Mini #597 - Swift speed: Werewolves (Game over)

[Jenter Brolincani]

Blonde;

From;

unvote; vote: Phoebus
- Mostly to make sure korts isn't quick-lynched.

To;

I do realise that both had 2 votes, i am far happier being on the wagon of Phoebus at this stage.

Which in itself nullifies his orignal argument without replacing it with anything discernable. Change of argument. The buddying of Korts included in this is a textbook n00b scum move, hence my comment.

Enough for you?

However, I find Phoebus' attack on Donkey worryingly daft, for the reasons given by Shy Guy. Scum will want to hold everyone to deadline to give themselves the maximum chance of getting a night action in. They won't want the day ended early.

vote phoebus

You attack donkey and Korts, but fail to mention anyone else on the wagon, notably M.B. who advocated a fast lynch just before Donkey did one.

Vote count

(11 players alive = 6 to lynch before deadline)
(2) Phoebus – Shy Guy, Jenter Brolincani
(1) donkeyz12212 – Phoebus
(1) Jenter Brolincani – Mr. Blonde

Not voting:

donkeyz12212, Grimmy, killa seven, Korts, SleepyPanda, water_foul, Xanatos Roulette

Deadline:

Thursday 22 May 6:00 PM (GMT -5 according to forum clock)

[water_foul]

ok, so my town vibes for phoebus are gone (if they aren't created bu lack of sleep) although i think people are overreacting to things which is why I think we killed a power role. After saying this I will stay in the unvoting group and will look into the two people I think are scummiest (phoebus and korts) and check back in

[killa seven]

im here. will re read real fast

[Johoohno]

Mod note:

Chaosweaver

has asked for a replacement and

Grimmy

has stepped in.

Thank you Grimmy!

[Mr. Blonde]

Welcome Grimmy!

Jenter:

Which in itself nullifies his orignal argument without replacing it with anything discernable. Change of argument. The buddying of Korts included in this is a textbook n00b scum move, hence my comment.

Okay, I realize that we both were meaning the same thing, and I got stuck in the word "change". This is fine.

unvote Jenter Brolincani

vote: Xanatos Roulette

(for lurking - and waiting townies to lynch each other?)

[SleepyPanda]

I read through a couple times, but I'm still not picking up on anything that sticks out to me.

Oh and also, as far as I'm concerned, this outcome doesn't absolve Korts in my book.

Does clammy being town make you think he's more or less suspicious now? You were so sure that he was scum on day 1, you stuck to your case against him regardless of what other people said. Are those points still valid?

I don't find donkeyz vote particularly scummy. Although hammer votes can be suspicious, I'm not getting a very scummy vibe here.

I'm not sure if ending the day early was better off for scum or town. An extra day could've gave clammy a chance to defend himself. But had clammy claimed, I don't think it would've made much difference. To prove he was telling the truth, we'd have to wait until night anyways. Also, I didn't see any solid cases against other people and he was the top suspect.

Ending a day early didn't let werewolves get in a NK, so that's a plus. Perhaps they didn't get a chance to send in their night command or maybe a doctor sucessfully guarded, which I think is pretty low, but is it possible that they didn't know that they had to get their night command in by day? Honestly, I had missed that in the rules, and it seemed that Korts and Blonde also seemed to be a bit confused by not having a night. I think that's more plausible than a doctor scenario.

[Korts]

I'm here, currently waiting on Phoebus to answer my question regarding his stance on donkeyz after his reply.

[Grimmy]

Hi All.

Im here, just checking in, and ill give my $.02 later.

Grimmy

[Xanatos Roulette]

Hi All.

Im here, just checking in, and ill give my $.02 later.

Grimmy

out of curiousity, are you the same Grimmy from Clockwork storybook?

unvote Jenter Brolincani

vote: Xanatos Roulette (for lurking - and waiting townies to lynch each other?)

the lurking I can understand. I've been busy the last few days, but I haven't even voted for anyone yet. I didn't understand before how you thought someone could fake being a tracker, but now I understand that you meant that it would just be a gambit to buy time.

