Mushroom Kingdom Mafia (Game over!)

[skitzer]

Sorry...I'm happy with my vote on Rogue. I think his jump is way more suspicious then Cream.

Mod edit:
Visible votecount:
Cream147 (6): armlx, Phoebus, Alabaska J, Gimbo, TheSweatpantsNinja, killa seven
TheSweatpantsNinja (2): Riceballtail, iamausername
Alabaska J (2): populartajo, farside22
somestrangeflea (1): Dead Rikimaru
Rogue Shenanigans (1): skitzer

No lynch (1): malthusis

Not voting (11): Surye, andersonw, Pepsidude, Cream147, FaerieLord, Celebloki, mr. incrediball, Rogue Shenanigans, DragonsofSummer, somestrangeflea, sideney

With 24 alive it takes 13 real votes to lynch. At deadline, it takes 7 real votes to lynch.

[iamausername]

-MafiaSSK
-alvinz95

I believe these two have been replaced. Not that we've heard anything much from their replacements, either.

[Gimbo]

Sorry...I'm happy with my vote on Rogue. I think his jump is way more suspicious then Cream.

I know what you meant, I forgot the exact detail of who he jumped from and to but yea, I see what you are saying. But apparently, the rest of town is ignoring this.

[Riceballtail]

Apologies, I must have missed this when I posted I would be on V/LA...

Anyway, as far as right now goes, I still don't see much beneficial discussion. There's too much beating around the bush, with not enough content.

@Gimbo: Lurker hunting will help, but lurking doesn't always make you scum. I strongly doubt we have 10 scum in this game, but I could be wrong too. I don't think you would be scum for having that item, but you certainly earned the attention of a lot of scum with that extra info.

unvote
vote:surye

for revealing that. It was fairly scummy, and I don't like it.

[Gimbo]

^ if you mean revealing the scumminess of the 1-UP shroom. I don't see how that is wrong in anyway in hindsight because if he had deliberately no mention this fact (since me and him obviosuly had no previous agreement on what to do), it would be a little weird and I would question WHY he wouldn't even mention it. If he had revealed the entire thing then I would've also asked him why also. By basically telling everyone that it exists but then nto actually revealing is a good medium between the two.


......

...
or I'm just an extremely misinformed townie playing right into Surye's hands.....or maybe Cream is your scumbuddy (meaning you, Riceballtail) and you are trying to direct the attention from Cream, all sorts of possibilities.

[killa seven]

mod prod gimbo

[Gimbo]

killa seven -> don't try that in this game, Lawrencelot might think you have some kind of mental illness and is retarded.

[Surye]

Apologies, I must have missed this when I posted I would be on V/LA...

Anyway, as far as right now goes, I still don't see much beneficial discussion. There's too much beating around the bush, with not enough content.

@Gimbo: Lurker hunting will help, but lurking doesn't always make you scum. I strongly doubt we have 10 scum in this game, but I could be wrong too. I don't think you would be scum for having that item, but you certainly earned the attention of a lot of scum with that extra info.

unvote
vote:surye

for revealing that. It was fairly scummy, and I don't like it.

Hint, when at claim or die, as much information as possible should be put on the table. The fate of the item and Gimbo was being discussed, the town needs to be informed, I gave Gimbo the courtesy to elaborate.

I like the Cream wagon, it's making him squirm. But it's not time for a lynch on him yet. Probably not today.

I think a FL wagon should be pushed. He made premature statements at not even halfway to a lynch, who's words were clearly intended to make the town think they had a consensus. Which we don't.

Vote: FaerieLord

[armlx]

Mod, maybe some prods would be in due order as per the list Gimbo posted (minus those who have posted since then and what not).

[Lawrencelot]

Rogue Shenanigans, somestrangeflea, mr. incrediball and DragonsofSummer have been prodded.

Pepsidude and Dead Rikimaru will be replaced unless they post immediately.

Deadline is in 1 week! Let's say... wednesday at 6 PM GMT. A reminder of the rules at deadline:

If the day ends because of a deadline, the real votecount is not showed, whether a lynch happens or not. At deadline, the amount of real votes needed for a lynch is half the amount of real votes normally needed for a lynch (rounded up), but only the visible votes are shown.

The real votecount will only be shown if the day ends before deadline.

[Cream147]

popular's lurking is noted, due to the fact that he is perfectly active in other games.

