Newbie 594: (Game Over!)

Atticus · Post Post #450 (ISO) » Sun Jun 15, 2008 4:30 pm

How is that not reason enough?

zu_Faul · Post Post #451 (ISO) » Mon Jun 16, 2008 10:00 am

I need to reread the entire game. Await a post tomorrow or on Wednesday.

Atticus · Post Post #452 (ISO) » Mon Jun 16, 2008 3:56 pm

I might reread a little, but I doubt it. Otherwise, I think I'm going to read yesterday.

silence · Post Post #453 (ISO) » Tue Jun 17, 2008 3:08 am

Atticus wrote:How is that not reason enough?

May be a problem with my reading comprehension but I don't understand this comment/question. What do you mean by 'that'?

weilawei · Post Post #454 (ISO) » Tue Jun 17, 2008 4:48 am

I've just an argument over a PBPA in my other game. I'm dead there so I'll be devoting more attention here. Big post tonight. (I know, I don't post that often, but I'm trying to put my full effort into each one. Mafia is a surprising amount of work...)

Atticus · Post Post #455 (ISO) » Tue Jun 17, 2008 7:10 am

silence wrote:How can you have any more reason than others?

I said, "How is that not reason enough?"

Because, quite surely he would know if he was the cop or doc.
That is certainly not more than those people.

But, I would also assume that there is no cop or doc, considering that we haven't had anyone come forward with innocents or guilty investigations. Now, it's possible that they investigated people who died that night, but that seems less likely.

silence · Post Post #456 (ISO) » Tue Jun 17, 2008 12:22 pm

Atticus wrote:
silence wrote:How can you have any more reason than others?
I said, "How is that not reason enough?"

Argh. This is frustrating. Apparently either you or me does not understand English. You still did not explain what 'that' refers to, and I still don't understand the question.

If he was cop or doc, he certainly would not have reason to believe there is _no_ cop or doc in the game, so I don't understand why you are talking about that. And, if he is town/scum, he doesn't have any greater information than other townies, which I understand 'I have reason' would indicate.

If he meant that it follows from public information X that there probably is no cop/doc, why did he not say "Because X, there probably is no cop/doc" instead of claiming that he specifically has some reason?

Nocmen, could you elaborate on what 'reason' you have?

silence · Post Post #457 (ISO) » Tue Jun 17, 2008 1:05 pm

And, to clarify, I also find it unlikely that there is cop/dop. Probability about 5 %, I can give calculations if anybody is interested.

Atticus · Post Post #458 (ISO) » Tue Jun 17, 2008 5:45 pm

So he should have said, "We now have reason to believe..."?

Nocmen · Post Post #459 (ISO) » Wed Jun 18, 2008 4:54 am

Sorry about not posting, I had graduation last night distracting me for most of yesterday. As for why I don't think there is a cop/doc, gorillaman was my biggest candidate for who the doc would be, which explains a few of my posts from last night talking about that.

Really I don't know who my candidates for scum will be, but I will continue with the leads where we were at yesterday.

Nocmen · Post Post #460 (ISO) » Thu Jun 19, 2008 6:54 pm

A look at all 4 of the remaining players:

Atticus - He seems to be using a bit more deeper thinking into posts in order to cast suspicions, which sometimes seem as a bit scummy because upon first look it is as if he is going in really deep, but many times it helps me a bit. Leaning towards town.

Zu_faul - I suspected him for all of his FoSes earlier in the game, but he has been better since then, but that may have been becuase I called him out on it for his actions? I don't know...neutral for me.

silence - He's been actively lurking it seems, not really doing as much as I would like, but then again I haven't been the most active player either.

weilawei - He has been hard to get a read on. I see him as some good arguments, but a lot of what he argues is just numbers...

I'm leading towards suspecting weilawei and silence, but I'm not sure about trusting the IC's just with that. I really dont know, tomorrow I will look more into voting patterns and associations with the dead.

bird1111 · Post Post #461 (ISO) » Thu Jun 19, 2008 10:24 pm

weilawei has requested replacement. Looking for one now.

