Pick your Poison 3 (Game Over)

Patrick · Post Post #700 (ISO) » Mon May 26, 2008 1:56 pm

Votecount

armlx (1) -- Incognito
Xtoxm (6) -- scotmany12, Ether, elvis_knits, armlx, Sarcastro, farside22
scotmany12 (1) -- Xtoxm

Not voting: Coron, DrippingGoofball, Elmo, Gorrad, Flameaxe
13 alive, 7 to lynch.

Ether · Post Post #701 (ISO) » Mon May 26, 2008 2:16 pm

For all I say about {Xtoxmscum, Incogscum, Armlxscum in that order}, Farside makes me very uneasy.

Unvote

--we're not ending the day just yet.

Gorrad · Post Post #702 (ISO) » Mon May 26, 2008 2:32 pm

Gah! Sorry y'all. I've been busy beyond reason recently. I haven't forgotten the game, really, but I just haven't had time for a readthrough.

If anyone can summarise, that'd save me a LOT of trouble, otherwise I should be able to read soonish.

DrippingGoofball · Post Post #703 (ISO) » Mon May 26, 2008 2:51 pm

Am I the only one to think Coron is scummy?

Coron · Post Post #704 (ISO) » Mon May 26, 2008 3:16 pm

DrippingGoofball wrote:Am I the only one to think Coron is scummy?

I certainly don't

armlx · Post Post #705 (ISO) » Mon May 26, 2008 7:38 pm

Elmo wrote:INCOG IS TOWN, LET'S TAKE THIS SOMEPLACE USEFUL

Second this.

Also, DGB, Coron is Coron.

elvis_knits · Post Post #706 (ISO) » Tue May 27, 2008 12:13 pm

I also think farside has high probability of being the scumzor.

farside22 · Post Post #707 (ISO) » Tue May 27, 2008 1:01 pm

You know I have 2 people saying I'm scummie, but no reason. This doesn't help.

Incognito · Post Post #708 (ISO) » Tue May 27, 2008 1:59 pm

This was a serious question, and I'd like for you to answer it:

Incognito, at farside22 in post 698, wrote:Excuse me, but what's scummy about a "hissy fit"? Do you actually think that scum are more likely to act in that way than town? If so, can you cite specific examples from previous games you've been in that display that to be true? Because otherwise, I think you're talking out of your ass.

Anyway, this was the largest wagon that formed on me all game that happened during Day 1:

Incognito (8) --

Ether (alignment unknown)

,

Sarcastro (alignment unknown)

, q21 (town), Mellowed Man (town), babygirl86 (town),

Dave (alignment unknown)

, mr. incrediball (town), ashmite84 (alignment unknown and now Xtoxm)

This was the end of Day 1 wagon that formed on Mellowed Man:

Mellowed Man (10) --

Ether (alignment unknown)

, Elmo (alignment unknown),

armlx (alignment unknown)

, q21 (town), mr. incrediball (town),

Flameaxe (alignment unknown)

, babygirl86 (town),

Sarcastro (alignment unknown)

, Coron (alignment unknown),

Dave (alignment unknown)

This was the end of Day 2 wagon that formed on q21:

q21 (8) -- scotmany12 (alignment unknown), JDodge (town),

Sarcastro (alignment unknown)

, DrippingGoofball (alignment unknown subbed in for Marmalade), elvis_knits (alignment unknown subbed in for Inquisitor), farside22 (alignment unknown subbed in for starkmoon),

Flameaxe (alignment unknown)

,

armlx (alignment unknown)

The common denominator of the "alignment unknowns" on all of these wagons has been bolded in red.

The common denominator of the "alignment unknowns" on two of these wagons have been bolded in blue.

If you ask me, I think Sarcastro, armlx, or Flameaxe would make excellent lynches for today based on the fact that they've been on these wagons and haven't done a very good job of convincing me that they're town anyway. I still think Ether is likely town based on her play in this game thus far, and I'm still waiting for

something

from Gorrad to get a better feel for what Dave might have been doing within this game. I still feel like his self-vote in response to the votes that accumulated on him is more likely to come from newb town rather than newb scum though. farside22 feels really scummy to me thus far as do Coron and DGB. I'd certainly like to see much more from each of them as well.

Ether · Post Post #709 (ISO) » Tue May 27, 2008 2:04 pm

Post 707, Farside wrote:You know I have 2 people saying I'm scummie, but no reason. This doesn't help.

gut

armlx · Post Post #710 (ISO) » Tue May 27, 2008 2:12 pm

Ether wrote:
Post 707, Farside wrote:You know I have 2 people saying I'm scummie, but no reason. This doesn't help.
gut

Fail. Gut is never a valid reason. Gut always means there is something there, or gut is that you are scum and are working with extra info.

Ether · Post Post #711 (ISO) » Tue May 27, 2008 2:16 pm

Okay.

