Mushroom Kingdom Mafia (Game over!)

[iamausername]

For those who aren't aware, I was reaction fishing with my NL vote.

What reactions did you expect to see from scum? From town?

Mod edit:
Visible votecount:
Cream147 (6): armlx, Phoebus, Alabaska J, Gimbo, TheSweatpantsNinja, sideney
Phoebus (5): ashmite84, killa seven, Riceballtail, somestrangeflea, Rogue Shenanigans
FaerieLord (3): Surye, mr. incrediball, iamausername
Rogue Shenanigans (1): farside22
Alabaska J (1): populartajo
somestrangeflea (1): goborage
Riceballtail (1): skitzer

No lynch (1): malthusis

Not voting (5): andersonw, Cream147, FaerieLord, Celebloki, DragonsofSummer

With 24 alive it takes 13 real votes to lynch. Deadline: June 25th. At deadline, it takes 7 real votes to lynch.

[Riceballtail]

LOL wait. Riceballtail is so much more scummy than Rogue Shenanigans...

NL just for reactions? Please.

Unvote, Vote Riceballtail

Is exactly the scummy reaction I was looking for.

[Rogue Shenanigans]

LOL wait. Riceballtail is so much more scummy than Rogue Shenanigans...

NL just for reactions? Please.

Unvote, Vote Riceballtail

Is exactly the scummy reaction I was looking for.

He was on me for the same reason...

Way to look for nothing.

[Gimbo]

Riceballtail-> zealous much??

LOL wait. Riceballtail is so much more scummy than Rogue Shenanigans...

NL just for reactions? Please.

Unvote, Vote Riceballtail

Is exactly the scummy reaction I was looking for.

Riceball, you seem very opportunistic in your votes and once people started moving away from the person you voted (and rejected your NL suggestion), you withdraw saying its just for reactions and then called skitzer's post 'exactly the scummy reaction' that you are looking for.

Please, riceball

Unvote Vote:Riceballtail

, you are trying too hard.

FoS: Cream

since Riceball voted for NL the minute Cream's wagon started growing.

[skitzer]

My read through of Riceballtail

(7) - confirm post
(42) - random vote
(93) - a joke about BM.
(233) - clarifies that there is probably a Mario and Luigi role, by what the first post said.
(304) - points out that there are no regular power roles and approves of Gimbo’s trade and trade back to Surye.
(365) - agrees with Rogue Shenanigans on the fact that pooling coins is only good for scum, a point I also agree with, and he votes TheSweatpantsNinja.
(372) - says that we need a bigger bandwagon on TheSweatpants Ninja.
(508) - tries to summarize 21 pages for me, thinks that farside could be scum, but still says he supports a lynch of TheSweatpantsNinja.
(512) - explains what Gimbo’s 1-UP mushroom does.
(550) - VLA Post
(603) - says there is no beneficial discussion. Somewhat disagrees with Gimbo’s lurker hunting. Votes Surye for revealing the scum benefit of the 1-UP mushroom. In my opinion, it is better that Surye did, because now we know that we need to be extra careful with it so that it doesn’t fall into scum hands.
(625) - says he’s

okay

with a No Lynch on day 1. It is entirely possible for many good cases to form on Day 1, which could all lead to scum.
(627) - says that we have already decided that we are going to do a mass vig/cop tonight, when nothing of the sort has been decided.
(643) - unvotes and says he is going to process these new thoughts
(689) - agrees with wagon on Phoebus (I don’t find it that good myself) and says his No Lynch vote was just testing reactions…
(692) - says that laziness can help catch scum…scum are more likely to be the ones playing than the ones lurking, IMO.
(701) - says that my vote on him was the exact reaction he was looking for. Did you expect everyone to brush it off and just say “Oh, he just voted No Lynch because he was

testing reactions.

”?

Also, @ Rogue Shenanigans: I believe this situation is entirely different from yours: You jumped off a bandwagon, while I voted for someone who had no votes at all.

FoS: Rogue Shenanigans

just to keep my suspicions up there.

[Alabaska J]

I am okay with a Riceballtail lynch, in addition to being okay with a RogueShenanigans and definitely a Cream147 lynch.

Also, the Phoebus case is based off of him rolefishing? I'll admit, there was some rolefishing present, but goborage and ashmite84 rolefished also, and just as much, if not more so. Seems to be a double standard here.

FoS: all rolefishers and everyone on the Phoebus wagon who didn't point out the other rolefishers (so everyone on the Phoebus wagon)

. I almost feel like there is a very high chance that either ashmite84 or goborage is scum with one or more people on the Phoebus wagon, which almost feels like it was started to direct attention away from their rolefishing.

[Cream147]

RS - who is a better lynch in your opinion? FL or Phoebus?

At this point it is obviously phoebus. FL was a pressure bandwagon from start to finish. While pheobus has been the most scummy player.

unvote,Vote Phoebus

I'm a little concerned about this. Have I missed something you've said Rogue? I personally haven't enjoyed Phoebus' play at all this game, but then that is pretty obvious! However, I don't see how he has suddenly, with one (very odd) post become the most scummy player in the game. Is this your first mention of Phoebus or am I missing something?

[Gimbo]

Cream, be grateful that your ass isn't on the chopping block (anymore), and shut up

[Gimbo]

LOL, ^ its a joke, guys, dont take it seriously

[goborage]

LOL wait. Riceballtail is so much more scummy than Rogue Shenanigans...

NL just for reactions? Please.

Unvote, Vote Riceballtail

Is exactly the scummy reaction I was looking for.

Part of me wants to vote for you too. If I was a little tougher on LAL I would. If I wasn't meta-ing you I would. TBH I don't know exactly what you were expecting from your "gambit" (I'm thinking you just wanted to sound cool after making such a lame post). It's pretty much always going to be "I disagree" or "You're scummy". If anyone ever said "I agree", congratulations, you just caught yourself a newbie.