Atticus · Post Post #462 (ISO) » Fri Jun 20, 2008 8:54 am

Hey! Let's save bird1111 the trouble of find a replacement, and just lynch weilawei!

vote: weilawei.

silence · Post Post #463 (ISO) » Fri Jun 20, 2008 11:42 am

Uh. Let's not lynch for such reasons.

bird1111 · Post Post #464 (ISO) » Fri Jun 20, 2008 9:30 pm

Game and Watch Forever replaces weilawei

zu_Faul · Post Post #465 (ISO) » Sat Jun 21, 2008 1:48 am

Nocmen wrote:Sorry about not posting, I had graduation last night distracting me for most of yesterday.

Same here.

I am sorry, it is very irresponsible of me that I have not posted yet, especially since I promised it earlier this week.
I promise I'll do this soon (read: in the next few hours).

Atticus · Post Post #466 (ISO) » Sat Jun 21, 2008 6:41 am

silence wrote:Uh. Let's not lynch for such reasons.

Uh. Then Let's find some good reasons to lynch.

zu_Faul · Post Post #467 (ISO) » Sat Jun 21, 2008 10:06 am

I reread the posts of the players alive and of BlackWolf. BlackWolf to look for connections between the other palyers and him. I'd rank the players in order of scumminess:
1. Atticus
2. Game and Watch / Weilawei
3. Nocmen
4. Silence

Some reason: I don't see BW ever mention anyone of Atticus or Weilawei.

I'd really like to hear more of Silence, though.

Nocmen · Post Post #468 (ISO) » Sat Jun 21, 2008 8:36 pm

Sorry for not doing what i wanted to today, I was at grad parties all day and now I'm just getting back at 330am.

Game and Watch Forever · Post Post #469 (ISO) » Sun Jun 22, 2008 11:02 am

Hey guys, GnWF here. I'll post whatever my guts and logic dictate as soon as I get through these 19 pages of stuff. Hopefully I can help you get the last scum hiding.

/confirm for now

Atticus · Post Post #470 (ISO) » Sun Jun 22, 2008 6:48 pm

zu_Faul wrote:I reread the posts of the players alive and of BlackWolf. BlackWolf to look for connections between the other palyers and him. I'd rank the players in order of scumminess:
1. Atticus
2. Game and Watch / Weilawei
3. Nocmen
4. Silence

Some reason: I don't see BW ever mention anyone of Atticus or Weilawei.

I'd really like to hear more of Silence, though.

That's actually interesting, because I see the same occurrence.

But why do you rank me over weilawei?

silence · Post Post #471 (ISO) » Sun Jun 22, 2008 10:03 pm

zu_Faul wrote:Some reason: I don't see BW ever mention anyone of Atticus or Weilawei.

Why would he not mention his scumbuddy?

zu_Faul · Post Post #472 (ISO) » Mon Jun 23, 2008 12:12 am

silence wrote:
zu_Faul wrote:Some reason: I don't see BW ever mention anyone of Atticus or Weilawei.
Why would he not mention his scumbuddy?

To keep him out of the spotlight.

zu_Faul · Post Post #473 (ISO) » Mon Jun 23, 2008 12:12 am

Atticus wrote:
zu_Faul wrote:I reread the posts of the players alive and of BlackWolf. BlackWolf to look for connections between the other palyers and him. I'd rank the players in order of scumminess:
1. Atticus
2. Game and Watch / Weilawei
3. Nocmen
4. Silence

Some reason: I don't see BW ever mention anyone of Atticus or Weilawei.

I'd really like to hear more of Silence, though.
That's actually interesting, because I see the same occurrence.

But why do you rank me over weilawei?

Feeling.

Atticus · Post Post #474 (ISO) » Mon Jun 23, 2008 4:46 am

Good enough, I suppose.