[Mr. Blonde]

Yep, gambit could buy time or even reveal werewolf and "prove" he is the tracker.

Well Xanatos Roulette, whom do you suspect - who would vote now?

[Grimmy]

Hi All.

Im here, just checking in, and ill give my $.02 later.

Grimmy

out of curiousity, are you the same Grimmy from Clockwork storybook?

Yeppers.

That is what got me to this mafia forums.

Are you from there too?

Good to see (possibly) a fellow fabletown resident here out in the real world (I guess that makes us tourists)

enough in jokes.

on to the lynching.

actually, I dont have a solid lead on who is the wolf, but I have some suspicions.

so for now

FOS: Mr Blonde

Thats all for now

Grimmy
has more fun than blondes

[Mr. Blonde]

Off-topic: Is Clockwork storybook a forum... where mafia is played? If so, please share a link.

FoS me - why?

[Grimmy]

OT: http://www.clockworkstorybook.net/forum ... m.php?f=14
this is a forum for the fables comic, and they playmafia, which led me here.

On Topic: Just a hunch/gut feeling.

[Mr. Blonde]

off-topic: thanks

Ok.

[killa seven]

i find it funny phoebus has let up on korts today after heavily attacking him yesterday.

[Korts]

unvote, vote: grimmy

FoSing just for the sake of FoSing (as in, with nothing to have warranted the FoS) is a strong scumtell.

[Korts]

i find it funny phoebus has let up on korts today after heavily attacking him yesterday.

Actually, I'm thinking he hasn't let up, just hasn't posted.

[Mr. Blonde]

Yeh, let's see what Phoebus has to say...

[Phoebus]

Phoebus is away for the next 14 or so hours.
He will respond then.

I will address the questions that I noticed as I skimmed...

My current vote is admittedly reactionary.

I've already said that I don't find Korts cleared of all wrong-doing.
Yes, I attacked him yesterday. Part of that attack is what he calls broken logic. Part of the attack was tied in to clammy being scum. Seeing as clammy was pro town, that shoots a hole in my theory, eh?

At present, if not for donkeyz or korts (and i'm yet to read donkeyz's response), I'd vote for Jenter Broliwhatever.
It would be semi OMGUS. His reasons for voting me seem off and a tad opportunistic.
Of course, this is off a skim read only - yet...first impressions might not be too off...

[Mr. Blonde]

Phoebus, wouldn't your own vote be quite OMGUS? You haven't said anything bad about Jenter before now after he voted you?

[Xanatos Roulette]

Off topic: Grimmy, you can call me E. Jacob.

Well Xanatos Roulette, whom do you suspect - who would vote now?

Well, At this point, I'm suspicious of Phoebus. Everyone's already stated why. I'm not in the mood to vote right now though.

I'm also suspicious of JB. something about his votes are bugging me, but I can't quite put my finger on it.

And I'm also suspicious of you, but I think that's mostly because you just jumped down my throat earlier.

[Grimmy]

Granted, I will have a better clue as to peoples guilt/innocence as the days go on, which is why I did not vote outright, but simply pointed a finger.

I will withhold my vote until clearer signs of guilt/innocence reveal themselves.

E. Grimmy B.

[Korts]

Granted, I will have a better clue as to peoples guilt/innocence as the days go on, which is why I did not vote outright, but simply pointed a finger.

I will withhold my vote until clearer signs of guilt/innocence reveal themselves.

E. Grimmy B.

To let go, or not to let go, that is the question.

unvote

But just because of the plus points and you get by having replaced.

[Skruffs]

Vote count

(11 players alive = 6 to lynch before deadline)
(2) Phoebus – Shy Guy, Jenter Brolincani
(1) donkeyz12212 – Phoebus
(1) Xanatos Roulette – Mr. Blonde

Not voting:

donkeyz12212, Grimmy, killa seven, SleepyPanda, water_foul, Xanatos Roulette, Korts

Deadline:

Thursday 22 May 6:00 PM (GMT -5 according to forum clock)

[Korts]

Oh, hey, Skruffs. For a long moment I thought this was justice justice. I really ought to get some sleep.