Mafia 78: Meta Breaking Mafia 1 - Game over!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

I'm calling BS on this one. How convenient that you break out the guilty in this probable LYLO situation. Your fakeclaim is all making sense now.

First you choose to no-kill Night 2 to fool the town into thinking TSdoc successfully protected you.

Then you still do not kill TSdoc Night 3 since you knew you probably would draw the protection again.

Next when TSdoc indicated she might not protect you anymore Day 4, you killed her Night 4.

And now you go for the win.

Finally, a sane cop + doc combo is the ultimate anti-meta-breaking role pair in mafia.

Vote: Tar

[Surye]

Unvote

MM brings up some good points, don't want anyone at L-1 right yet.

[shaft.ed]

I'm leaning Tar on this one. If scum didn't skip the kill they'd be celebrating a win right now and not in LyLo. Skipping kills is not a bright strategy here. On the otehr hand after losing two scum it might have been the only way to stay alive.

Also reading over his claim again it was very much unprovoked. I am a bit cautious that in a game like this one might suspect a Cop to be absent. I need to reread MM reaction to Tar's claim. I would expect it to be rather incredulous.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

I need to reread MM reaction to Tar's claim. I would expect it to be rather incredulous.

Actually my reaction was the opposite of incredulous. At that time I had just day-investigated Tar and thought it was highly likely my sanity was insane due to CoolBot flipping town, so I believed Tar's claim. Obviously now I know Tar is fakeclaiming and my sanity is paranoid.

[shaft.ed]

OK I've been thinking about this over the weekend and I believe that lynching between the masons is the correct play. If Tar and MM were scum partners, Tar's guilty would not be placed on MM as a bus, but would instead be used in an attempt to take out the last townie in LyLo. Thus one of the masons must be scum.

PEG would you care log'ing in to tell us which of the masons is scum?

Mod can we get a PEG prod/replacement please?

[Surye]

OK I've been thinking about this over the weekend and I believe that lynching between the masons is the correct play. If Tar and MM were scum partners, Tar's guilty would not be placed on MM as a bus, but would instead be used in an attempt to take out the last townie in LyLo. Thus one of the masons must be scum.

PEG would you care log'ing in to tell us which of the masons is scum?

Mod can we get a PEG prod/replacement please?

This is an excellent point, MM/Tar scum pair does not make sense. Either MM/Peg or MM/shaft.ed or Peg/shaft.ed is the scumpair. Or. Tar/shaft.ed or Tar/Peg.

shaft.ed and peg are in 3 of the possibilites, more then tar or mm. Straight statistics say they are the best bet, and honestly, were the people I already stated that I am suspicious of them both, so the statistics just confirm that.

Tar needs to post about his meta claim.

shaft.ed, who do you trust more, MM or Tar?

[shaft.ed]

I trust Tar a bit more than MM at the moment. MM has been growing on me however.

[Surye]

I trust Tar a bit more than MM at the moment. MM has been growing on me however.

Same question, regarding me and peg.

[shaft.ed]

I trust you more than PEG, but I have nothing to go on with PEG.

[Tarhalindur]

OK I've been thinking about this over the weekend and I believe that lynching between the masons is the correct play. If Tar and MM were scum partners, Tar's guilty would not be placed on MM as a bus, but would instead be used in an attempt to take out the last townie in LyLo. Thus one of the masons must be scum.

PEG would you care log'ing in to tell us which of the masons is scum?

Mod can we get a PEG prod/replacement please?

[Tarhalindur]

EBWOP: Computer malfunction, disregard that.

[Surye]

EBWOP: Computer malfunction, disregard that.

You gonna come back and make a real post?

[Tarhalindur]

EBWOP: Computer malfunction, disregard that.

You gonna come back and make a real post?

Yes, but I have to think over all the situations first.

Also, I should note now that 1) a recheck indicates only a partial meta on PEG (town only), and 2) at this point, I disagree with shaft.ed - in no small part because, if there's two surviving scum, I think he's one of them.

[shaft.ed]

Also, I should note now that 1) a recheck indicates only a partial meta on PEG (town only), and 2) at this point, I disagree with shaft.ed - in no small part because, if there's two surviving scum, I think he's one of them.

So investigated innocent trumps scum mason then? Which mason(s) have you investigated again?

And my major point was the MM and yourself are not scum together. From my perspective it is obvious there must be a scum mason, and it is quite likely one of yourself and MM are lying.

[Guardian]

Still have no reliable internet access, sadly.

I'll prod PEG.

Deadline is about one week from now, exactly, but I may extend that a day or two due to my mod-ing absence-ness.

[pickemgenius]

I WOULD LOVE TI LINK YOU GUYS TO MY NEWBIE GAME POST BUT ALAS I WILL RETYPE THIS OUT!


I HAVE SHITTY HOTEL INTERNET AND HAVE FOR AWHILE (PERMISSIVE TDY YAYAYAYAYAYAYAY) AND HAS EVEN GONE OUT FOR EXTENDED PERIODS OF TIME (LIKE A DAYISH ONCE).





YOU GUYS KNOW MY ROLE ALREADY SO THAT'S OK AND STUFF, BUT I MOSTLY ROLL ON FINDING SCUM FROM PREVIOUS SCUM REACTIONS. I HAVE HAD... caps lock off now, more success doing this than overthinking everydamn little thing. Go with what's there, and if nothing's there you can take one of two different paths.

1. Raise Hell
2. Wait till something new piques your interest.

Nothing has ridiculously jumped out at me recently. Sure some stuff I don't particularly care for, but in the big picture doesn't look that bad.

[shaft.ed]

Is PEG always this useful?

MM how'd your investigation go last night?

[Surye]

I thought MM was a day cop, a paranoid day cop for that matter... At least by his claim.

[shaft.ed]

I thought MM was a day cop, a paranoid day cop for that matter... At least by his claim.

you weren't supposed to say anything. It was a poor trap to test his claim.

[Surye]

I thought MM was a day cop, a paranoid day cop for that matter... At least by his claim.

you weren't supposed to say anything. It was a poor trap to test his claim.

Doh. Well, it was silly But sorry for spoiling it.

[Guardian]

Deadline is exactly 1 week's time from now.

[shaft.ed]

Deadline is exactly 1 week's time from now.

Yay and the town is lurking to victory!

[Surye]

Deadline is exactly 1 week's time from now.

Yay and the town is lurking to victory!

Seriously, what happened.

[shaft.ed]

The scum seemed to have gone with the "kill are posters" strategy in this game.

[Tarhalindur]

I apologize for the lack of posting (I've been borderline flaking since early in the game).

I can't promise more right now, however: a family emergency just came up, and my access

may

be affected. I'll try to get my big post up ASAP, though, it's half-written.

Request Deadline Extension