In post 823, BuJaber wrote:VOTE: James
Seems only interested in his feud with garmr.
@Locke - gamma was more active, more antagonistic I guess you could say. He shared his thoughts more often and more thoroughly. He pushed original cases and voted on unpopular wagons.. things like that. It's inconclusive evidence and 1 game doesn't say much and this game sucks conversation wise compared to that one tbh. I also don't trust meta tells very much because it's very easy to fake and meta changes with time. Just something to keep a note of as the game progresses.
I'll keep this in mind from now on, though this info doesn't really change my read on him but better to have info than to not
In post 827, James Brafin wrote:Page 24
So I open this page and I’m starting to get the feeling that Gamma might be scum. I haven’t actually seen him be productive today at all, and it sort of looks like Gamma is hiding behind this to avoid doing too much.
UnrealSeal is now lockdown for me. Thanks have a nice day.
In post 579, BuJaber wrote:As for hiraki I think we can assume the post is a joke but we just regard him with a healthy amount of caution. I highly doubt he's actually a traitor, but who knows.
He could be:
Town who joked - we don't want to lynch
Traitor - better to lynch actual mafia first
Scum - we'll sort later.
Pedit - nope. If gustavo is indeed town we are in the best position to force scum to hammer or risk losing their wagon. No need to hurry up at all.
And rob is a better lynch than garmr.
Why would we lynch confirmed Town and not make scum waste their shot? This seems odd. If you could explain your reasoning here BuJaber that would be great.
In post 596, BuJaber wrote: In post 595, James Brafin wrote:Okay, I came into this thinking Hiraki was rough, but this is just downright toxic. I wouldn’t put this past scum play either; I’ve seen games where players have survived to endgame by just turning people off and make them not want to play. Scum leaning Hiraki for now.
Huh? Are you sure you're talking about the right person?
I was. I felt like Hiraki was being a bit nasty at the time, just enough to turn people off. Her play and posting has improved since then though, and in perspective there are way worse in the game right now.
Why is your townread on Seal so strong? I don't think you've ever gone into detail about your read of him so far but you've pretty consistently had him as one of your top townreads
In post 833, James Brafin wrote:Page 26: not gonna start doing massive quote walls, but nvm. Garmr is still tunneling Gustavo.
Also liking BuJaber more and more. His interactions and questions all feel very natural and town driven.
Garmr was no longer tunneling at this point, he was just still arguing with Gus since neither of them can get along but he had unvoted him by that point if I recall correctly
In post 860, Garmr wrote:Bub what's your reason for voting James you seem to portray him as antitown. Do you think his scum or anti town
Are these really a one or the other kinda deal? Cause I'm pretty sure scum can be anti town
In post 868, popopopopopopo wrote:i think ive been pretty transparent
just because i dont post long text walls that no one reads
You haven't been transparent about your reasonings behind most things today though you have stated your reads on occasion without much in the way of explanations so I suppose you've been a little transparent
In post 874, Garmr wrote:Also If I was scum i would be loving the situation right now but I'm not so what can I do to change it?
This just strikes me as LAMIST
In post 876, popopopopopopo wrote:
james is still a lynch i can get behind i caught him page 2
what are your thoughts on gamma emerad
But I thought you "caught" James page 1 when you first started tunneling him?
In post 884, Garmr wrote: In post 883, popopopopopopo wrote: In post 879, Garmr wrote:
Basically his action of jumping on every major wagon seems scummy to me. But despite his actions I my gut says his town from the way he engaged with me.
this is weird to me. seems like youre covering yourself by not commiting either way. i feel you
pedit: if you can get some support for it yes i would vote a james wagon. town was resistant to the idea before and said i was tunneling so id prefer to focus on gamma for now, but if a wagon starts i will join it.
I'm going with my gut and won't be voting him today if that makes it slightly more clear. I'm just being vocal about it because last game I went with my gut over logic with blue blooded toffee and he turned out to be scum. I feel like I let town down that game because I only caught 2/3 scum and if I raised concerns I would of potentially nailed 3/3.
But also I don't really see anyone town reading James so I don't know where this resistance is coming from. I haven't really noticed it either. Gb is pretty much the only wagon with steam and I town read Gb/doctors slot. Your vote would make James the 2nd leading wagon and the counter wagon to my town read of Dr dolittle.
I guess you could also vote unreal seal but I don't know your thoughts on them. I personally null scum read them but I would rather deal with James first. So I wouldn't be opposed to their lynch but I'd rather have James lynched.
I don't know about anyone else's resistance to the James wagon but mine is just I'd prefer rob/doolittle slot to be lynched more, but I would be willing to lynch James if seemed like neither rob/doolittle or you weren't getting lynched today