Mafia 78: Meta Breaking Mafia 1 - Game over!

[shaft.ed]

What I'd like to know is why did you not put up a post during the Rosso bandwagon?

Because it built up on a Friday afternoon.

And you have two posts on site in the thick of it with nothing here if I'm not mistaken.

[shaft.ed]

I think Kison may have outed himself with that slip up.

FOS Kison

[Kison]

What slip? Voting Tar?

[Guardian]

Vote Count #36

Tarhalindur[1]: (Gorrad)
Gorrad[1]: (Toaster Strudel)
the silent speaker[1]: (shaft.ed)
Toaster Strudel[1]: (Tarhalindur)


Not Voting[6]: (the silent speaker, pickemgenius, elias_the_thief, Machiavellian-Mafia, Surye, Kison)

[Gorrad]

Yeah, I kinda spaced too ><. Sorry, mind's still reeling a bit from three days of con.

In other new, 901 SUCKS.

Unvote, Vote: shaft.ed

[shaft.ed]

Yeah, I kinda spaced too ><. Sorry, mind's still reeling a bit from three days of con.

In other new, 901 SUCKS.

Unvote, Vote: shaft.ed

I find it a bit of a coincidence that he makes a case against Tar right after your vote.

[Kison]

I would hardly call what my post "making a case", but if it was then that'd be further indication that my post had nothing to do with Gorrad's, considering the time gap between our two posts :

Posted: Sun Jun 01, 2008 8:03 pm
Posted: Sun Jun 01, 2008 8:17 pm

But in reality, if you take note of my recent activity in this game(where I even noted I'd be busy for a few days), I was refreshing and catching up and found a few things I found interesting, that post being the main thing. I do remember Tar claiming cop but I had forgotten at the time, likely, aside from not having been fresh on this game, due to the fact that we had four(?) roleclaims yesterday, Gorrad's being the main focus.

[Kison]

Also, I find it insulting you think I'd try to lynch a claimed cop without good reason. <3

[shaft.ed]

there's a reason it's just a FoS. Over-offense noted.

[Kison]

Note it all you like, I am slightly insulted you think I'd try to make such an outrageous move as scum.

there's a reason it's just a FoS.

I think Kison may have outed himself with that slip up.

Pretty hefty FoS over such a little thing if you ask me.

[shaft.ed]

I'm so sorry for insulting you by pointing out a scum motiviation for your play. Will you ever forgive me?

[Kison]

No.

[Kison]

Anyway, shafty, I'm not exactly crying, here. It's more that what you're suggesting is so outrageous that you honestly can't believe I'd try to do that unless you thought I was a complete idiot, which would be insulting. I think you're just mull headed and didn't think it through!

You know I <3 you though.

[shaft.ed]

Anyway, shafty, I'm not exactly crying, here. It's more that what you're suggesting is so outrageous that you honestly can't believe I'd try to do that unless you thought I was a complete idiot, which would be insulting. I think you're just mull headed and didn't think it through!

You know I <3 you though.

No I did think it through. The big lie is the easiest one to pull off because no one thinks the liar would be capable of such a thing. Just because something is overtly scummy doesn't mean someone wouldn't do it.

[Kison]

What would my motivation be? Trick everyone and hope they all forgot that he claimed cop?

[shaft.ed]

What would my motivation be? Trick everyone and hope they all forgot that he claimed cop?

Your motiviation is that you forgot he was the cop and you saw support for suspicion in the previous post.

[Kison]

Then if I legitimately forgot, what then would be my "big lie"?

[pickemgenius]

IN COLORADO AGAIN LIMITED ACCESS.



*finding a house is more important*

[shaft.ed]

Then if I legitimately forgot, what then would be my "big lie"?

the cover up

[Kison]

Your logic is contradicting itself. What would my cover up be? Claiming that I forgot about the role claim. Yet the condition is "if I legitimately forgot" about the role claim. How can I legitimately forget and be lying about forgetting at the same time?

[shaft.ed]

Your logic is contradicting itself. What would my cover up be? Claiming that I forgot about the role claim. Yet the condition is "if I legitimately forgot" about the role claim. How can I legitimately forget and be lying about forgetting at the same time?

The lie is this indignation on the fainting couch that anyone should suspect you for making the slip up in the first place.

[Kison]

I can understand someone suspecting me for that if they didn't think it through. The problem I have right now with you is that you claim you've thought it through while simultaneously failing to point out the thinking process and how the vote and unvote(which is what you FoS'd me for) make me any more likely to be scum while continuing to support it.

Again, your FoS was hefty : "I think Kison may have outed himself with that slip up."

My entire point was that there is no motive for me, as scum, to try to get Tar lynched if I

knew

he claimed cop. Your response to that was that "The big lie is the easiest one to pull off because no one thinks the liar would be capable of such a thing." Now you're claiming my "lie" is something that came

AFTER

the very incident you based your FoS on in the first place.

[the silent speaker]

And you have two posts on site in the thick of it with nothing here if I'm not mistaken.

I can

post

on Fridays. I can't post Friday evenings and Saturdays. On Fridays I don't have time for much beyond surface extemporanea that I happen to notice, because the oncoming Sabbath gives time constraints. So I will make some short posts (depending on how early the sun sets) but not extensive comments. I happened not to make a short post in this thread that day; it's not beyond the pale of possibility that I forgot to check the thread altogether.

[shaft.ed]

Anyway, shafty, I'm not exactly crying, here. It's more that what you're suggesting is so outrageous that you honestly

can't believe I'd try to do that

unless you thought I was a complete idiot, which would be insulting. I think you're just mull headed and didn't think it through!

You know I <3 you though.

No I did think it through. The big lie is the easiest one to pull off because no one thinks the liar would be capable of such a thing. Just because something is overtly scummy doesn't mean someone wouldn't do it.

Bah, it's an improper analogy to the situation. I blame your bolded portion. It's clear from my first post using the phrase "slip up" that I did not think you were actually trying to lynch the cop. I pointed out that you were piling on suspicion to a player that had just been accused, in a rather sloppy fashion since he was the claimed cop.

And since when did FoS's become such a big deal to you? You're pushing on that FoS as if it were an L-2 vote.

[Kison]

And since when did FoS's become such a big deal to you? You're pushing on that FoS as if it were an L-2 vote.

Well, like I said, your FoS seems fairly hefty because of the line proceeding it, and I don't get that since I don't view what I did as very indicative of me being scum. Mildly suspicious, perhaps.