Mushroom Kingdom Mafia (Game over!)

[Surye]

Something really bugs me about that claim. I don't think DK has been pro-Mario in ANY game in the Mushroom Kingdom. If I am wrong, someone can correct me, but vote stands.

Mario party series? He's definitely anti-bowser, almost by definition.

Mod edit:
Visible votecount:
Rogue Shenanigans (7): farside22, goborage, TheSweatpantsNinja, Alabaska J, iamausername, armlx, Riceballtail
Phoebus (4): ashmite84, killa seven, somestrangeflea, Rogue Shenanigans
FaerieLord (2): Surye, mr. incrediball
Riceballtail (2): skitzer, Gimbo
Cream147 (1): sideney
Alabaska J (1): populartajo
killa seven (1): Phoebus

No lynch (1): malthusis

Not voting (5): andersonw, Cream147, FaerieLord, Celebloki, DragonsofSummer

With 24 alive it takes 13 real votes to lynch. Deadline: June 25th. At deadline, it takes 7 real votes to lynch.

[armlx]

Hmm. That certainly is more recent canon then the ones I was thinking of (namely way back when DK threw barrels at Mario).

Unvote

DK is pretty iconic, and until I see a counter claim, I would believe that RS is telling the truth about his role name. Rule 25 also implies that anti-Bowser is pro-town.

Vote Riceball

as of him + Cream he has more votes and this vote is the most progress towards the day day not resolving in a No Lynch. I will still vote RS if absolutely necessary to end the day in a lynch rather then NL, but if given the choice I would rather lynch Riceball after that claim.

[somestrangeflea]

Something really bugs me about that claim. I don't think DK has been pro-Mario in ANY game in the Mushroom Kingdom. If I am wrong, someone can correct me, but vote stands.

Mario party series? He's definitely anti-bowser, almost by definition.

Mario Party maybe, but not Mushroom Kingdom.

I call fakeclaim.

Unvote, Vote: Rogue Shenanigans

[Rogue Shenanigans]

Mario Party maybe, but not Mushroom Kingdom.

Mario games is mario games.

DK was anti mario in his first game. But not anti

peach

as many people think.

[somestrangeflea]

Mario Party maybe, but not Mushroom Kingdom.

Mario games is mario games.

How observant.

Mario games doesn't automatically => Mushroom Kingdom.

[Gimbo]

People,

Rogue and Riceballtail are scumbuddies, however when Riceballtail saw that the wagon on Rogue is getting too big for them to undo, he reluctantly adds his own vote to the Rogue wagon because he doesn't want people to get suspicious.

So I say after Rogue, I want Riceballtail

DEAD

[Gimbo]

or better yet, since Rogue claimed, let's move the wagon onto Riceballtail and force him to claim today also.

[Rogue Shenanigans]

Mario Party maybe, but not Mushroom Kingdom.

Mario games is mario games.

Mario games doesn't automatically => Mushroom Kingdom.

I would say that it did in terms of a mario theme.
[/i]

[Rogue Shenanigans]

By the way guys. If you are really set on lynching me... put your money where your noose is. The banana I get is an ITEM. I can be confirmed in the same way gimbo was.
When I said " at any point" I meant day or night.

[somestrangeflea]

By the way guys. If you are really set on lynching me... put your money where your noose is. The banana I get is an ITEM. I can be confirmed in the same way gimbo was.

I didn't buy that either.

[farside22]

DK is anti mario. Would DK be in the mushroom kingdom? I haven't played the more recent games (like the game party), but the claim has some flavor.
Rogue why all the vote hoping without more info?

[Rogue Shenanigans]

Rogue why all the vote hoping without more info?

To be honest I have just found it hard to get into this game as awesome as the flavour is. Maybe that led to slightly strange voting... though I stand by my votes and the reactions of the town toward them.

As far as I am concerned DK is a role that could easily go either and all ways. I dont think the name alone can swing it.

[mr. incrediball]

By the way guys. If you are really set on lynching me... put your money where your noose is. The banana I get is an ITEM. I can be confirmed in the same way gimbo was.
When I said " at any point" I meant day or night.

just wondering...

1)where are you proposing you get these 10 coins from?

2)isn't a permanent jail-keeper item a little unbalanced, especially considering that you didn't claim to have a night action in the first place?

