Mini 588: Achewood Mafia - Game Over!

[Musher333]

Sorry, just got out of hospital earlier today, im up for claiming though it may be tomorrow so i have a bit of time to rest.

[Greasy Spot]

hurry up and claim, i'm waiting for you guys *yawn*

What was you claim again?

I am Teador.

[OG Smokedank]

hurry up and claim, i'm waiting for you guys *yawn*

What was you claim again?

don't quit your day job

[Greasy Spot]

hurry up and claim, i'm waiting for you guys *yawn*

What was you claim again?

don't quit your day job

??

[NabakovNabakov]

Vote Count as of Post 428

All:

None

None:

All

4 to lynch.

Musher prodded

[lulu muumuu]

i'm molly sanders, vanilla townie.

[mustafa15]

I'm tina (ray's girlfriend), vanilla townie

[thinktank]

I am Emiril: Townie.

[OG Smokedank]

if you have a power role, you guys should be claiming it.

[Musher333]

I am Cassandra (Roast Beef) (Molly's Boyfriend) Vanilla Townie

[mustafa15]

if you have a power role, you guys should be claiming it.

I don't see how claiming doctor would be a good thing, as the doctor is busy saving you at night and would be killed by the sk...

[Musher333]

if you have a power role, you guys should be claiming it.

I don't see how claiming doctor would be a good thing, as the doctor is busy saving you at night and would be killed by the sk...

Just to add to this this seems like quite a bad case of role-fishing, we have no proof of OG being the bartender or if she is that they are pro-town, although i hope she is so then we have some type of power role to help us (with the cop being dead they can't) find out who the SK'er is.

[populartajo]

I am Philippe's Mother. Vanilla Townie.
Bah. As I thought the majority of the roles left are vanilla townies, besides OG. However, the way we have claimed and our name claims tell us big information of who could be lying and who isnt. A principal character that isnt counterclaimed is pretty much confirmed, IMO.

I did a bit of research to find out whose claim seems more believable. For now, we have.

mustafa15

tina (ray's girlfriend), vanilla townie.

mmmm, not so confirmed @mustafa15 did you research, do you have any acknowledge of the flavor?

populartajo

Philippe's Mother , vanilla townie.

I know Im confirmed

lulu muumuu

molly sanders, vanilla townie.

Pretty much confirmed

Musher333

Cassandra (Roast Beef) (Molly's Boyfriend) Vanilla Townie

I'd like to say confirmed although I dont know if "Molly's boyfriend" was added in your PM. @Musher did you research, do you have any acknowledge of the flavor?

Greasy Spot

I am Teador.

Pretty much confirmed

thinktank

Emiril: Townie.

mmmm, not so confirmed

OG Smokedank

i'm cornelius the bartender, my role is basically cop, every night i get to see if someone is a drinker there or not.

Pretty much confirmed

Ok, so far we should look to these three guys : thinktank, mustafa and Musher. Greasy, lulu and OG have believable claims and they were the first to claim.

[Musher333]

I am Philippe's Mother. Vanilla Townie.
Bah. As I thought the majority of the roles left are vanilla townies, besides OG. However, the way we have claimed and our name claims tell us big information of who could be lying and who isnt. A principal character that isnt counterclaimed is pretty much confirmed, IMO.

I did a bit of research to find out whose claim seems more believable. For now, we have.

mustafa15

tina (ray's girlfriend), vanilla townie.

mmmm, not so confirmed @mustafa15 did you research, do you have any acknowledge of the flavor?

populartajo

Philippe's Mother , vanilla townie.

I know Im confirmed

lulu muumuu

molly sanders, vanilla townie.

Pretty much confirmed

Musher333

Cassandra (Roast Beef) (Molly's Boyfriend) Vanilla Townie

I'd like to say confirmed although I dont know if "Molly's boyfriend" was added in your PM. @Musher did you research, do you have any acknowledge of the flavor?

Greasy Spot

I am Teador.

Pretty much confirmed

thinktank

Emiril: Townie.

mmmm, not so confirmed

OG Smokedank

i'm cornelius the bartender, my role is basically cop, every night i get to see if someone is a drinker there or not.

Pretty much confirmed

Ok, so far we should look to these three guys : thinktank, mustafa and Musher. Greasy, lulu and OG have believable claims and they were the first to claim.

Well i researched to see as you were in that post who could be lying and i found that my character was with someone, i thought it might be helpful due to flavour so i added it into my claim.

[thinktank]

Populartjo, what exactly are you basing your analysis of who is "pretty much confirmed" and who is suspicious.

[populartajo]

First ones to claim principal character's names. And with no counterclaims. I assume there are more probabilities of having a principal character than a minor one.

[OG Smokedank]

First ones to claim principal character's names. And with no counterclaims. I assume there are more probabilities of having a principal character than a minor one.

this doesnt mean anything, for all we know a principal character could have been given as a fakeclaim

[thinktank]

That logic in quite craptacular indeed. You are making assumptions based on no factual evidence what so ever, the fact that you may use that as an argument to lynch someone is both stupid as well as scummy. Pretty much everything in your "analysis" is based on assumptions with no actual base in reality and are just speculation. Remember, when you assume, you make an ass, out of u and me.

