Gorrad[4]: (Tarhalindur, Toaster Strudel, Gorrad, Surye)
Not Voting[6]: (Kison, the silent speaker, shaft.ed, pickemgenius, elias_the_thief, Machiavellian-Mafia)
I actually like the directed kill idea. It's an extra lynch for the cycle basically. I say we keep Gorrad around for the time being and see if two candidates come up during the course of today. If not we lynch him.the silent speaker wrote:I wouldn't consider it bastardmoddery as long as there are no disadvantages to the role -- it's basically a naive cop with no risk of getting an innocent read on a scum -- but I think Gorrad needs to get voted regardless of which he is, unless we want to just assume he's the SK and allow him to live so long as his kills are directed. Dunno if that would be a great idea though, though I tend to like that sort of risk-taking.
I say we examine those resistant to the Rosso lynch. Seems like a logical place to start.Surye wrote:Well, we have plenty of time, so lets just go with the idea of finding two other candidates, and then if nothing presents it self clearly, or if more against Gorrad comes up, we can just lynch him. Either way we need more activity to move forward.
Good idea, doing so now myself.shaft.ed wrote:I say we examine those resistant to the Rosso lynch. Seems like a logical place to start.Surye wrote:Well, we have plenty of time, so lets just go with the idea of finding two other candidates, and then if nothing presents it self clearly, or if more against Gorrad comes up, we can just lynch him. Either way we need more activity to move forward.
Meh I don't know Gorrad's play very well, but if he's a SK his only miniscule chance of winning is to perform a directed kill. I also still leave about a 10-15% chance that he is in fact a pro-town vig, in which case he would abide by the town's judgement or perhaps take a shot in the dark if he feels the consensus wrong.Surye wrote:EBWOP: And in line with that idea,Unvotehowever, I would like to say I don't think Gorrad is a good person to keep alive, but if we lynch someone tonight, he'll be just as likely to hit scum as we will at night as a townie, and we can lynch him tomorrow. My only fear is if he is an SK, he knows even if he follows the night kill directive tonight, he must die tomorrow, so I don't know if it's in his best interest to try to hit town or mafia if he doesn't follow it. My guess is he would follow it for sure on the off chance someone pushes the vig idea again, so letting him live risks that if he is an SK.
It's a hard call. But what I've come down to is this, in any case, he will follow the directed kill (most likely) and he must die tomorrow on policy. Or we could lynch him today and not risk a double town kill.
Already stated I did not like this post, it seems like he was hoping his non-vote would prevent a deadline lynch, and he setup an alibi for not having to take responsibility. Note it's wednesday and we have yet to hear from him.Elias_the_thief wrote:I seem to remember Rosso playing like this before, but I'm not certain.
Anyways, I'm gonna be gone until Monday.
Then again Tar posted when it would not have mattered, but I still get some pro-town feel from it.Surye wrote:Already stated I did not like this post, it seems like he was hoping his non-vote would prevent a deadline lynch, and he setup an alibi for not having to take responsibility. Note it's wednesday and we have yet to hear from him.Elias_the_thief wrote:I seem to remember Rosso playing like this before, but I'm not certain.
Anyways, I'm gonna be gone until Monday.
I'm liking Tar right now. If he were scum, he would have had a prime oppertunity to bus an already doomed buddy, but instead he helped prevent a no-lynch while not just "going with the wagon".
FoS: Elias
No no no, that's not what I'm saying. Though I guess since I actually am sitting down and thinking about what I said, bastard moddery wouldn't really qualify in this case. I was more or less pointing out that "chainsawing" is typically a Serial Killer MI(right?). Giving that MI to a vigilante would throw people off.the silent speaker wrote:I wouldn't consider it bastardmoddery as long as there are no disadvantages to the role -- it's basically a naive cop with no risk of getting an innocent read on a scum -- but I think Gorrad needs to get voted regardless of which he is, unless we want to just assume he's the SK and allow him to live so long as his kills are directed. Dunno if that would be a great idea though, though I tend to like that sort of risk-taking.
OK given that I believe Tar, and Rosso is dead. the bolded players above need to go under the microscope. I think good odds on scum being amongst those four.Guardian wrote:Gorrad[1] (Toaster Strudel)
Xtoxm[1] (pickemgenius)
shaft.ed[1] (Tarhalindur)
Not Voting[3]: (the silent speaker, Rosso Carne,elias_the_thief)
I'd like to see if anyone else sees what I'm seeing before I tell you my reasoning.Surye wrote:Hmm... any particular motivation? I see his isolated posts makes up less then a page, so I may do another full rundown in a bit tonight.shaft.ed wrote:and I choose the silent speaker
vote: the silent speaker