Mushroom Kingdom Mafia (Game over!)

[somestrangeflea]

that specific ability seems very odd for a scum.

Same with perma jail.

I can see scum uses for a permanent stoppage of a players Night Choices and the removal of a Townie vote...

Scum are more likely to be vanilla then town

Huh. I would say this is less likely to be true in Themed games.

Mod edit:
Visible votecount:
Rogue Shenanigans (5): iamausername, mr. incrediball, skitzer, somestrangeflea, Surye
Cream147 (4): sideney, Riceballtail, armlx, farside22
Phoebus (3): ashmite84, killa seven, Rogue Shenanigans
Riceballtail (2): TheSweatpantsNinja, Alabaska J
killa seven (2): Phoebus, goborage
Alabaska J (1): populartajo

No lynch (1): malthusis

Not voting (6): andersonw, Cream147, FaerieLord, Celebloki, DragonsofSummer, Gimbo

With 24 alive it takes 13 real votes to lynch. Deadline: June 25th, 6 PM GMT. At deadline, it takes 7 real votes to lynch.

[armlx]

I can see scum uses for a permanent stoppage of a players Night Choices and the removal of a Townie vote...

Did he say it removed the vote? And what about the bulletproof part?

Huh. I would say this is less likely to be true in Themed games.

Well, I guess it depends on the size of the scum group somewhat, but even then I expect a 50% ratio of scum as vanilla as opposed to a 20-40% town ratio.

[armlx]

Visible votecount:
Rogue Shenanigans (5): iamausername, mr. incrediball, skitzer, somestrangeflea, Surye
Cream147 (4): sideney, Riceballtail, armlx, farside22
Riceballtail (3):TheSweatpantsNinja, Alabaska J, Surye
Phoebus (3): ashmite84, killa seven, Rogue Shenanigans
Alabaska J (1): populartajo
killa seven (2): Phoebus, goborage

No lynch (1): malthusis

Not voting (5): andersonw, Cream147, FaerieLord, Celebloki, DragonsofSummer , gimbo

Also, visible vote count.

My hatred of wasting kill opportunities is clashing with my hatred of lynching confirmables outside of LyLo.

[somestrangeflea]

I can see scum uses for a permanent stoppage of a players Night Choices and the removal of a Townie vote...

Did he say it removed the vote?

Referring to RBT's claim.

And what about the bulletproof part?

What with the ability for Town to buy killing items, I'd say Bulletproof is fairly useful for scum too.

[somestrangeflea]

Also, I'd like to ask a question to everyone on the Cream wagon.

If the wagon were to gain momentum, and Cream claimed something in the same vein as the claims so far, what would you do?

[armlx]

SSF: I would unvote. Not sure from there.

What with the ability for Town to buy killing items, I'd say Bulletproof is fairly useful for scum too.

Trading the ability to kill for bullet proof is not that good for scum.

Referring to RBT's claim.

I see.

[Surye]

Whats your point Surye?

I assumed your point was that a power role on top of mafia would be unbalance. Not if that role was so underpowered.

[Gimbo]

Also, I'd like to ask a question to everyone on the Cream wagon.

If the wagon were to gain momentum, and Cream claimed something in the same vein as the claims so far, what would you do?

Then i'm going to vote for a lurker just because I'm pissed.

[farside22]

I really hate doing this, but a day 1 NL does us no good.

unvote:
vote Rogue

[somestrangeflea]

SSF: I would unvote. Not sure from there.

I'm guessing deadline will be too soon to build up a non-Cream, non-Rogue, non-Riceball wagon. If you're crazy lucky, you'll get Phoebus!

My point is this: I don't want to run the risk of No Lynching because everyone we go to lynch claims something that might confirm them in the future. At the end of the day (which is now less than 18 hours away), we're just going to have to take a chance and lynch someone we think is scummy, despite their claim.

Surely you can see where I'm coming from?

What with the ability for Town to buy killing items, I'd say Bulletproof is fairly useful for scum too.

Trading the ability to kill for bullet proof is not that good for scum.

Only if they're the last scum alive...

[armlx]

Surely you can see where I'm coming from?

Yeah, sure, but I also would rather go to my next option that is still viable then lynch a confirmable role.

Only if they're the last scum alive...

Just in general its bad IMO.

[iamausername]

But my argument still stands. Why should people who have had aspects of their role confirmed be seen as more likely to be town than those who have not?

Let's not forget that Rogue's claimed role has in no way been confirmed, and can't be without the town throwing away ten coins.

And seriously, a super banana? Which is so tasty that it makes you invincible forever? Has such a thing ever existed even in a Donkey Kong game, which would at best be tangentially related to the Mushroom Kingdom theme?

[Gimbo]

yea, i was thinking that too...a super banana...even the name sounds bad, plus the whole thing seems made up.

[somestrangeflea]

yea, i was thinking that too...a super banana...even the name sounds bad, plus the whole thing seems made up.

Gimbo speaks the truth.

[Gimbo]

^ SSK, wait, do i smell sarcasm?

anyways

Vote:Rogue

i am kinda frustrated, i am not 100% positive about this vote but at this time, it seems that town doesn't want to start a brand new wagon...

[farside22]

^ SSK, wait, do i smell sarcasm?

anyways

Vote:Rogue

i am kinda frustrated, i am not 100% positive about this vote but at this time, it seems that town doesn't want to start a brand new wagon...

If I'm right GMT 6pm is in 10 minutes. It is better then a NL.

[iamausername]

Nope, 1AM here in ten minutes.

[Gimbo]

lol, its 7:56 pm where I live.

[armlx]

Sigh, while I hate to do this, NL < lynching possible scum but confirmable if town.

Unvote, Vote RS

to ensure we get to 7 real votes.

[ashmite84]

Why are people claiming at the drop of a hat?

[killa seven]

unvote vote rs

[armlx]

Why are people claiming at the

drop of a hat?

L-1 or 2?

Are you sure you need the answer to this question?

Mod: tags fixed

[ashmite84]

Why are people claiming at the

drop of a hat?

L-1 or 2?
/quote]

Are you sure you need the answer to this question?

RBT was barely even looked at at the time of the claim. Goborage's poison shroom was a potentially useful item that he seemed be in a hurry to get rid of.

Mod: tags fixed

[Gimbo]

ashmite, unlike my shroom, goborage got a shitty shroom that is potentially incriminating as he explained in his post, if it was me, i probably would've gotten rid of it too.

[ashmite84]

ashmite, unlike my shroom, goborage got a shitty shroom that is potentially incriminating as he explained in his post, if it was me, i probably would've gotten rid of it too.

I read his post, I just felt it a pretty weak reason. I'd never give up a 1-shot vig like that.