Mushroom Kingdom Mafia (Game over!)

[Surye]

Pop is the only 100% confirmed to me, only because I saw the mushroom, and am 100% it dos not flip alignment. Well, unless you think he's some crazy death miller ;P

Mod edit:
Visible votecount:
Riceballtail (1): skitzer
Gimbo (1): Riceballtail
Surye (1): somestrangeflea
somestrangeflea (2): Gimbo, armlx
Cream147 (2): Alabaska J, populartajo
armlx (1): TheSweatpantsNinja

Not voting (15): iamausername, Phoebus, sideney, Surye, killa seven, Gremwell, mr. incrediball, farside22, andersonw, malthusis, FaerieLord, Cream147, Korts, ashmite84, goborage

With 23 alive it takes 12 real votes to lynch.

[iamausername]

Oh yeah, forgot we had two people who know exactly what the 1-up mushroom does. I guess Gimbo and Surye could still both be scum and be hiding the fact that the mushroom flips alignment, but yeah, tajo is basically confirmed town.

[armlx]

IAU, I wouldn't clear Gremwell just yet. The possiblity of scum faking an investigation on town still exists.

[skitzer]

OK.

I was thinking about this during the night: RBT claimed as Yoshi, and he can't hold items or anything. But I was like, "Wait, yoshi has arms!". So I thought some more, and those little bombs, Bob-Ombs, don't have arms, so they couldn't hold coins or items in that facture...

Just a hunch, but I'm going to

Vote: Riceballtail

I would like a bit more input on this. It seems plausible.

[Surye]

IAU, I wouldn't clear Gremwell just yet. The possiblity of scum faking an investigation on town still exists.

QFT.

Gremwell has zero confrimedness. Hell, if DK crew is another scum group, then there is Bowser and DKers that could be investigating to find eachother.

[iamausername]

Well, multiple scumgroups mean a faked investigation might not be accurate, which could end up implicating him later on. And using up coins on investigations seems like a poor use of resources for scum.

I agree that it's possible Gremwell is scum (as I said, none of the players I listed are confirmed), I just don't think it's likely on the current evidence.

[Gimbo]

but who ever said Gremwell is telling the truth? am i missing something?

as far as i know, in this game, 2 ppl are confirmed town, me and pop, thats it.

FALSE!

You are NOT confirmed town.

And then you

accuse

Grem of lying? I have half the notion to lynch you for saying this garbage. If you are going to say you're confirmed town, then you should be saying TSN is too, since there's at least as much evidence his direction than yours. You are defeating your own defense.

RBT, 1 word for you

READ

"as are as

I

know"

P.S. 'accuse' is a strong buddy, i didn't

accuse

Grem of anything, i am merely considering the fact that he might not be

truthful

[Gimbo]

IAU, I wouldn't clear Gremwell just yet. The possiblity of

scum faking an investigation

on town still exists.

THANK YOU!! the ONLY one (besides me!) that's making sense so far.

[Gimbo]

EBWOP: ^ p.s. Surye also

[Cream147]

OK.

I was thinking about this during the night: RBT claimed as Yoshi, and he can't hold items or anything. But I was like, "Wait, yoshi has arms!". So I thought some more, and those little bombs, Bob-Ombs, don't have arms, so they couldn't hold coins or items in that facture...

Just a hunch, but I'm going to

Vote: Riceballtail

I would like a bit more input on this. It seems plausible.

Obviously as far as Mario goes, you are absolutely right about everything you said there. That said, I think you're probably reading a bit too much into Mario and not enough into Mafia.

[armlx]

Gimbo, I do not believe the result is incorrect, only that by revealing it Gremwall is not confirmed.

[Gimbo]

^ yes, but the result could be incorrect, nothing about the investigation or Gremwell is confirmed. confirmed = 100%, 99% = unlikely but still unconfirmed

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

yes, but the result could be incorrect, nothing about the investigation or Gremwell is confirmed. confirmed = 100%, 99% = unlikely but still unconfirmed

Doesn't that describe you? Isn't that how this whole thing got started?

[Surye]

99% = unlikely but still unconfirmed

Kinda like you. Yet you've called yourself confirmed more then once?

[armlx]

^ yes, but the result could be incorrect, nothing about the investigation or Gremwell is confirmed. confirmed = 100%, 99% = unlikely but still unconfirmed

I doubt the result is incorrect. The two scenarios is if Gremwall is scum group A, TSN is scum group B, which is very unlikely and for all intents and purposes makes the investigation pro-town unless Gremwall flips scum, or a straight up gambit which is fairly risky. The later can be eliminated by simply saying TSN can not be the person to investigate Gremwall so that if it is true Gremwall is investigated by a 3rd party or or lynched to reveal alignment.

[Gremwell]

we can make a feather chain, though it could be easily derailed by scumz

[Cream147]

IAU, I wouldn't clear Gremwell just yet. The possiblity of

scum faking an investigation

on town still exists.

THANK YOU!! the ONLY one (besides me!) that's making sense so far.

This made me laugh. You make less sense than a *insert something with no sense here*. I have a problem with Gimbo. He continually reminds us how he's nearly confirmed town. I can just imagine him as scum laughing behind our back. I'm pretty sure Surye is town. If he were scum, I don't think he'd care about Gimbo revealing the fact that Gimbo has 2 votes, he'd agree with Gimbo to keep it a secret, and then kill Gimbo at night.

Popular is the only confirmed innocent. Of course, that doesn't mean that what he says is right. I'd wish Gimbo would learn this as well. Gimbo seems to think that everything he says is right. You'd at least hope that we can trust that every post from Gimbo has the town's best interests in mind, but he's already proved that even that is too much to ask from him.

[somestrangeflea]

we can make a feather chain

OOH! AND THEN WE CAN BRAID EACH OTHER'S HAIR AND WATCH

DANGEROUS LIASONS

!

I'm not proud of that...

[Gremwell]

Give one coin to populartajo

I'm guessing your broke but if we can pool you 5 you could feather me tonight confirming myself and TSN 100%

[iamausername]

Give one coin to populartajo

I'm guessing your broke but if we can pool you 5 you could feather me tonight confirming myself and TSN 100%

This is a good plan.

[armlx]

This made me laugh. You make less sense than a *insert something with no sense here*. I have a problem with Gimbo. He continually reminds us how he's nearly confirmed town. I can just imagine him as scum laughing behind our back. I'm pretty sure Surye is town. If he were scum, I don't think he'd care about Gimbo revealing the fact that Gimbo has 2 votes, he'd agree with Gimbo to keep it a secret, and then kill Gimbo at night.

You would also distrust Gimbo.

Either Cream or SSF is fine with me for now.

[Lawrencelot]

Give one coin to populartajo

Transaction succesful. Gremwell loses 1 coin and populartajo gains 1 coin.

[farside22]

Give one coin to populartajo

I'm guessing your broke but if we can pool you 5 you could feather me tonight confirming myself and TSN 100%

This is a good plan.

Only one problem I have with this and no TSN you can't jump up on me for this. Is that we still don't know if there is a doc to protect. I would like to have pop investigate as he is the only true known alignment, but I worry about the scum taking him out before we get an answer.

[Lawrencelot]

malthusis asked replacement. If you know someone you think is interested in this game, please tell Flameaxe.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Only one problem I have with this and no TSN you can't jump up on me for this.

Can so, but I won't. That's a legitimate complaint. If pop is going to use a feather, he can't also hold a mushroom.

Of course, we could give him enough for a star.