Mini 589: SSBB Smalltown Mafia (Game Over!)

[pickemgenius]

It came later, it involved agreeing with another poster (hiding behind their argument) and added nothing of his own.

yeah, what kind of idiot doesn't give reasons when they vote

OH NO YOU DIDNT!?!?!

i was talking about me

i was talking about you.

[dahill1]

It came later, it involved agreeing with another poster (hiding behind their argument) and added nothing of his own.

yeah, what kind of idiot doesn't give reasons when they vote

OH NO YOU DIDNT!?!?!

i was talking about me

i was talking about you.

cool

[Lawrencelot]

ckd's and MafiaSSK's votes look a bit more... opportunistic.
Fonz, why do you think MafiaSSK's action is scummier than ckd's?

first of all, I would like you explain my vote. I would like to hear your perception of it. then, explain why my vote was opportunistic. Once you do that, explain my unvote after I checked back in to see a couple votes after mine. Then explain how it is opportunistic when we dont even know the alignment of AK yet...do you know something that we dont?

then explain this vote.

Vote Lawrencelot

, I dont think I have liked any of your posts since this game has started.

Gladly, although I would prefer you explain it yourself.
1) you vote because you don't agree with Gorrad's style. It is an explanation, but not a good one, and definately not worth a vote from my point of view. By looking at the votes only, it seems you wanted to follow Gorrad, or that MafiaSSK wanted to follow you. It seemed opportunistic because, although AK might be scum, the reasons for voting him were crap. Your unvote: it is like 20 posts after the latest vote (of James) on AK that you unvote him, while you did post earlier after James's vote, so I'm not really convinced. Besides, AK's behaviour on page 8 looked very scummy to me, but maybe you were bussing. Yet, I don't think you're more scummy than the others who were voting AK, and they can't all be scum, but I'm pretty sure one of those on the AK wagon is scum. Maybe it's just MafiaSSK, he is repeating others a lot, said he would post his thought on page 7, and didn't give any, and on page 9 he says he doesn't post a lot because there's nothing to comment on.

Vote: MafiaSSK

.

[Lawrencelot]

Heh, I think I got off track there. 2?) I don't understand your vote on me. You should explain it yourself, because I did like my posts since this game started

[Gorrad]

Lawrencelot, that was a good case. I dig it. Erm, how many votes is that on SSK now? I don't want to L-1 yet.

Mod:

VC please.

[Xdaamno]

Votecount

MafiaSSK: 4

(Flameaxe, The Fonz, pickemgenius, Lawrencelot)

Anatole Kuragin: 3

(dahill1, JamesThePhox, goborage)

pickemgenius: 2

(Anatole Kuragin, andersonw)

Lawrencelot: 1

(curiouskarmadog)

Not Voting: 2

(Gorrad, MafiaSSK)

Player List: curiouskarmadog, Flameaxe, pickemgenius, MafiaSSK, Lawrencelot, Anatole Kuragin, The Fonz, dahill1, goborage, andersonw, JamesThePhox, Gorrad.

Seven (7) to lynch.

Once again, can I remind you to put votes/unvotes on the left side of the page for ease of reading.

Edits didn't change anything significant

[The Fonz]

Once again, can i get a yea or nay from everyone on whether we should insist Lawrence use his power? I say yea.

[curiouskarmadog]

Once again, can i get a yea or nay from everyone on whether we should insist Lawrence use his power? I say yea.

Well, I am getting scum vibes off him, so I would rather lynch.

but I think I am standing alone on this.

If he is town, I think he has one of those powers that he shouldnt tell people today if he is going to use it tonight or not. I think it is pro-town to use it, especially if it is a role that is useful or he has a strong vibe someone is town. Tomorrow he can defend his actions (or lack there of)...but talking about it today is not good.

[goborage]

Once again, can i get a yea or nay from everyone on whether we should insist Lawrence use his power? I say yea.

Has this been discussed? If so can you refer me to the post? I'm a fan of people having accounted-for night actions but I don't see how we can verify that Link is doing anything.

[curiouskarmadog]

then you need to read the roles again

[goborage]

Who would he be assigned to protect? Do we have any confirmed town?

[curiouskarmadog]

do you mean "justify" doing anything or "verify" doing anything?