She's lurking, she jumps in on my conclusions at the end but never really scumhunts, and even if she's right, bussing doesn't require much effort in a game where the investigative roles are presumably all dead.

Ether · Post Post #712 (ISO) » Tue May 27, 2008 2:17 pm

What about me?

Why am I scummy, Armlx?

Ether · Post Post #713 (ISO) » Tue May 27, 2008 3:31 pm

Heeeeeeeeeey...

armlx · Post Post #714 (ISO) » Tue May 27, 2008 3:35 pm

Supported 2 shot vig, pushing the Incog wagon, swapped off the Incog wagon on the basis of a "trap" (which never actually work except to catch lazy players, town and scum), not giving off town tells and hence being on the list by process of elimination.

scotmany12 · Post Post #715 (ISO) » Wed May 28, 2008 10:58 am

armlx wrote:Supported 2 shot vig, pushing the Incog wagon, swapped off the Incog wagon on the basis of a "trap" (which never actually work except to catch lazy players, town and scum), not giving off town tells and hence being on the list by process of elimination.

q21 also supported the 2 shot vig, so did coron, who you find town. I don't think you can use that as a scum tell anymore. The incog wagon was a bad wagon...her getting off of it is not scummy. She was not the only one to get off of it. Ether is acting pretty protown in this game. I really don't see your case on her.

scotmany12 · Post Post #716 (ISO) » Wed May 28, 2008 10:59 am

Oh, and I know I have been guilty of this too, but can we have more people posting? We need more activity from practically everyone...

Elmo · Post Post #717 (ISO) » Wed May 28, 2008 11:05 am

<-- bored with this game, don't wait for me to reread to end the day with xtoxm/armlx death

armlx · Post Post #718 (ISO) » Wed May 28, 2008 11:29 am

scotmany12 wrote: q21 also supported the 2 shot vig, so did coron, who you find town. I don't think you can use that as a scum tell anymore.

Yeah, but them I can cut slack for it. I expect Ether to automatically know better.

The incog wagon was a bad wagon...her getting off of it is not scummy. She was not the only one to get off of it.

Yet she is still pushing him as scum today. Also, its even scummy how she got off it. "Traps" aren't a real strategy play unless they involve trapping in role based info.

scotmany12 · Post Post #719 (ISO) » Wed May 28, 2008 11:32 am

armlx wrote:
scotmany12 wrote: q21 also supported the 2 shot vig, so did coron, who you find town. I don't think you can use that as a scum tell anymore.
Yeah, but them I can cut slack for it. I expect Ether to automatically know better.

Um, coron has been along longer than ether...longer than you even. Why does he deserve slack over ether?

armlx · Post Post #720 (ISO) » Wed May 28, 2008 11:35 am

scotmany12 wrote:
armlx wrote:
scotmany12 wrote: q21 also supported the 2 shot vig, so did coron, who you find town. I don't think you can use that as a scum tell anymore.
Yeah, but them I can cut slack for it. I expect Ether to automatically know better.
Um, coron has been along longer than ether...longer than you even. Why does he deserve slack over ether?

Have you read anything Coron has posted in this game or ever?

armlx · Post Post #721 (ISO) » Wed May 28, 2008 11:35 am

EBWODP: I'm not trying to be offensive Coron, but I definitely view Ether as a higher tier of player than you.

elvis_knits · Post Post #722 (ISO) » Wed May 28, 2008 11:52 am

farside22 wrote:You know I have 2 people saying I'm scummie, but no reason. This doesn't help.

I guess it's just your low-volume, non-helpfulness. All your posts have been basically one-liners, and not insightful at that.

farside22 · Post Post #723 (ISO) » Wed May 28, 2008 1:11 pm

elvis_knits wrote:
farside22 wrote:You know I have 2 people saying I'm scummie, but no reason. This doesn't help.
I guess it's just your low-volume, non-helpfulness. All your posts have been basically one-liners, and not insightful at that.

I'm pretty much like that in all my games, but I understand. I jump on those who do the same.
As for incog hissy fit. You were close to being lynched day one. You get all indigent and say you wish to be replaced. People start to unvote you and ah shucks you decided to not be replaced after all. It could have been a ploy to garner people from voting against you. That is why I find you hissy fit scummie.

Gorrad · Post Post #724 (ISO) » Wed May 28, 2008 1:45 pm

Halfway through my readthrough. So for it seems like Incog and Coron are fairly obvious scumbuddies. EK has some serious strikes too, including the whole pretend to not know that scum don't know the supersaint bit and JL's one post. I'm getting bad vibes from Scot.

I replaced an idiot. Joyous.

Sarc and Armlx are totally pro-town.

Xtoxm, it should be pointed out, is lurking a lot more than is typical of him. He's usually posting all the time. Not sure if this is a scumtell, but it's different from the townplay I usually see from him.

Pages 16-29 come after this commercial break