so we're clear, i know i frequent the bar in the comic, and i also know that i drink in the comic, but my role pm doesn't mention drinking all.populartajo wrote: Lulu you know you drink in the bar but not for your PM, right?
not only that, why then does Cipher's role specifically say he doesn't?populartajo wrote: Then why is Alabaska the only one who has it specified in his role PM?
the question you have to ask yuorself here is, is alabaska lying or am i lying? because one of us definitely is, so insanity/paranoia is no longer an issue.mustafa15 wrote:Hey guys, I got back a little later than I anticipated, so I'll save a detailed analysis until tomorrow, but here are some quick and tired questions. Does anyone else want to counter-claim? If one of the two cops is lying, then I would assume that there would be another player with the role Cornelius or the creator. Well, definitely Cornelius, and I would assume the creator would be included, simply because my own role is a darn minor character. I'm pretty sure that I drink (Ketel One to be precise), and while this theme makes it pretty obvious that OG is telling the truth about her role, that doesn't mean that her investigations are correct. I doubt that DoS is scum, I instead think that there is some paranoia/insanity going on here.
And I also just want to say, this is a really cool game Nabakov, love how the role pms are playing a subtle role in the games, and it seems like the roles are pretty darn interesting too. [/suckup]
idk its like the first one of the day where i say he doesnt drink and vote him, this was after establishing that people who didnt drink were scum in my original claimGreasy Spot wrote:Alright so we have a claimed doc (DragonsofSummer) who investigated a Dead person. Can't tell if he is really truthful or not since we can't prove it. If he is the doc he will probably be targeted tonight.
OG claims to be the bartender and knows whether people are drinkers or not. Based on my PM (which says I'm a smoker) which doesn't say whether I drink or not, I think you may be reading into your flavor a little too much.
@ OG: By the way where is the post in which you called alabaska scum. I looked for it but wasn't sure which one you were referring to.
Well mine tells me not to drink too much but doesn't actually say I am drinking, just that I am a smoker (of the illegal flavor).OG Smokedank wrote:idk its like the first one of the day where i say he doesnt drink and vote him, this was after establishing that people who didnt drink were scum in my original claim
My problem is who told you that people that dont drink are scum? Is it specified in your PM? So, did you target Alabaska and the resul was "He doesnt drink"?OG Smokedank wrote:idk its like the first one of the day where i say he doesnt drink and vote him, this was after establishing that people who didnt drink were scum in my original claimGreasy Spot wrote:Alright so we have a claimed doc (DragonsofSummer) who investigated a Dead person. Can't tell if he is really truthful or not since we can't prove it. If he is the doc he will probably be targeted tonight.
OG claims to be the bartender and knows whether people are drinkers or not. Based on my PM (which says I'm a smoker) which doesn't say whether I drink or not, I think you may be reading into your flavor a little too much.
@ OG: By the way where is the post in which you called alabaska scum. I looked for it but wasn't sure which one you were referring to.
yes, I answered this question like5 fucking timespopulartajo wrote:My problem is who told you that people that dont drink are scum? Is it specified in your PM? So, did you target Alabaska and the resul was "He doesnt drink"?OG Smokedank wrote:idk its like the first one of the day where i say he doesnt drink and vote him, this was after establishing that people who didnt drink were scum in my original claimGreasy Spot wrote:Alright so we have a claimed doc (DragonsofSummer) who investigated a Dead person. Can't tell if he is really truthful or not since we can't prove it. If he is the doc he will probably be targeted tonight.
OG claims to be the bartender and knows whether people are drinkers or not. Based on my PM (which says I'm a smoker) which doesn't say whether I drink or not, I think you may be reading into your flavor a little too much.
@ OG: By the way where is the post in which you called alabaska scum. I looked for it but wasn't sure which one you were referring to.
I agree that someone is lying, though, and that this situation almost confirms someone as scum. There was no reason for lying.
I think that it is a very good possibility that neither of you are lying, but that you are paranoid, meaning that you will always get a result of not drinker. The way to find this out for sure is to investigate me tonight, as my role pm implies that I drink. If you find that I don't drink, than we can assume that you are paranoid, and if you find that I do drink, then we will need to do some more thinking. I agree that alabaska seemed a bit suspicious, but not enough to lynch right now when there is a doubt as to whether or not we can trust your investigations.OG Smokedank wrote:
the question you have to ask yuorself here is, is alabaska lying or am i lying? because one of us definitely is, so insanity/paranoia is no longer an issue.
once again: my investigation value is no longer a pertinent source for debate, since REGARDLESS of how much drink/not drink affects the setup, one of me or alabaska is lying. either alabaska is lying about his role (making him scum) or i am lying about my investigation result.
my argument: look at how alabaska reaccted when i called him scum. instead of trying to say i was lying and get me lynched, he tried to play off that i was lying about being roleblocked but was really just a townie. is this how YOU would have reacted if someone who claimed cop called you scum when you were town? no I doubt any of you would react like alabaska did.
are you fucking serious?mustafa15 wrote:I think that it is a very good possibility that neither of you are lying, but that you are paranoid, meaning that you will always get a result of not drinker. The way to find this out for sure is to investigate me tonight, as my role pm implies that I drink. If you find that I don't drink, than we can assume that you are paranoid, and if you find that I do drink, then we will need to do some more thinking. I agree that alabaska seemed a bit suspicious, but not enough to lynch right now when there is a doubt as to whether or not we can trust your investigations.OG Smokedank wrote:
the question you have to ask yuorself here is, is alabaska lying or am i lying? because one of us definitely is, so insanity/paranoia is no longer an issue.
once again: my investigation value is no longer a pertinent source for debate, since REGARDLESS of how much drink/not drink affects the setup, one of me or alabaska is lying. either alabaska is lying about his role (making him scum) or i am lying about my investigation result.
my argument: look at how alabaska reaccted when i called him scum. instead of trying to say i was lying and get me lynched, he tried to play off that i was lying about being roleblocked but was really just a townie. is this how YOU would have reacted if someone who claimed cop called you scum when you were town? no I doubt any of you would react like alabaska did.
@DoS, was there any flavor in your role pm about drinking, or are you just a basic cop?
I think it would make the most sense if tonight DoS investigated OG and OG investigated me, although I suppose that one of those two will be killed tonight by the mafia. The doc should obviously protect one of those two.
Does anyone else want to claim cop right now? Or cornelius or chris? This would be helpful/ insanely confusing
he's NOT a drinkerthinktank wrote:Its quite what possible that what Dragon says is true, the drinking could be the use of a night action because in your night pm it just says Alabaska is a drinker right? so hes not necessarily scum, but considering we have two claimed power roles already chances are if you are indeed a tracker than he could be scum.
Yes we do but we have the right to ask becuase you were that DUMB to believe that you were the cop when you weren't.OG wrote:does anybody fucking read my posts?
are you kidding me? how are we supposed to confirm that?? based on your merit?mustafa 15 wrote: The way to find this out for sure is to investigate me tonight, as my role pm implies that I drink. If you find that I don't drink, than we can assume that you are paranoid, and if you find that I do drink, then we will need to do some more thinking.
or musher is scum since he is assuming drinking is in mentioned in everyone's pm.Musher333 wrote:Only town could know it tells you in role pm, any1 else think this means populartajo is scum because he didnt know?
It was mentioned in mine and if i remember correctly OG's (presuming she didnt make it up and is scum with a cop claim)lulu muumuu wrote:or musher is scum since he is assuming drinking is in mentioned in everyone's pm.Musher333 wrote:Only town could know it tells you in role pm, any1 else think this means populartajo is scum because he didnt know?