Perfect Masquerade [Game Over]

[Lady 5]

Honestly, theres alot I could say about L5 not accepting the proposal.

I thought she would have accepted that asap since people scumread her and probably have her pinned as a first target.

Im not sure how that makes me feel ie her alignment

Do people still scum read me for emojis? XD or something else?

[Lady 5]

I can still work with L5, for reasons.

But I share the sentiment with L4 that her previous post was bad.

What’s your reason.

[Gentleman 5]

Keep going

[Lady 4]

L5, could you please explain any of your reads at all?

[Gentleman 5]

Gentleman 5 would help with pushing my scum Reads but I’d have trouble trusting him at least in the beginning as he’s not my Lock Town where I can say with 100% confidence that Gentleman 3 is Town.
Me and Him can share are Reads and make stronger solving.

This reads to me as something I would say in a scum PT. Like something I would ask my scumbuddies before accepting the proposal. Given her hesitance, It makes me wonder.

I think L8 is mafia, I dont think L5 can be mafia with L8 given their interactions imo, so I may have to check into my reads of both.

L5 are you just going to ignore this as well?

[Gentleman 3]

Can we please stop with the altguesses? It would really suck if he started force replacing due to it.

+1

That seems pretty clearly against the idea of the game.

[Gentleman 3]

That pairing of G2-L9 lost its luster when L9 started posting.

FTFY.

[Gentleman 3]

This reads to me as something I would say in a scum PT.

???

[Gentleman 3]

Maybe I should dance with the lettuce lady.

Im a BIG sucker for those stories where the two people who dont like each other come together and find out they were meant for each other in the end

Not a good idea, if you both are town one of you would probably end up walking out on the other like a bonehead.

[Gentleman 3]

On a related note, if anyone here is considering forming a pair with the intent to catch your partner off guard by leaving-- don't.

[Gentleman 3]

I'm surprised L5 didn't respond to my posts from this morning.

[Gentleman 5]

That pairing of G2-L9 lost its luster when L9 started posting.

FTFY.

Ooooooooh Explain this one!

This reads to me as something I would say in a scum PT.

???

Oooooooooh I thought I explained this one!

Maybe I should dance with the lettuce lady.

Im a BIG sucker for those stories where the two people who dont like each other come together and find out they were meant for each other in the end

Not a good idea, if you both are town one of you would probably end up walking out on the other like a bonehead.

Im not sure why you think this. Im a reasonable guy, just need to call her pretty and make her feel wanted. Its gentleman 101

[Gentleman 3]

Ooooooooh Explain this one!

I don't think L9 has ever been towny. Not much to explain.

[Gentleman 3]

Oooooooooh I thought I explained this one!

Did you? I don't think it's normal for scum to post reads in the scum PT as though they really believe them.

[Gentleman 5]

Why do you feel L9 hasnt been towny. Any specifics?

I ask because I think she is my top townread

[Lady 7]

Hmm

3
7/1
8

Of the ones left.

Can you clarify this statment please?

That’s my order of preference for pairing based on who is left.

[Gentleman 3]

She's clearly a strong player; she's playing solidly, outing reads, asking questions, but there's nothing there that reads as specifically motivated by solving rather than motivated by keeping up the appearance of solving-- it could easily be either one.

[Gentleman 5]

Oooooooooh I thought I explained this one!

Did you? I don't think it's normal for scum to post reads in the scum PT as though they really believe them.

I assume they are discussing who they should pair with or who is a good person to dance with.

People in the scum PT could be like

“dont partner with G5 since hes probably getting lynched early or plans on leaving right away”

or something similar.

I just see that as her reasoning on why or why not to accept, it rubs me the wrong way.

She's clearly a strong player; she's playing solidly, outing reads, asking questions, but there's nothing there that reads as specifically motivated by solving rather than motivated by keeping up the appearance of solving-- it could easily be either one.

Pushing the game forward in the early game like she has is a plus for me.

I really dont like her activity post-accept though. I know its only been a day and a half but still. Odd

[Gentleman 3]

People in the scum PT could be like “dont partner with G5 since hes probably getting lynched early or plans on leaving right away” or something similar.

But that's not at all what she said.

[Gentleman 3]

Pushing the game forward in the early game like she has is a plus for me.

Ehh. I don't really think pushing the game forward is that towny in a game where deepwolfing is everything.

[Gentleman 5]

People in the scum PT could be like “dont partner with G5 since hes probably getting lynched early or plans on leaving right away” or something similar.

But that's not at all what she said.

Look at that post again.

Im saying it reads as something I would expect in a scum pt. It doesnt feel right. I dont know what more I can say.

Pushing the game forward in the early game like she has is a plus for me.

Ehh. I don't really think pushing the game forward is that towny in a game where deepwolfing is everything.

Unless I know the person via meta or personal expierences, Im intending to townread her for it, but again, her disappearance has me worried.

[Gentleman 4]

Gentleman 3, do you think Lady 4 is town?

[Gentleman 4]

I know there is no stated time deadline for posting in the thread, but I'm not completely certain if this is due to an oversight or players are legitimately allowed to lurk for the entirety of the game.

If this is merely an oversight,

@moderator, request you prod

Gentleman 1 ~ 2 days 15 hours
Gentleman 8 ~ 2 days 23 hours
Lady 1 ~ 3 days 18 hours

[Gentleman 3]

Look at that post again.

Im saying it reads as something I would expect in a scum pt. It doesnt feel right. I dont know what more I can say.

She says she thinks she would sync well with me or you but she townreads me more than she townreads you.

Those are not genuine concerns scum would have. I don't see why they would be brought up in a scum PT.

[Gentleman 3]

Gentleman 3, do you think Lady 4 is town?

I remember townreading her but I don't remember why. I think part of it was a lot of going against the grain.