3)now that you're asking us to wait for you to magically scrounge up the money, can't you just lie to us, and keep yourself alive for days on end while we wait for you to end your imaginary brokeness, and buy an imaginary banana?

in other words, i'm not buying it.

[mr. incrediball]

by which i meant:

vote rogue

.

Mod: not counted, you should unvote first

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Unvote, vote riceballtail.

RS' claim is both believable, and better yet, confirmable.

[iamausername]

1)where are you proposing you get these 10 coins from?

I think he is proposing that we give them to him.

I don't like the sound of "Hey guys, give me all your coins and I get a magical super awesome item, I promise." Also not seeing DK as all that likely to appear in this game.

My vote is staying.

[Surye]

By the way guys. If you are really set on lynching me... put your money where your noose is. The banana I get is an ITEM. I can be confirmed in the same way gimbo was.
When I said " at any point" I meant day or night.

Really? You can? The beauty of checking gimbo is it didn't change ANYTHING else in the game. It was a simple trade back. You would require consuming coins, many coins. This is a world of difference.

And your role seems constructed to damage town on your way down. I don't buy it either.

Vote: Rouge

Mod: not counted, unvote first

[Rogue Shenanigans]

By the way guys. If you are really set on lynching me... put your money where your noose is. The banana I get is an ITEM. I can be confirmed in the same way gimbo was.
When I said " at any point" I meant day or night.

just wondering...

1)where are you proposing you get these 10 coins from?

2)isn't a permanent jail-keeper item a little unbalanced, especially considering that you didn't claim to have a night action in the first place?

3)now that you're asking us to wait for you to magically scrounge up the money, can't you just lie to us, and keep yourself alive for days on end while we wait for you to end your imaginary brokeness, and buy an imaginary banana?

in other words, i'm not buying it.

I would condone that the rest of the town give me the coins. I said "at any point" that means at any point. I don't need to wait to night for my item. Then I can confirm the same way gimbo was.

The possible outcomes are this.

1) I am confirmed and we get on with the real scumhunting.

2) I keep the cash and I am not confirmed, you lynch me. The town loses 10 coins.

10 coins= two investigations by the way... I would easily trade that for a scum lynch day one. Wouldn't you.

[mr. incrediball]

by which i meant:

vote rogue

.

by which i meant

unvote vote rogue

.

[mr. incrediball]

By the way guys. If you are really set on lynching me... put your money where your noose is. The banana I get is an ITEM. I can be confirmed in the same way gimbo was.
When I said " at any point" I meant day or night.

just wondering...

1)where are you proposing you get these 10 coins from?

2)isn't a permanent jail-keeper item a little unbalanced, especially considering that you didn't claim to have a night action in the first place?

3)now that you're asking us to wait for you to magically scrounge up the money, can't you just lie to us, and keep yourself alive for days on end while we wait for you to end your imaginary brokeness, and buy an imaginary banana?

in other words, i'm not buying it.

I would condone that the rest of the town give me the coins. I said "at any point" that means at any point. I don't need to wait to night for my item. Then I can confirm the same way gimbo was.

The possible outcomes are this.

1) I am confirmed and we get on with the real scumhunting.

2) I keep the cash and I am not confirmed, you lynch me. The town loses 10 coins.

10 coins= two investigations by the way... I would easily trade that for a scum lynch day one. Wouldn't you.

3) we keep the coins and lynch you. if it turns out you were telling the truth, gimbo revives you and we buy you a banana. the town loses nothing.

[Rogue Shenanigans]

Oh yea...

Cause Gimbo is gonna survive the night.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

3) we keep the coins and lynch you. if it turns out you were telling the truth, gimbo revives you and we buy you a banana. the town loses nothing.

Can we please stop acting like who we lynch doesn't matter because we might be able to revive them?

[armlx]

The issue is if we want test Rogue we don't have actual time to do it today.

[farside22]

I am willing to give Rogue time to prove his role. It is interesting idea and if tomorrow he can't give the item to someone then I would be up for a lynch.

unvote:
vote: RBT

Another vote hopper that adds nothing. Looks good to go

[skitzer]

I am willing to give Rogue time to prove his role. It is interesting idea and if tomorrow he can't give the item to someone then I would be up for a lynch.

unvote:
vote: RBT

Another vote hopper that adds nothing. Looks good to go

I'm not sure I see how this is going to help, because Rogue doesn't have the coins to get his banana (BTW, armlx, banana innuendos FTW).

FomS: farside22