Awesome") to something that is beneficial to the town (such as a Mafia lynch or no kill at night) is sometimes an example of Mafia trying to act like townspeople, especially among new people who don't know any better. Then again, he wasn't on the Mafiamurkrow wagon (or any wagon), which makes me wonder if he's trying to fade into the background.
I think it's interesting that you'd defend Dave and not yourself. I'm not entirely sure what, if anything, to make of this.camisade wrote:I agree that Dave only seems to pop in like Lassie when his name is called. IMO the "Awesome" reaction isn't really a scum tell. The same reaction could be a townie who doesn't know better. And "trying to fade into the background?" Please, he already has.The World No.1 Noob wrote:Well for Dave I Dave I agree with RTW's statement earlier - He seems to be popping in when he's needed and then disappearing. Also, a really exuberant reaction (e.g. "Awesome") to something that is beneficial to the town (such as a Mafia lynch or no kill at night) is sometimes an example of Mafia trying to act like townspeople, especially among new people who don't know any better. Then again, he wasn't on the Mafiamurkrow wagon (or any wagon), which makes me wonder if he's trying to fade into the background.
I already posted my reasoning on this along with my vote, I think.Grum wrote:@ roland why are you so suspicious of me? aside from me being confusing...
Please reread the post and my responses to goborage. Especially the original post. I was against a quicklynch of Mafiamurkrow, encouraged her to claim and was warning people not to hammer until a claim came.The World No.1 Noob wrote:AA because of the incident earlier of what goborage noticed that he made a whole wall of quotes that pointed towards marf being suspicous but didn't vote for her himself and then later said he wasn't suspicous of her at all.
[quote="AA]Mafiamurkrow had acted strangely, but nothing to make me think she was scum.[/quote]Abstract Actuary wrote: And all Mafiamurkrow has to say is . . .
Seems like it could be scum saying "I'm not going to name any names as to avoid leaving any more trail."Mafiamurkrow wrote:Huh...erm,vote: no lynch.I have no leads and no idea otherwise, so I can't really lynch anyone.