[dahill1]

hey, before we lynch obvscum MafiaSSK, who should Gob and I target tonight?

[Gorrad]

I think Lawrencelot's power should be used when he chooses, not when we do. Too much to lose, not enough to gain.

[Gorrad]

Oh, and

Vote: MafiaSSK

L-2.

[goborage]

do you mean "justify" doing anything or "verify" doing anything?

Verify...why would I write one word when I mean another?

[Lawrencelot]

do you mean "justify" doing anything or "verify" doing anything?

Verify...why would I write one word when I mean another?

Because you're from Canada...

I am against telling whether I use my target or not. It's too much benefit for scum.

[The Fonz]

If he is town, I think he has one of those powers that he shouldnt tell people today if he is going to use it tonight or not. I think it is pro-town to use it, especially if it is a role that is useful or he has a strong vibe someone is town. Tomorrow he can defend his actions (or lack there of)...but talking about it today is not good.

I really don't see the harm in making it clear he's going to use it, as long as we don't announce who he's going to use it

on

.

Once again, can i get a yea or nay from everyone on whether we should insist Lawrence use his power? I say yea.

Has this been discussed? If so can you refer me to the post? I'm a fan of people having accounted-for night actions but I don't see how we can verify that Link is doing anything.

We don't actually need to verify it. We do need the threat of verification to be there.

Who would he be assigned to protect? Do we have any confirmed town?

do you mean "justify" doing anything or "verify" doing anything?

Verify...why would I write one word when I mean another?

Because you're from Canada...

I am against telling whether I use my target or not. It's too much benefit for scum.

And this, ladies and gentlemen, is why I insist he use it. Because this is flat-out untrue.

There's very little benefit to scum to knowing lawrence is using his power, but no on whom. His argument about 'stopping a scum getting vig' is weak too, because I would sincerely hope any town vig think long and hard about when to use that power.

HOWEVER there is no way in hell, if he's scum or SK, he's going to want to use it, because it makes HIM more likely to die.

Therefore, using the power is basically neutral for town, but a bad move for scum, so should definitely be required to be exercised.

[JamesThePhox]

Looks like we're pressuring/lynching MafiaSSK.

Go go go

Unvote; Vote: MafiaSSK

! L-1. Be careful, guys.

[curiouskarmadog]

If he is town, I think he has one of those powers that he shouldnt tell people today if he is going to use it tonight or not. I think it is pro-town to use it, especially if it is a role that is useful or he has a strong vibe someone is town. Tomorrow he can defend his actions (or lack there of)...but talking about it today is not good.

I really don't see the harm in making it clear he's going to use it, as long as we don't announce who he's going to use it

on

.

Hey, I think it is pro-town to use it, but there is no point in telling the mafia today if he plans on using it tonight or not....let him defend himself /explain why tomorrow if he doesnt use it.

Looks like we're pressuring/lynching MafiaSSK.

Go go go

Unvote; Vote: MafiaSSK

! L-1. Be careful, guys.

if you want to pressure/ lynch him, why are you telling people to be careful?...sort of getting that scummy vibe off someone who says "go go go" and "be careful" in the same breath.

unvote, vote James

[MafiaSSK]

Looks like we're pressuring/lynching MafiaSSK.

Go go go

Unvote; Vote: MafiaSSK

! L-1. Be careful, guys.

Fine, I'll explain my reasoning for jumping on the bandwagon. I was being lazy with who to vote for so I agreed with CKD.

[curiouskarmadog]

Looks like we're pressuring/lynching MafiaSSK.

Go go go

Unvote; Vote: MafiaSSK

! L-1. Be careful, guys.

Fine, I'll explain my reasoning for jumping on the bandwagon. I was being lazy with who to vote for so I agreed with CKD.

wait a minute, you are agreeing with me about what?

If you feel like being lazy is anti-town, why did you do it? Why arent you redeeming yourself now by presenting some original thoughts on the game?

[The Fonz]

unvote

: James, that last post of yours was scummy as fuck.

It doesn't make MafiaSSK any less scummy, but does put you in a similar league.

[The Fonz]

Oh, and I'm happy to leave it at 'Lawrence should be lynched on sight if he claims not to have used his power.' We should force scum to lie.

[dahill1]

suggesting james as a possible target for me and Gob tonight because of that incredibly scummy post