Sorry about my absence. Unexpectedly eventful weekend.
Continuing my reread, there really isn't much to comment on. But I definitely will do so when I find something.
Post 125 by Grum is no good, I hate the role hunting. Even if he was subconsciously claiming the doc if you were town you wouldn't want to point this out because it gives scum help with their night kills.
Post 131 by Noob - docs can't self protect.
Grum appeals to emotion in post 134. Not good.
FOS: Grum.
He was hardly being attacked and pulled out a pretty much completely unprovoked appeal to emotion post.
I don't like post 138 by Noob, not because I think it is scummy, but because there is nothing wrong with aggressiveness and nothing is stopping someone who is defending themselves from attacking someone else except laziness.
I don't like post 142 by Gobo, he is asking everyone to make a scum list. Scum lists help scum a hell of a lot with their night kill choices.
FOS: Gobo.
I like post 146 by Roland
I agree with his suspicions of Grum, but don't see how he founded the rest of his list.
Post 148, /smacksface.
Again, don't like post 150 by Gobo. Reasons already stated.
Post 155 by Dave is killing me, I hope he follows through.
Have no idea what Grum is going on about in post 159. More unprovoked appeal to emotions?
Hating 163-165 by Noob, give us some reasonings please!?
Post 157 by Noob is an improvement but not much, he is just following everyones lead and saying what they said.
Post 179 by Dave is a relief, but it's also scummy. He lurks the whole game and then brings up a case on the easiest target for scum.
FOS: Dave.
There was plenty more to comment on, like Grums actions, or AA and Godos debate, despite all that he chose the easiest target to pick on.
/slams face into desk after reading post 191 by Dave.
Agrees with Gobo on post 204. But not the whole not playing newbie games anymore part. Post 203 by Gobo was terrible, I have no idea where he got any of his ideas from. That post alone makes me want to lynch him :\
Post 206 is good, so is 208.
I like post 223 by Noob. It looks like an honest (town) effort to encourage discussion. The difference between noob scum (Grum) and noob town (Noob) is posts like this.
Post 228 by Grum, not good. Another appeal to emotion.
Post 223 by Mokini, yay an active replacement /hypocrite. It's good to know that he is reading the thread, but honestly, less story telling and more suspicion explain would be nice.
Post 246 is good by Mokini, but again I hate scum lists. They give scum lots of information to make their night kills on.
Loving
post 250 by Noob!
Ok that's mostly what I thought as reading the thread.
Also for the AA vs Gobo issue, I'm having a hard time deciding who to go with because I agree with some points made by AA and agree with some points made by Gobo. On a completely random note I fucking love the name Gobo. Gobo Gobo Gobo!
After completing the reread, I've decided that an
unvote: vote: Dave
is required.
That is not a pressure vote. That is not a prod either. However, that
is
an I think he is scum actively lurking only posting every 5 days to avoid fulling his inbox with prods from the mod.
Right after Dave is Grum, if anyone isn't bothered reading over this post to find out why, I can sum it up one another post for you. But I can't right now, I must be off to bed.
