Mini 624 - Game Over!

[Inspector Godot]

/Confirm.

[Inspector Godot]

vote: Inspector Godot

You were guilty in PW: Trials and Tribulations. You must be guilty now. Also, yay bandwagon.

B-b-but I was an anti-hero!

OMGUS: Tom

[Inspector Godot]

So.... Time for the game to get serious, I guess?

Unvote

Vote: geraintm

Much for the reason Kenfucius said.

[Inspector Godot]

Unvote

Ok, he's posted. Nice avatar by the way.

[Inspector Godot]

I'm willing to accept that it was a joke vote, but it could very well have given us a few clues.

[Inspector Godot]

He may have been very hasty bringing you to L-1 but it was a very good method of getting you to talk. I don't really see why you claimed though. It doesn't really serve much of a purpose except that it's either a scum hoping that he's safe by claiming so early, a power role hoping that he's safe by claiming so early, or a townie that hasn't thought things through.

[Inspector Godot]

Well, that's just for you to find out now isn't it.

Oh, don't worry, at the moment I think you're pro-town. It's just that the move wasn't thought through too much. Either that or you're an evil genius that has planned this to a T.

[Inspector Godot]

Gah, I had a birthday to attend and I was away for a few days. I thought I posted that I was going to be absent in this thread but I guess it slipped my mind. Anyway, DWS seems a bit suspicious as do Chenhsi and Wumbo.

[Inspector Godot]

I didnt want to make an easy lynch. As geraintm said earlier in the thread, Mafia never hammer.

Using such an obvious WIFOM seems very suspicious. Surely if you were to use it you could try and disguise it?

[Inspector Godot]

Anyway, DWS seems a bit suspicious as do Chenhsi and Wumbo.

care to explain?

Well I think DWS sort of doesn't need explaining right now. Wumbo didn't really defend himself when he was at L-1 which strikes me as odd and Chenhsi is just giving me a gut feeling which is probably nothing.

[Inspector Godot]

What's the gut feeling?

Meh, it's just a gut feeling based off of nothing. I get them sometimes and they're usually wrong but it was enough for me to list you. To be honest I don't think you're as suspicious as the other two I listed though.

[Inspector Godot]

We have dudes on here now talking about their gut feelings, so we'll see how far that gets us in the game.

I wouldn't vote off a gut feeling unless there was evidence that the person was scum.

[Inspector Godot]

I'm not one for huge posts but at least I feel that I can articulate my thoughts and back them up with evidence when asked. I'm tempted to vote for Chenhsi but I want to give him another chance. At least try and say who's raised your suspicions.

[Inspector Godot]

So Wumbo, if you had to vote for one person: Chenhsi or DWS? Because something tells me that Chen will be the first day lynch.

[Inspector Godot]

After doing some research on Chenhsi in other threads, I'm actually going to vote for him. I'd rather take a chance and lynch a townie that contributes nothing then sit around waiting for the deadline to come.

Vote Chenhsi

[Inspector Godot]

Gah, this is where my inexperience annoys me. I guess I'll

Unvote Chenhsi

but I'd really like to see you pick up the pace. We have six days left until we reach the deadline. I guess it's time for a reread.

[Inspector Godot]

I'm willing to accept that it was a joke vote, but it could very well have given us a few clues.

Those clues being?

I said

could

have. I was looking for people to question me and/or act suspicious, neither of which happened. The only thing that really stood out to me was you taking a clear joke vote way too seriously. I'm still not sure if that was a good play on your behalf or not.

Well, that's just for you to find out now isn't it.

Oh, don't worry, at the moment I think you're pro-town. It's just that the move wasn't thought through too much. Either that or you're an evil genius that has planned this to a T.

Why the unnecessary remainder of doubt placed on Wumbo? Do you consider that last possibility to be valid or not? Because the sentence seems weirdly unnecessary.

It was a weak joke. Don't take it to seriously.

Gah, I had a birthday to attend and I was away for a few days. I thought I posted that I was going to be absent in this thread but I guess it slipped my mind. Anyway, DWS seems a bit suspicious as do Chenhsi and Wumbo.

You listed everyone the people talked about... and also contradicted yourself on Wumbo. Why the sudden change of heart?

