The Hobbit Mafia - GAME OVER

[mikehart]

Vote Count
Yggdrasil

- (1)

the silent speaker

Uraj45

- (1)

MMCL

MMCL

- (2)

Yggdrasil, CoolBot

the silent speaker

- (3)

Yaw, Talitha, Uraj45

[MMCL]

Seriously guys - I've had the week from hell... First my PC dies completely then I've been mega ill - my face is numb and Im feverish... Im shaking as I type this... going back to bed shortly. Don't replace me as I can help a lot more in this game.

[CoolBot]

Hope you feel better, MMCL. Since that seems like a legit reason,

unvote: MMCL
vote: the silent speaker

Tss has been spouting alot of crap, or least poorly reasoned, logic lately.

[Tigris]

Quick question for Coolbot, what is the name of your dwarf? Yes this has a small point and right now it's the only thing I can think of to go off of, but it might help the town.

[Talitha]

13 alive means 7 to lynch
TSS is at 4/7

(For my own reference) Players not voting:
AndrewS (replacing Shivan_Dragon)
Flying Dutchman
Jaylen
Quagmire (replacing Lord Gurgi)
Tigris
willows_weep (replacing Narninian)

[CoolBot]

The name's Bifur

[MMCL]

Unvote

I'm feeling a bit better now. Gonna re-read now and get back to you asap.

[mikehart]

Vote Count
Yggdrasil

- (1)

the silent speaker

MMCL

- (1)

Yggdrasil

the silent speaker

- (4)

Yaw, Talitha, Uraj45, CoolBot

[Quagmire]

Considering that it's 7 to lynch, and tss is only at 4, I'm going to go and hop on the bandwagon to get a claim from him. It's time to put the pressure on and see what you really are.

Vote: the silent speaker

[willows_weep]

There are factors to names?
K, since I didn't know names and such would be an intergral part I'll actually go look up information for myself.

[MMCL]

OK - I have re-read the whole lot...

Nothing major jumps out at me yet - however, I find it most curious that Tigris suggests that knowing Coolbot's dwarf name will help the town. Since Coolbot had already given his dwarf's name and it hadn't been countered it's either an attempt on Tigris' part to see if Coolbot gives a different dwarf... or an attempt by a Tigris to find a specific dwarf.
Im curious as to why Tigris didn't already know the name however since Coolbot had already given it and Yaw had reposted that Coolbot was Bifur in post #612 so it's not as if the dwarf name had been lost in any of the previous pages.

Since I'm inclined to believe Coolbot (no counter, ?Tigris' test failed?) then I would suggest that Tigris is a good bet for today.

Vote: Tigris

until we get an explanation.

[Yaw]

FOS: willows_weep

, as that last post was almost claiming she

doesn't

have a named role.

Otherwise, waiting on the role claim.

[Talitha]

Also waiting for TSS.

[the silent speaker]

I'm a dwarf, Bofur to be specific.

[Yaw]

Ok. Not TSS then. For reasons above, let's try door number 2.

Unvote: TSS

,

Vote: Quagmire

.

[Tigris]

Meh, I thought that Coolbot had claimed dwarf without a name and thought to better understand how a few things stood with said name, which now I do.

For now, I'm willing to follow Yaw, as I was suspicious of Gurgi, so

vote: quagmire

[Talitha]

unvote, vote: quagmire

[MMCL]

UNVOTE

OK - I am not convinced by Tigris' explanation - but I believe it requires further scrutiny.

This game seems to want to stall again, so I will add a vote for Quagmire... Lord Gurgi added nothing new, and neither really has Quagmire since he replaced LG...

Vote: Quagmire

[the silent speaker]

Unvote: Yggdrasil, vote: Quagmire

which makes by my count five of seven. Time to claim, Mr. Vietnam.

[Uraj45]

mmmph. i don't understand this one.

unvote: The silent speaker

[CoolBot]

unvote: the silent speaker

[willows_weep]

Hm?
I said I didn't know names were integral. Like when Tigris? asked someones name it would aid in ..whatever it is Tigris is/was doing.

Now knowing that I can take it upon myself to look up claimed names and check out the mod posts to see what its all about.
If it's a source of information should'nt everyone be aware of that?
I wasn't aware that it was important. I wasn't even aware that there were a bunch of different types(dwarves, trolls ,etc) .
Lately the theme games Im playing arent character based like that even with names and a theme.

More used to that for my mini themes.

'When you got no body to love'

[Jaylen]

Hrm - I've been away sorry, but I must say I'm not terribly convinced at the case against Quagmire.

Could someone do a quick recap, if they would be so kind? As I see it (unless I'm missing something, it is all based on Yaw's (admittedly good so far)) gut feeling.

So I'll wait a bit before voting, hopefully Quagmire will come up with something to say in order to miss a lynching.

[Yaw]

I don't do gut.

What I posted earlier about Lord Gurgi's behaviour day 1 that indicates possible goblishness was:

Lord Gurgi (now Quagmire) -- Never did vote for jediknight, despite clearly stating he didn't believe the claim. Didn't even express an intent to vote for jediknight in this circumstance. Went so far as to ask if others were going to vote or unvote with respect to the jedi-wagon.

That is, if you look over the posts from day 1, it looks like Lord Gurgi was paying lip service to the jediknight wagon, but was really trying to avoid actually being on it at all costs. It's really weird behaviour to ask if other people are going to lynch jediknight or not when you admit you think he's scum after a claim, and aren't on the bandwagon yourself.

[Jaylen]

Vote: Quagmire

Okay Yaw - I'm not convinced, but having read back, I can see what you are getting at, and since we have done so well so far, if he is a townie... well I hate to be nasty, but we can afford the loss.

I really think it's time Quagmire roleclaimed - He is now one vote away from a lynch.