NY 215: HMS Erebus - Game Over!

[Nosferatu]

i wish i could revise yalls ability to play the game well

[Io]

I really don't care weather or not if Serial Killer is "likely."
All I do know is that Dave didn't vig himself and Popo was in Dave's declared shooting pool.
Therefore I'm going to assume Dave shot him and there's not a Serial Killer for now.

[Performer]

I just start looking through some ISO's again and Akarin's 1162 is pretty weird as was their post calling Dave manipulative for claiming Vig.
Performer v Akarin does feel like TvS though.
I can't really tell which one is scum though since I can't actually get a solid reed on either, the push Akarin was making on Performer just does not feel like it was two scum buddies fighting.
This is mostly since Performer didn't seem to really care if Akarin voted him or not and if scum were going to start bussing then I would have expected Performer to at least try and make it look TvS and not SvS

Performer's fixation on tictac just feels too off for me to call Performer the definite town in this situation.
It just kind of feels like his only reason for voting him is his meta from two years ago and that tictac scum read him at some point.

Interestingly, I see it the other way, he keeps voting me and I recall stating he's the #1 go yesterday. Sadly nobody wanted to lynch him yesterday.

Actually how the fuck is pox7 a strange vigilante target? He was lurking and being unhelpful.

I agree about the 2nd part of your logic but damnit dave, you keep your vote on me for so long and say nothing about me being town?? and then shoot popo? this is some M E S S E D up stuff you did to me.

[Io]

Yeah no Io that wasn’t an odd vig shot in the slightest, as I said pox7 wasn’t contributing, that’s textbook what a vig should be shooting
Counterwagons are second best, at best, and wagon placement scumminess is something generally lynched for, not vigged for

I'm just saying there was better hoptions out there.

[Gamma Emerald]

You’re lying to yourselves if you think for a second pox7’s play was in any way towny or beneficial to town
Nos I challenge you to tell how exactly pox7 was “towny”

[Performer]

@Nos you have some messed up reads, are you town here? mala AND popo town? N O way.

There are still 3 people if I count right - tic, akarin, purr, who haven't said a word.

this GE push on Hugo is something though, with Hugo looking suspect. The tone of his posts strikes me as really off.

[Garmr]

I thought popopo was town, Lapsa on the other hand....


Anyway my lynch pool for now in no order

(tictac,lapsa,davesaz)

People I have my eye on (purr or anyone who gets a cat avi jokes)

@Gamma emerald
We just came from a game where popo played like this. The biggest difference was you were scum that game and your probably town this game. Different perspectives. The fact you suspected him plays into my town read of you actually.

Anyone else that's not in my town list or in scum list is null and I don't mind if they get lynched. Nosf on the other hand joins my town list just because his scum game felt way different.

[Performer]

Based on dave's last scumreads on pg 43, he had
Akarin(27), popopopopopopo(28), Garmr(35), Io(88), Nosferatu(108), Hugo Stiglitz(19) listed as the below:
tr, scum, scum, tr, tr, scum

popo flipped green, that leaves garm & hugo which GE has been pushing on d2.
--------
garm putting up dave for lynch pool, is very interesting.

[Performer]

VOTE: garmr

[Io]

The only think I see odd about Hugo atm is their vote of Purr followed immediately* by voting Mala saying they agreed with Purr. But they voted for Mala which was the opposite wagon than Purr was voting on. It's just really odd and inconstant with his words and actions not matching.
*immediatly being a hundred or so post gap, but their very next ISO post.

[Gamma Emerald]

I thought popopo was town, Lapsa on the other hand....


Anyway my lynch pool for now in no order

(tictac,lapsa,davesaz)

People I have my eye on (purr or anyone who gets a cat avi jokes)

@Gamma emerald
We just came from a game where popo played like this. The biggest difference was you were scum that game and your probably town this game. Different perspectives. The fact you suspected him plays into my town read of you actually.

Anyone else that's not in my town list or in scum list is null and I don't mind if they get lynched. Nosf on the other hand joins my town list just because his scum game felt way different.