While I was gone Wumbo had been put on L-1 and a hell of a lot of fingerpointing was going on. I was reading it and was eager to see what Wumbo had to say about being put on L-1 and.... he didn't mention it at all.

]

We have dudes on here now talking about their gut feelings, so we'll see how far that gets us in the game.

I wouldn't vote off a gut feeling unless there was evidence that the person was scum.

Can you give an example of such evidence? To me, all mafia votes are gut feelings explained in a logical manner. Mafia isn't a game of debating.[/quote]

I don't really get what you're asking here. It would be basically a normal vote except I doubt I'd take it off quite as fast.

DWS, Wumbo and Godot all said something amounting to "serious time nao", and I really don't understand it. Why would anyone say that? Is a clear and direct transaction necessarily better for the town?

I said it because it looked like the joke voting stage was over to me. So sue me.

Gah, this is where my inexperience annoys me. I guess I'll

Unvote Chenhsi

but I'd really like to see you pick up the pace. We have six days left until we reach the deadline. I guess it's time for a reread.

Those results being?

StrangerCoug and Imaginality seem the most pro-town. You, maxwellhouse, Cass, nhat and geraintm are most likely town in my book, but max does need to post a bit more. Tom and Kenfucius don't give me much of a read. Chen.... Really annoys me but I see no reason to doubt his claim of cop. DWS seems very suspicious but he could just be a fellow newbie. Wumbo is 50/50 at the moment.

[Inspector Godot]

Vote DWS

You could be a fellow newbie. But your post targeting nhat is one of many very suspicious posts and the newbie card should not be a get out of jail free card. Seeing as we're only a few days away from the deadline I feel comfortable voting for you.

[Inspector Godot]

Welcome Battousai. Hypatia, does this mean we get an extension on the deadline?

[Inspector Godot]

Top three (No order)
DWS
Wumbo
Tom

Mod, can we please

Prod Tom

[Inspector Godot]

...

Damn, I need more sleep. Back to bed.

[Inspector Godot]

Yeah, Chenhsi shouldn't say who his suspects are. As long as he has at least one though that's all that matters.

[Inspector Godot]

So we either have two cops or one of you is lying.... I'd love to vote for Chenhsi but I want there to be a lynch today and both of you could very well be cops.

[Inspector Godot]

Well if my counting is correct DWS is at L-2. I found Chen scummier but the fact that no one counter claimed was enough for me to remove my vote. But now, I'm more than happy to remove my vote from DWS and take him down to L-3. If we get to the deadline and there are more votes on DWS then Chenhsi I will change though as I don't want a no-lynch on day 1.

Unvote DWS

Vote Chenhsi

[Inspector Godot]

The way I see it there are a few options:

A) Max is scum and trying to get us to lynch another townie.

B) Max is insane so DWS is innocent.

C) Max is sane and DWS is scum.


What Litral said about Chenshi's role being Town Cop is a pretty good point. At the moment I'm debating whether or not I should vote for DWS or Max. Either way, it looks like one will be lynched today and one tomorrow.

[Inspector Godot]

godot, why you planning the pair of lynches like that? if dark comes up scum, surely that would give max a day off at least?

I wasn't planning lynches, I was just saying what seemed likely to happen. And yes, if Dark was scum Max would almost certainly be confirmed town.

[Inspector Godot]

well, the way you went "either way, one will be lynched today and th eother tomorrow" looked like you had your next two days lynches osrted out

No, that was the vibe I was getting from the messages already posted. For all we know DWS and Max could escape the lynch today.

[Inspector Godot]

So DWS is at L-2, which I feel comfortable with right now. I'd like to see some thoughts from Wumbo.

Godot's tunnelling post gives me the same bad feeling - that he is limiting our choices to those that can both be bad for us.

Limiting our choices to those that can both be bad for us? What?

[Inspector Godot]

So nice to see you try and start a bandwagon on me, especially considering that you've listed me in your top suspects and not really attacked me at all this game. I'd love to put an OMGUS on you, but that would put you at L-1 and that strikes me as a very scummy thing to do.

