Mushroom Kingdom Mafia (Game over!)

[farside22]

All you are saying is you are getting scummy vibes and say "well the farside wagon isn't going anywhere." It's like you have no one else in your radar or scum vibe and then just vote with the flow. You don't think that doesn't look scummy to me? Honestly I think you are just being narrow minded on the subject.

I made a very specific point, which was that I didn't like that you said we should wait until tomorrow. That only makes sense from scum's perspective, which is why I continue to think its scummy. Even my most recent post, I was saying I didn't like a specific post. Nothing about scummy vibes.

If you think my play has been

scummy

, say so. Instead, you're implying I'm voting for you because I've for some reason taken it personally that you disagree with me.

I wasn't the only one who said wait till tomorrow. Read narrow minded not scummy.

Mod edit:
Visible votecount:
Cream147 (7): armlx, Phoebus, Alabaska J, Gimbo, TheSweatpantsNinja, killa seven, sideney
FaerieLord (5): Surye, somestrangeflea, Rogue Shenanigans, mr. incrediball, iamausername
Rogue Shenanigans (2): skitzer, farside22
Alabaska J (1): populartajo
somestrangeflea (1): goborage
Phoebus (1): ashmite84

No lynch (1): malthusis

Not voting (6): andersonw, Cream147, FaerieLord, Celebloki, DragonsofSummer, Riceballtail

With 24 alive it takes 13 real votes to lynch. Deadline: June 25th. At deadline, it takes 7 real votes to lynch.

[killa seven]

Phoebus question definately does not sound like the words of someone who got the townie PM,

Hahaha!
And what exactly is the townie PM?
Are you role fishing?


Are there even any specific non townies?
For all I know - there's the mafia, a bunch of toads who can buy powers and that's it.
Even Peach might be a mechanic from where I sit...

You are right clueless, you are.

What exactly have I said or.. rather... not said that's so evil and scumbaggy?

unvote vote phoebus

this is scummy as hell. and half of what you just said is B.S

phoebus wrote.
"For all I know - there's the mafia, a bunch of toads who can buy powers and that's it."
sounds very much like scum fishing for power town roles.

phoebus wrote
"Even Peach might be a mechanic from where I sit..."

again sounds like your fishing to find peach.

[mr. incrediball]

Im going to ask some questions.
Do you think Gimbo could be scum now that we know that the 1UP mushroom also has a scum ability?
What was the exact reasn for voting Faerie Lord?
iamausername, Farside, Armxl, Surye, SSF, Rogue and Mr.Incredibel

were both of those questions directed at me, or was it just the faerie one?

[armlx]

I think those questions were directed at all of those listed.

[mr. incrediball]

I think those questions were directed at all of those listed.

i know. just surprised that anyone would want to know my opinion on anything O.o


gimbo question: i can see that it's possible, but don't think it's too likely. depends mostly on what exactly its pro-scum ability is.

faerie question: it seems to be a better alternative to the cream wagon, which i'm still not getting.


although pheobus thinking peach might be scum is odd... especially since scum win the game by nightkilling her. pheobus might be a good idea for a lynch, i'll see if anything else comes up.

[armlx]

although pheobus thinking peach might be scum is odd...

You seem to be confused. The issue is not that, but instead him thinking no player has the role Princess Peach in the game.

[ashmite84]

Phoebus question definately does not sound like the words of someone who got the townie PM,

Hahaha!
And what exactly is the townie PM?
Are you role fishing?


Are there even any specific non townies?
For all I know - there's the mafia, a bunch of toads who can buy powers and that's it.
Even Peach might be a mechanic from where I sit...

You are right clueless, you are.

What exactly have I said or.. rather... not said that's so evil and scumbaggy?

Why would I tell you the townie role PM? The townies already know it. You ask me if I'm rolefishing in a post where you yourself are rolefishing. It's clear from my post that the only roles I'm interested in fishing for are scum roles.

I'm also not liking the laughter and calling me clueless unreasonably and would probably now policy lynch you anyway.

You persist that Peach may be a mechanic, townie roles know this to be incorrect from something in our role PM. You may be a third party role or a power role. Either way your death would not phase me. I'm uneasy about 3rd party roles in a game like this and as for power role - anyone can be a power role in this game with the right coin.

And finally, no pro-town should fear being lynched today, because barring some horrible stuff up, you will be revived.

Pretty happy with my vote right now.