@ RBT: Would it really be surprising to you if townies didn't like your "trap" and wanted to vote for you?

And Gimbo, you seriously play like a jester. Cream raises a good point I think, and I believe an RS wagon is way better than a Phoebus or RBT.

[armlx]

i'm sure i am confused... what is a mechanic, then?

A mechanic is something like the coins, an in game set of actions that changes the fundamentals of the game.

If I was a little tougher on LAL I would

goborage- What part of Riceball's posts is lying?

STRONG FOS Rogue Shenanigans

. His behavior this game seems very odd compared to my overall read on him, less content and more votes.

[Riceballtail]

No, I wouldn't be surprised with a town-anger response. I kinda expected it anyway. I'm just trying something out. With the large number of players, I figured I could at least get enough of a reaction before it could escalate into my lynch.

[armlx]

No, I wouldn't be surprised with a town-anger response. I kinda expected it anyway. I'm just trying something out. With the large number of players, I figured I could at least get enough of a reaction before it could escalate into my lynch.

Reactionary play where you do something legitimately scummy is dumb. Just saying, it just makes people validly want to lynch you, and your "trap" of them isn't worth anything.

[Riceballtail]

Reactionary play where you do something legitimately scummy is dumb. Just saying, it just makes people validly want to lynch you, and your "trap" of them isn't worth anything.

Yeah, I'm thinking it really didn't work well. But, I learned anyway, so it'll help next game if nothing else.

[goborage]

Sounds like a lie:

For those who aren't aware, I was reaction fishing with my NL vote.

because:

I'm thinking you just wanted to sound cool after making such a lame post

But I can buy RBT making a fail trap.

[armlx]

Sounds like a lie:

For those who aren't aware, I was reaction fishing with my NL vote.

because:

I'm thinking you just wanted to sound cool after making such a lame post

But I can buy RBT making a fail trap.

I wouldn't so much call that a lie for the purposes of LAL. LAL lies are proven true.

[Alabaska J]

Sounds like a lie:

For those who aren't aware, I was reaction fishing with my NL vote.

because:

I'm thinking you just wanted to sound cool after making such a lame post

But I can buy RBT making a fail trap.

I wouldn't so much call that a lie for the purposes of LAL. LAL lies are proven true.

[goborage]

Hmm just looked at the wiki. You're right. I just heard the term and made up my own definition.

[Phoebus]

All the people wagonning me are clueless goons.

Especially the one (whoever it is -- i can't even bother to find out at this time -) who wants to policy lynch me just because they find me and my words annoying -- get help/training/whatever...

If your play is going to be based on how you react to people's words...you've got another thing coming....might as well give up playing now.

Policy lynching is usually a stupid thing. Doing it just because you don't like what you're hearing about yourself...especially more so...!


Given all the raving about me these last few pages, only one person seems to have caught on to what I'm saying (though they don't seem to approve) but I'm fine by that.
The rest of you are a bunch of clueless lunatics with torches, out on a witch hunt!


For what it's worth, I'll echo Gimbo's polite post to Cream and

unvote: Cream ; vote: killa seven

[killa seven]

lol phoebus are you voting me because i voted you? all you say is we are clueless goons but im positive i have more info in this game then you

[armlx]

All the people wagonning me are clueless goons.

Especially the one (whoever it is -- i can't even bother to find out at this time -) who wants to policy lynch me just because they find me and my words annoying -- get help/training/whatever...

If your play is going to be based on how you react to people's words...you've got another thing coming....might as well give up playing now.

Policy lynching is usually a stupid thing. Doing it just because you don't like what you're hearing about yourself...especially more so...!


Given all the raving about me these last few pages, only one person seems to have caught on to what I'm saying (though they don't seem to approve) but I'm fine by that.
The rest of you are a bunch of clueless lunatics with torches, out on a witch hunt!


For what it's worth, I'll echo Gimbo's polite post to Cream and

unvote: Cream ; vote: killa seven

This post makes me face palm in so many ways.

[iamausername]

LOL wait. Riceballtail is so much more scummy than Rogue Shenanigans...

NL just for reactions? Please.

Unvote, Vote Riceballtail

Is exactly the scummy reaction I was looking for.

Why do you think this is more likely a scum reaction than town?

[Alabaska J]

All the people wagonning me are clueless goons.

Especially the one (whoever it is -- i can't even bother to find out at this time -) who wants to policy lynch me just because they find me and my words annoying -- get help/training/whatever...

If your play is going to be based on how you react to people's words...you've got another thing coming....might as well give up playing now.

Policy lynching is usually a stupid thing. Doing it just because you don't like what you're hearing about yourself...especially more so...!


Given all the raving about me these last few pages, only one person seems to have caught on to what I'm saying (though they don't seem to approve) but I'm fine by that.
The rest of you are a bunch of clueless lunatics with torches, out on a witch hunt!


For what it's worth, I'll echo Gimbo's polite post to Cream and

unvote: Cream ; vote: killa seven

This post makes me face palm in so many ways.

I think armlx is the government in my brain posting my thoughts before I can.

[armlx]

I think armlx is the government in my brain posting my thoughts before I can.

Interestingly enough, you are one of the people I have not yet mind bugged.

[Riceballtail]

LOL wait. Riceballtail is so much more scummy than Rogue Shenanigans...

NL just for reactions? Please.

Unvote, Vote Riceballtail

Is exactly the scummy reaction I was looking for.

Why do you think this is more likely a scum reaction than town?

Because I find that his use of words, in particular, are what makes it scummy. They sound pro-town upon looking, but if you run them through your head as though someone were saying it, they sound very anti-town whichever way you run it.