Alisae V Pine: Trees Apparently Make Good Treestumps

[MariaR]

Oh are we getting another counter wagon to Mastina? It's almost like she's impossible to lynch because she's scum (B

[Titus]

Oh are we getting another counter wagon to Mastina? It's almost like she's impossible to lynch because she's scum (B

No. She's not getting lynched because she's town and you can't get enough dumb town to lynch the bg.

If I had more charisma than a house fly, pops Krazy and you would be lynched.

[MariaR]

Thank goodness you don't because that's 3 town.

[Titus]

Thank goodness you don't because that's 3 town.

Well it seems like you're agreeing with my VCA at least now.

[MariaR]

It's less me agreeing and me not having the real knowledge to disagree. If it helps you, by all means, go at it, but I disagree with it

[MariaR]

(By disagree I mean the fact that it's a good tool to find scum/town Not the results itself)

[Titus]

Ok. Go ahead and shoot me when mastina flips town.

We'll laugh at this town in dead chat.

[Alisae]

Ok. Go ahead and shoot me when mastina flips town.

We'll laugh at this town in dead chat.

what are you talking about?
no one is shooting you

[popsofctown]

Titus maybe you're right the game is factionalized

And you're just picking the wrong faction?

[Titus]

Ok. Go ahead and shoot me when mastina flips town.

We'll laugh at this town in dead chat.

what are you talking about?
no one is shooting you

Just like mastina's scum right?

Sorry but you're wrong Ali. You've been captured. Your high volume of posting stopped town from organically working together. You deciding to slow down helped a bit, but the damage may already be done.

Between you and the governor tying my less charismatic hands, I seriously don't know how to get through a lynch on scum here.

You'll be here tomorrow. There's a decent chance when mastina flips town I won't. I don't have the entire game though.

[Titus]

Titus maybe you're right the game is factionalized

And you're just picking the wrong faction?

I'd be open to that if any of you behaved like rational actors instead of scumfucks and the only flip I can track as scum going after Fire and Krazy.

[Titus]

But I'm cranky tired pops, case mastina without the bodyguard. Case the worst. Look at the other faction and show me they are scum.

[the worst]

COWARDS!

[Alisae]

Ok. Go ahead and shoot me when mastina flips town.

We'll laugh at this town in dead chat.

what are you talking about?
no one is shooting you

Just like mastina's scum right?

Sorry but you're wrong Ali. You've been captured. Your high volume of posting stopped town from organically working together. You deciding to slow down helped a bit, but the damage may already be done.

Between you and the governor tying my less charismatic hands, I seriously don't know how to get through a lynch on scum here.

You'll be here tomorrow. There's a decent chance when mastina flips town I won't. I don't have the entire game though.

This day sucks but Krazy isn't scum and I'm just keeping my eyes open
if I had to pick one of the 2 I would lynch, I would lynch mastina
but I'm not sure she's scum
I'm just not.
they're both town so..........

[Titus]

Ok. Go ahead and shoot me when mastina flips town.

We'll laugh at this town in dead chat.

what are you talking about?
no one is shooting you

Just like mastina's scum right?

Sorry but you're wrong Ali. You've been captured. Your high volume of posting stopped town from organically working together. You deciding to slow down helped a bit, but the damage may already be done.

Between you and the governor tying my less charismatic hands, I seriously don't know how to get through a lynch on scum here.

You'll be here tomorrow. There's a decent chance when mastina flips town I won't. I don't have the entire game though.

This day sucks but Krazy isn't scum and I'm just keeping my eyes open
if I had to pick one of the 2 I would lynch, I would lynch mastina
but I'm not sure she's scum
I'm just not.
they're both town so..........

Then do chennisden. I'm not totally ruling out T v T. I still think Krazy is scum bc no one will tell me how Krazy scumhunts and tunneling the bg is not town town motivated. His tone doesn't feel fake.

Mastina will resolve.

Good night Ali.

[the worst]

Gngn Ali

[chennisden]

No Titus, I really dont believe ur town here.

[Formerfish]

Oh are we getting another counter wagon to Mastina? It's almost like she's impossible to lynch because she's scum (B

Nice to see you surface for a few posts, show youre still behind and then disappear again without really doing anything.

Later!

[popsofctown]

It's one of the 3 valid reasons Mastina could have for putting me near the bottom of her readslist but I won't go into the other 2.

You're at the bottom because you're scum.

Small confession: I've been skimming about 80% of the pages offline: I haven't read every page, there's many pages that I missed, and the pages that I did read I didn't really put more than the bare minimum into.

I haven't been commenting tho because I've wanted to read in detail all the pages and give commentary on key issues, but the thread creating new content faster than I could respond to it makes the task daunting, so the intimidation factor has kept me from weighing in.

There's only about half a dozen (maybe like eight total) posts which I want to respond to, but I can't remember where they are off the top of my head and would need to read to find them.

In the mean time, tho:
LLD, regardless of her alignment, is a distraction.
Town, scum, doesn't matter. Pine wants us to be focusing attention on her.
Personally: while I recognize that there are reasons for both LLD and GreyIce to be scum, I think that at most one of them would be, and that it's quite probable that both are town in spite of my reasons to find them suspect.

Ditto for LLD/xofelf. I recognize the validity of LLD's case, but while I see the logic, I'm not convinced that it's actually right.

I am quite dead serious about my jjh/Aristophanes scumreads; I am sure AT LEAST one of them is scum, quite possibly both.

There's other players who I should give feedback on, but I wanted to do so on a full readslist wallpost where I explain where I am coming from on all of them.

Like if you just skim her iso you get terrible shit like this so easily.
"LLD, regardless of her alignment, is a distraction"
Not mindmeld. Literal opposite of the truth when literally clearly Pine preferred for us to focus on Firebringer.

going hard against jjh and Aristophanes, so she's at least twice as bad as I was with my day 1 reads, that delves deeper into some probabilistic concerns.

The comment on LLD/xofelf is super partnery. "I see the logic, I'm not convinced it's actually right"? What does that even mean? If she called the logic bad, she'd be forced to scumread LLD, which she obviously doesn't want to do. If she calls the logic good, she should be sheeping it. So she just bizarrely says "The logic is good, but not actually right."
Like given (X+3)/2=5, (X+3)=5*2 has logic, yes, X+3-3 = 5*2-3 has logic yet, X=7, no no no, that's not right, Pine posted in the scum PT we're going with X=4 right now.

[popsofctown]

Oh are we getting another counter wagon to Mastina? It's almost like she's impossible to lynch because she's scum (B

Nice to see you surface for a few posts, show youre still behind and then disappear again without really doing anything.

Later!

Eh, you and I are the ones making this game unplayable with the standard amount of mafiascum effort per game.

The contrast to Iconeum is that she's not vanity wagoning so she's not keeping us from getting anywhere.

[Dannflor]

Not mindmeld. Literal opposite of the truth when literally clearly Pine preferred for us to focus on Firebringer.

probably the best case for town!firebringer

[Dannflor]

the problem is is that I don't see mastina vs. Krazy as scum theatre really?

I don't see Mastina attacking Krazy's ability to have fun this game if that's the case

and I see actual attempts to solve in Mastina's ISO and none in Krazy's

[Dannflor]

and I don't really see Krazy as not scum

[Dannflor]

maybe I need to case it better with how bored people seem to be with that take

[Formerfish]

maybe I need to case it better with how bored people seem to be with that take

So you could vote for either Krazy or Chenny and you arent getting movement on Krazy and you are waiting for movement on Chenny, but instead of interacting someone who wants to hang Chenny you want to go back and recase Krazy to refresh your stale case?