[populartajo]

First ones to claim principal character's names. And with no counterclaims. I assume there are more probabilities of having a principal character than a minor one.

this doesnt mean anything, for all we know a principal character could have been given as a fakeclaim

It could but I doubt it.
Do you think lulu, Greasy Spot and OG, asumming one of them is the SK, would claim knowing that there could be another person claiming that principal role?
Geez, its not so hard.

[populartajo]

That logic in quite craptacular indeed. You are making assumptions based on no factual evidence what so ever, the fact that you may use that as an argument to lynch someone is both stupid as well as scummy. Pretty much everything in your "analysis" is based on assumptions with no actual base in reality and are just speculation. Remember, when you assume, you make an ass, out of u and me.

Ok, Einstein, give me another way to get information of this mass claim.

[mustafa15]

That logic in quite craptacular indeed. You are making assumptions based on no factual evidence what so ever, the fact that you may use that as an argument to lynch someone is both stupid as well as scummy. Pretty much everything in your "analysis" is based on assumptions with no actual base in reality and are just speculation. Remember, when you assume, you make an ass, out of u and me.

No, you aren't reading what he's saying well enough. Characters like Roast Beef and Teodor are so important to achewood that there is no way that the mod wouldn't have put these characters in the game. If someone claimes Roast Beef and nobody counterclaims, then they must be Roast Beef, and since RB is a protagonist, it is really doubtful that he would be scum, therefore Musher is 90% confirmed innocent.

Also, there are 7 people left, we have all role-claimed. We've pretty much established that Nice Pete is a character, and that he is the sk. Also, Lyle hasn't been claimed yet, and I would assume that he would be in the game. I could definetly see him as scum, he's on the same level of dickiness (dickyness? dickieness?) as Todd was, so I think that this is a likely scenario.

While I know you'd like to confirm yourself, populartajo, your role is small enough that it could be a very good fake claim, especially considering that she is the only claimed character that doesn't live near ray *raises eyebrows*. This certainly isn't lynch-worthy evidence, but you are nowhere near confirmed.

Therefore, the people that I would say aren't confirmed are me, populartajo, and thinktank. I would say that thinktank is the choice for today, the post I quoted above seems pretty darn defensive, and emiril is a pretty unlikely character (I realize that this is a case of the pot calling the kettle black, but whatever)

vote:thinktank

[populartajo]

That logic in quite craptacular indeed. You are making assumptions based on no factual evidence what so ever, the fact that you may use that as an argument to lynch someone is both stupid as well as scummy. Pretty much everything in your "analysis" is based on assumptions with no actual base in reality and are just speculation. Remember, when you assume, you make an ass, out of u and me.

No, you aren't reading what he's saying well enough. Characters like Roast Beef and Teodor are so important to achewood that there is no way that the mod wouldn't have put these characters in the game. If someone claimes Roast Beef and nobody counterclaims, then they must be Roast Beef, and since RB is a protagonist, it is really doubtful that he would be scum, therefore Musher is 90% confirmed innocent.

Also, there are 7 people left, we have all role-claimed. We've pretty much established that Nice Pete is a character, and that he is the sk. Also, Lyle hasn't been claimed yet, and I would assume that he would be in the game. I could definetly see him as scum, he's on the same level of dickiness (dickyness? dickieness?) as Todd was, so I think that this is a likely scenario.

While I know you'd like to confirm yourself, populartajo, your role is small enough that it could be a very good fake claim, especially considering that she is the only claimed character that doesn't live near ray *raises eyebrows*. This certainly isn't lynch-worthy evidence, but you are nowhere near confirmed.

Therefore, the people that I would say aren't confirmed are me, populartajo, and thinktank. I would say that thinktank is the choice for today, the post I quoted above seems pretty darn defensive, and emiril is a pretty unlikely character (I realize that this is a case of the pot calling the kettle black, but whatever)

vote:thinktank

I like this post. I wrote in my post that I was confirmed because I know Im town. Im glad you understand my point and I agree that thinktank's role, as yours and mine, are a little off. I thought it was a good way to start decent conversation and scumhunting.
Im going to vote thinktank unless he gives me a good damn reason for not to.

[OG Smokedank]

First ones to claim principal character's names. And with no counterclaims. I assume there are more probabilities of having a principal character than a minor one.

this doesnt mean anything, for all we know a principal character could have been given as a fakeclaim

It could but I doubt it.
Do you think lulu, Greasy Spot and OG, asumming one of them is the SK, would claim knowing that there could be another person claiming that principal role?
Geez, its not so hard.

what i'm saying is that the sk might have a "good name" to fakeclaim under, like a role that isnt in the game that the mod set aside.

thinktank/greasy spot are you both vanilla?

[OG Smokedank]

support for a "good name" theory is that alabaska had a fakeclaim that wasnt in the game, he could have gotten lucky guessing but i doubt it

[populartajo]

support for a "good name" theory is that alabaska had a fakeclaim that wasnt in the game, he could have gotten lucky guessing but i doubt it

Do you realize that he actually claimed Cipher's (scum) role?