1. Done
2.
I'm not going to analyze every player here because I've made an analysis on SA and minor runs at you (muer)
Firstly Shaka: Very insightful... i think i should have just read Shaka's posts to figure out what is going on... They are concise and to the point.
Interesting quote from Shaka I found:
Second, it is not circular because I am not saying that Muerrto is less suspicious because he wanted to lynch himself. I said that you agreeing with him and voting him is more suspicion that him wanting lynch him self is suspicious.
Massive: Semi lurking but likely due to the fact that whatever he does say are damn good questions that needed answering. For one of the least talkative players, some very good information is gleamed from the questions he asks.
Litral: On a second read through... less of the saint i thought he was. Inconsistancies, misrepresentations (though I can see a fair number of them being linked to english being a secondary language as they are general wording issues such as mis-translation.) but still very fency on a lot of topics. When he does finally come to a point of decision it is generally repeated mishmash of other posts saying "Yes, i agree" But again having mentioned the language barrier this might be construed as general problems with formulating linguistic explanations.
Q21 has been very hard for me to read. through both reads i caught a lot of ambiguous comments that could have been noobish or scum-underbelly. THings such as:
I've mentioned 4 people: Walnut, Mike, snafoo and (on outside chance) Litral. If there's no scum among those 4 I'd be astounded.
This comment, coupled with a vote for walnut, looks like track covering. "Yes i think this person is scum and we should lynch him, but if he's not these are my other choices." Preemptive defending against the obvious mislynch that would be Walnut. also: Q in as his first comment on the game says
FoS: Mike as lurkerscum.
But his first vote is for Walnut, a player who, up until that point, and who did not appear on Q's first list of suspects and was very open and genuine about his Noob status almost to the point of ignorance.
Super archivist: I've stated it before... ACTIVE LURKER... reinforcing my belief was his eagerness to hammer me, then when he saw I was willing to die retracted into oblivion.
Muerrto: an IC with a gift for being able to pick 2 syllables out of the word cat... this guy can break any remotely unfouded argument into a trillion pieces. Sad thing is, he also breaks apart comments that are not meant to have any game relevance too. He has been quick to question everyone... he has posted the most out of everyone, and has been willing to sacrifice himself. He is either town... or has enacted a very, very well, near impossibly, executed mafia run. He's put his neck out farther than Sin in a spam thread.
thats everyone yes?
3. ... this was where i read your last 4 posts and said fuck you...
Strategy, smategy.
