Mushroom Kingdom Mafia (Game over!)

[Riceballtail]

Farside: if that were true, then how did Gimbo survive last night? Anyone who wanted that would have probably killed him for it.

Mod edit:
Visible votecount:
somestrangeflea (2): Gimbo, armlx
Cream147 (2): Alabaska J, populartajo
Riceballtail (1): skitzer
Gimbo (1): Riceballtail
Surye (1): somestrangeflea
armlx (1): TheSweatpantsNinja

Not voting (15): iamausername, Phoebus, sideney, Surye, killa seven, Gremwell, mr. incrediball, farside22, andersonw, malthusis, FaerieLord, Cream147, Korts, ashmite84, goborage

With 23 alive it takes 12 real votes to lynch.

[farside22]

Farside: if that were true, then how did Gimbo survive last night? Anyone who wanted that would have probably killed him for it.

I'm not really sure. I'm still thinking about it all.

[iamausername]

I would like to have pop investigate as he is the only true known alignment, but I worry about the scum taking him out before we get an answer.

Well, if they do, that's one more night gone by that they don't get to kidnap Peach. Sounds good to me.

[armlx]

I would like to have pop investigate as he is the only true known alignment, but I worry about the scum taking him out before we get an answer.

Well, if they do, that's one more night gone by that they don't get to kidnap Peach. Sounds good to me.

This is a good post.

[farside22]

I would like to have pop investigate as he is the only true known alignment, but I worry about the scum taking him out before we get an answer.

Well, if they do, that's one more night gone by that they don't get to kidnap Peach. Sounds good to me.

This is a good post.

Good point. I think I just thinking too hard on this.

Give one coin to populartajo

[Alabaska J]

armlx, plz stop failing all over the place, k? Gimbo is NOT confirmed town. However, this doesn't make him scum. Understand? You aren't confirmed town either. THIS MUST MEAN I THINK YOU ARE SCUM LOLZ. Either/or fallacy to the max. Also, I

do

understand what you are trying to say, so don't turn this around as me misrepresenting you. You are trying to say, I believe, that if one is to doubt Gimbo's status as confirmed town, they must think he is scum on some level. This is wrong though, as all I believe ssf is trying to say is that Gimbo is not necessarily confirmed given the information we have about him.

Anyway, can we please lynch Cream?

PLEASE???

At least RBT has shown he can post intelligently. If someone can point out a better target at this point, I'll give them eighty coins. Hint: ssf, Phoebus, and Gimbo are NOT better targets.

[armlx]

This is wrong though, as all I believe ssf is trying to say is that Gimbo is not necessarily confirmed given the information we have about him.

I see it more as SSF trying to leave Gimbo open for accusation. There is straight up no way in my mind if the game is balanced for him to be scum.

[Gremwell]

getting pop a star is a good plan, after all whats another 3 coins if it means a couple 100% townies

also if you think about it that 1up is a fantastic scum item, it would give the scum 2 votes, remove a townie vote, and make them look very town when all they really did was give the scum a 2 vote swing

[iamausername]

How's he supposed to investigate you with a star again?

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

-Star (8 coins): protects yourself against multiple kills for one night, and grants you one nightkill. If you use this nightkill on someone who is on your side, he will not be killed. If you use this nightkill on someone who uses a mushroom or is immune to fireflowers, he will be killed (unless he’s on your side).

No kill means investigation.

[iamausername]

Oh, right, stars are even more useful than I remembered. