Alright, the deadline is looming and we need to lynch somebody. I vote silence (one of the players ) because he is lurking big time & not voting anybody. I have no idea if he is a scum or townie, but we need to pick somebody.
I cannot make up my mind regarding what I think about BlackWolf. It could perhaps make things easier, if you BlackWolf would cast your vote on somebody.
I haven't been commenting much as I don't have any good intuition to what is/isn't scummy and thus haven't a lot useful to say.
I don't want to place a vote now as it could help lynching someone (well, BlackWolf) prematurely. But I will place a vote before deadline if it enables a more favorable outcome.
At the moment my ranking of day outcomes would be to lynch (from most favorable to least favorable)
1. zu_Faul (explanation of my read in post 291)
2. Blackwolf (post 291)
3. weilawei (statement about helping scum in a newbie game and especially denying it)
4. Atticus (Claiming the roles might not be randomized in post 14)
5. Nocmen (Without reads I'd rather lynch an IC than a non-IC)
6. Mr. Blonde
7. Battousai
8. gorillaman (being voted by those I suspect most)
9. No lynch
10. me (well, obv.)
I think we should, if possible, agree before deadline who we are threatening so that he has time to claim (and on the other hand, so that no-one needs to claim unnecessarily). At this point obv. BlackWolf is under threat so if the situation doesn't change soon, he should claim if he is a powerrole.
I think you just put plenty of useful things: you gave your own rankings.
Well, I don't know who is scum and who is townie, but I'll stick my vote on silence for now - and I'm ready to change it if I see that sensible. silence has not participating in voting/fingerpointing so he might be scum lurking.
silence, I don't know if you are a scum, but the deadline is coming and we need people to vote.
Regarding blackwolf accusations: It's day 1 - we can't really tell who is the scum. It's pretty random no matter how much we go in circles, but it's best to pick somebody. I don't know who it could be, but I've thrown my vote to silence.
1a. Trying to run out the clock on the deadline. He disappears for a week from the 14th-21st, while active elsewhere; eventually returns on being prodded, where he makes some bullshit demand for Atticus to repeat his reasons instead of just going back a page and reading for himself, which buys him another two days lurking time.
1b. At least he has a vote on, but he's not doing anything to convice the town to join him. My guess, because he doesn't care who gets lynched as long as it isn't him or his teammate.
2a. Hiding behind his numbers. All this statistical gobbledygook looks like a way to conceal his motives.
2b. I also find little of substance in his other posts, except for his early accusations against Bat, which he seems to have abandoned.
Personally, I would most support lynching silence. He seems the scummiest, hopping in occasionally to repeat arguments and make it seem like he's contributing, and avoiding prods and seeming inactivity. When he posts, he hasn't realy voted for anybody, so if he helps lynch town he makes himself look more innocent.
But since I don't think anybody else will help vote, I'll help vote when deadline approaches. After all, any lynch has at least a chance of being scum.
Oh, and if you want me to claim, I'm a Vanilla. I get to be completely useless at night.
) because he is lurking big time & not voting anybody. I have no idea if he is a scum or townie, but we need to pick somebody.