Eh? I know at the very least he had his own reads and pushed them that game, which is a significant difference

[Io]

So why is Dave in your lynchpool Garmr?
Also you were scum reading Dave day 1 for "picking on" lapsa and Popo for easy mislynches.

[Gamma Emerald]

Bwuh
Isn’t Dave dead
Or is there another Dave?

[Io]

I'm actually very suspicious that you just slipped not knowing that Dave was killed last night.
Like, it's so odd that I don't feel like anyone would actually not realize someone was killed last night.
Like it's Mafia trying to fake a town slip that they didn't know who the Mafia killed.

[Nosferatu]

BRUHHH

You’re lying to yourselves if you think for a second pox7’s play was in any way towny or beneficial to town
Nos I challenge you to tell how exactly pox7 was “towny”

You are unable to differentiate between trolling town and scum

that's ok

but don't say im being weird for your inability to read a slot.

[Nosferatu]

@Nos you have some messed up reads, are you town here? mala AND popo town? N O way.

mfw being right is messed up

[Io]

BRUHHH

You’re lying to yourselves if you think for a second pox7’s play was in any way towny or beneficial to town
Nos I challenge you to tell how exactly pox7 was “towny”

You are unable to differentiate between trolling town and scum

that's ok

but don't say im being weird for your inability to read a slot.

I still love this guy.

[Garmr]

I'm actually very suspicious that you just slipped not knowing that Dave was killed last night.
Like, it's so odd that I don't feel like anyone would actually not realize someone was killed last night.
Like it's Mafia trying to fake a town slip that they didn't know who the Mafia killed.

I am going to be honest I don't know why I wrote davesaz in there. It was originally going to be another post but I pretty much deleted most it and reworked it again with some of the old stuff still in there. I do that quite a lot when there is pedits and I have had something similar to this happen once before. Last game I voted someone else by mistake.

viewtopic.php?f=2&t=76913

@garmr im still confused as to why you voted golden robster instead of unrealseal.

Oh I thought I voted unrealseal.

VOTE: unrealseal


I originally was going to direct the message at @golden robster and ask what he thought of unreal seal. But decided to direct it at everyone instead.

[Garmr]

I'm actually very suspicious that you just slipped not knowing that Dave was killed last night.
Like, it's so odd that I don't feel like anyone would actually not realize someone was killed last night.
Like it's Mafia trying to fake a town slip that they didn't know who the Mafia killed.

Also if I didn't know he was dead I wouldn't of replied to hugo talking about him being vigged.

@Purrcocet
The reason I held off voting you yesterday despite you appearing scummy was because your survival instinct kicking in could be something else. I thought there may be a off chance you are a town power role. So I wanted to see if you had results day 2 or not.

@hugo scum could of had a strong man or there is no protection role for town.

[Io]

Oh I didn't even noticed you posted earlier today.
Alright, you're just bizarre, got it.

[Garmr]

Also would like to point out that performer is using daves read list as a reason to scum read people with out actually discussing why he agree's with the reads. Because for all he knows davesaz could of been wrong on everyone of his reads and just played trash this game. This seems like a way he can bypass actually laying down a case and go straight for a vote while trying to sound town.

VOTE: Performer

[Nosferatu]

excellent observation

[Lapsa]

@Saudade are you Hugo?

[Hugo Stiglitz]

@Nos you have some messed up reads, are you town here? mala AND popo town? N O way.

There are still 3 people if I count right - tic, akarin, purr, who haven't said a word.

this GE push on Hugo is something though, with Hugo looking suspect. The tone of his posts strikes me as really off.

Who's tone, mine or GE?

[Performer]

Going to look through ISOs again.

Garm said he's ok with lynching anyone except nos. I was the counterwagon yesterday, garm was alright with mala, dave, me as sr.

And that inclusion of dave in d2, stands out . Not buying that it's a mistake from town.

So Unless there is some other news that pops up, I'm keeping the vote as is and working with Dave's sr list. I had garm sr then moved him to null in d1 I think.