[somestrangeflea]

Since you are still questionign my alignment, think of it this way. finding even a single scum is hard enough in mafia games, why would a scum be given an item that could potentially allow them to revive a dead player.

There could be a bunch of possible reasons. "To balance pro-town items", "To balance pro-town coin count" are just a few.

Im feeling really lazy atm.
Care to explain me why are you voting for him?

Well at least you're honest...
Also note: If you don't do your own research, you're susceptable to mindless bandwaggoning. I think you could be setting yourself up to hop on.

FoS: Pop

SO why not you?

I call "Burden of proof"...

Cream, the town wants you dead. So no, it is not being opportunistic. It is following the town's lead. Which in this case is a null-tell

Last I heard it was mindless bandwaggoning...
Also note: As previously mentioned, "the town wants you dead" is bullshit.

FoS: FL

being too town sometimes is a good scum-tell.

I certainly have not been too townie this game lol. I am aware that it is often a good tell,

X

"Too Townie", is a very well documented piece of bullshit logic.

Deadline approaching, this post needs a vote.

I can see the logic behind a Cream wagon, but I feel there are better lynches today. I agree with Surye. FL needs to be examined more, and quickly too.

Vote: FL

[Rogue Shenanigans]

Gimbp is still acting the fool i see.

Anyway, I agree that FL could use some pressure and I see FL as a better lynch than Cream today.

vote:FaerieLord

[FaerieLord]

Ironic no? Rogue just came to vote me, when he barely posted because he was under pressure.

As for that, I already said that I thought there was more to that bandwagon than there apparently is. I also, pushed it without voting because I rarely vote, it's that simple. I'm not even for a cream lynch, I'd honestly rather have more time to discuss, but I thought he was almost next to claim range

[Cream147]

"Too Townie", is a very well documented piece of bullshit logic.

I've read that before lol. Obviously didn't stick in my mind.

[farside22]

Sorry...I'm happy with my vote on Rogue. I think his jump is way more suspicious then Cream.

This comment and Rogue newest and greatest moment has me agreeing with Skitzer (

writes in journal of a freek accident where I agreed with Skitzer. Then called hell and asked if it was cold down there).

unvote:
vote: Rogue

[Rogue Shenanigans]

My "newest and greatest moment" came after being prodded and looking for a place to put my lonley vote. With a deadline coming up I don't feel comfortable with a no-vote.

Don't read too much into it.

[farside22]

My "newest and greatest moment" came after being prodded and looking for a place to put my lonley vote. With a deadline coming up I don't feel comfortable with a no-vote.

Don't read too much into it.

Usually you post more and indepth comments. You haven't been in this game.

[Rogue Shenanigans]

Don't try to build a meta against me with so few games under my belt...

Between gimbo's constant craplogic that he can't be touched for and a push on cream that just doesn't seem all that strong... this game leaves little to go into depth about.

I should re-read and try to pull something from what seems to be 25 pages of fluff.

[mr. incrediball]

sorry i've been lurking guys, i haven't been getting enough time to check both of the sites i play mafia on lately.

i'm still not seeing the case against cream. on the other hand, we need a lynch. i'm happy to consider voting him if someone can explain the case


on the other other hand, i like what surye's thinking about an FL wagon. make her squirm, see if she has anything else to say.

vote FL

[FaerieLord]

I should start a count. The number of people whom guess my sex

right

I'm not blaming anyone though .

[armlx]

I should start a count. The number of people whom guess my sex right

I did!

Don't try to build a meta against me with so few games under my belt...

Actually, only partly true, having few games under your belt simply means any meta has to based on ongoings.

[populartajo]

I seriously dislike D1s. They seem too random. Everyone has the potential of making something scummy and be bandwagoned to death. Thats why I dont love bandwagons also but Ill reread tonight and post something useful later.

[armlx]

Everyone has the potential of making something scummy and be bandwagoned to death.

True, but not true. Everyone has a chance, its just uneven so that scum have more of a chance.

[killa seven]

sorry i've been lurking guys, i haven't been getting enough time to check both of the sites i play mafia on lately.

i'm still not seeing the case against cream. on the other hand, we need a lynch. i'm happy to consider voting him if someone can explain the case


on the other other hand, i like what surye's thinking about an FL wagon. make her squirm, see if she has anything else to say.

vote FL

i belive he said make cream squirm.