[Rogue Shenanigans]

Phoebus question definately does not sound like the words of someone who got the townie PM,

Are there even any specific non townies?
For all I know - there's the mafia, a bunch of toads who can buy powers and that's it.
Even Peach might be a mechanic from where I sit...[/quote]

In a mushroom kingdom theme I would be highly disappointed to not see Mario, Luigi ect.

I would also seriously doubt these roles to be scum.

Also... Peach is NOT a mechanic... I suggest you read the rules.

Nice fishing though...

[populartajo]

Phoebus is not a decent lynch.
We need more votes on Rogue, please.

[killa seven]

NO PHOESBUS IS THE BEST LYNCH.
i endorse his lynch.

[ashmite84]

Phoebus is a decent lynch.
We need more votes please.

Fix'd.

[Rogue Shenanigans]

The case against me seems to be that I took part in a slightly strange bandwagon and I made a badly spaced out post explaining it...

Pheob on the other hand is blatently role fishing and has now basicly claimed with very little encouragement to do so.

Maybe I am bias... but that really is how I see it.

[ashmite84]

RS - who is a better lynch in your opinion? FL or Phoebus?

[iamausername]

What was the exact reasn for voting Faerie Lord?

A lynch is better than no lynch. The only players I could see being lynched today at the point I made my vote (barring some major incident) were Cream, FL or Rogue.

FL seems the best choice of those, I'm not seeing the case on Cream at all, whereas I think FL looks pretty scummy for acting like Cream's lynch was a foregone conclusion in this post. Also don't like Rogue's "bandwagoning to see reactions", seems like a good excuse for scum to get off a townie wagon that wasn't gaining enough weight. So I think he'd also be a better lynch than Cream.

FYI, I also think there's something to the latest movement against Phoebus.

[Riceballtail]

I am beginning to agree with the wagon against Phoebus.

For those who aren't aware, I was reaction fishing with my NL vote.

VOTE: Phoebus

[goborage]

Lol no you weren't.

I think the Phoebus wagon is crap. Of the people on it I'd say I find killa seven the worst. Which parts of Phoebus' post are BS?

Give Phoebus a little more credit, he wouldn't bother trying to fish for Peach. I don't think anyone would.

ashmite sounds a little more earnest in his comments. I'm ignoring RBT for now.

[armlx]

For those who aren't aware, I was reaction fishing with my NL vote.

Traps only trap lazy people, not scum or town in specific.

[Riceballtail]

Traps only trap lazy people, not scum or town in specific.

True, but laziness can help catch scum if you do it right.

And don't worry gob, I want to ignore you too. -_-

[armlx]

True, but laziness can help catch scum if you do it right.

Wrong. True laziness is a null tell, forced laziness is lying and what not. Distinguishing the 2 though....

[somestrangeflea]

Phoebus question definately does not sound like the words of someone who got the townie PM,

Hahaha!
And what exactly is the townie PM?
Are you role fishing?


Are there even any specific non townies?
For all I know - there's the mafia, a bunch of toads who can buy powers and that's it.
Even Peach might be a mechanic from where I sit...

You are right clueless, you are.

What exactly have I said or.. rather... not said that's so evil and scumbaggy?

Well, you accuse someone of fishing, then fish yourself, so I'm gonna go with hypocrisy...

...interspersed with ad hominem.

Unvote, Vote: Phoebus

For those who aren't aware, I was reaction fishing with my NL vote.

Of course you were.
For future reference, if I do anything scummy, it's just to test for reactions...

[DragonsofSummer]

I'm sorry it is taking me so long everybody, I am just having a hard time sitting down and concentrating on reading without an interuption coming, I will have something for you by sunday. I really am sorry about this.

[mr. incrediball]

although pheobus thinking peach might be scum is odd...

You seem to be confused. The issue is not that, but instead him thinking no player has the role Princess Peach in the game.

i'm sure i am confused... what is a mechanic, then?

[Lawrencelot]

mod: is it possible to perform an action such as 'give all my coins to player X', or do you have to nominate an amount?

That is not possible, you have to say the exact amount of coins.

[Rogue Shenanigans]

RS - who is a better lynch in your opinion? FL or Phoebus?

At this point it is obviously phoebus. FL was a pressure bandwagon from start to finish. While pheobus has been the most scummy player.

unvote,Vote Phoebus

[skitzer]

LOL wait. Riceballtail is so much more scummy than Rogue Shenanigans...

NL just for reactions? Please.

Unvote, Vote Riceballtail