[Inspector Godot]

What are you talking about? Investigating yourself is only a wasted night IF we lynch DWS today. If we lynch someone else and tomorrow you tell us your result.

If you get guilty, your insane. If you get innocent, we lynch DWS and that will prove your alignment. So if we lynch DWS today it will prove your sanity, but not your alignment. If we wait until tomorrow, then that will prove your alignment and sanity.

How many other people do we have that we could lynch? If DWS is lynched and shows up as town, then Max should investigate himself. If DWS shows up as Mafia, Max can investigate someone else. If he gets guilty on them too then maybe it's worth debating before they are lynched.

[Inspector Godot]

if dark comes up innocent, then the choice then is do we lynch max who is either an unhelpful cop or scum, of course depending on if there is a night kill.
games with 2 cops suck by the way

But if Max is an unhelpful cop he is confirmed town. As long as he keeps posting there is absolutely no way we should lynch him.

[Inspector Godot]

But if Max is an unhelpful cop he is confirmed town. As long as he keeps posting there is absolutely no way we should lynch him.

How do you know max is confirmed town?

I don't, I'm working off the dangerous assumption that he is. I understand that it is a bit stupid, but max has given me a pretty pro-town vibe so far.

Vote: Inspector Godot

. You seem to be banking on max being cop. Is it because your scum and know he's not or are you trying to protect your partner?

Hey, I'm just an optimist. Like I said, it's probably a stupid attitude to have but I'd really like to think that we still have a cop.

[Inspector Godot]

Why do you say assuming maxwellhouse is really the second cop is dangerous?

FoS: Inspector Godot

Because it is. He could easily be scum who saw a chance to get rid of the cop and get himself in as town cop. I'm just not getting that vibe from his posts though.

[Inspector Godot]

Well... I did target Imaginality night 1, but it was most definitely not to kill him. If I have to roleclaim I will, but I'd like more information on your role nhat. It seems pretty powerful.

[Inspector Godot]

Actually, I may as well roleclaim. Way I see it I have no other choice.


I am a Reporter. I choose one player and the next day I am told in a PM whether or not that player was home. I do not receive any additional information, I am just told if the person was home or not.

[Inspector Godot]

So, you want my actions?

Night 1: Investigated imaginality. Obviously he was home. I investigated him because he was the most pro-town player in my point and if he was away from home I would have pegged him as a power role. Of course, he could have also been mafia or serial killer or some other scum role but eh.

Night 2: Investigated Wumbo. He hasn't posted much and I was interested to see if he was a scum trying to go under the radar or possibly a power role keeping quiet. Unfortunately I was told that he was at home, so I guess he's just a normal townie.


Anyway, with regards to nhat's role it seems really powerful, especially considering we've had two cops and all. I guess if I want to stay alive I have to

Vote nhat

[Inspector Godot]

Godot, why would you want to figure out if someone was a town powerrole? Why not investigate DWS, or Wumbo that day? Both of those people were wagoned against D1.

I figured that Max would investigate DWS. I did think of investigating Wumbo but I went with Imaginality because if he was a power role then I thought that if he claimed I could claim to back him up. Looking back Wumbo would have been a better day 1 choice, but what can I do? And besides, why is everyone so ready to take nhat's word? It is a very powerful role, and although this could be my inexperience it seems to powerful for a Mini.

[Inspector Godot]

One of the main reasons I do not believe your claim, godot, is from D1. It seems to me nhat wanted DWS lynched, whereas you didn't really seemed to defend him a bit. Also, I found it a little suspicious that you wanted to lynch chenshi with the reasoning that was basically "I would rather lynch an inactive townie than wait for deadline."

A lynch is better then a no-lynch. Chen and DWS were the best two candidates for lynch and I went with Chen, figuring that DWS would be the day two lynch. It looks bad now but no one was complaining back then.

[Inspector Godot]

So...where was your vote for DWS on day 2?

Despite how scummy he looked I didn't want a quick lynch. The possibilities of Max being a scum needed to be considered. Truth be told, I probably would have voted DWS if Day 2 had been just a few days longer. People seem to be going for what they hope is true instead of considering both possibilities. Hell, I did that on Day 2 myself with Max.

[Inspector Godot]

So, that's a lynch? Damn. Good luck.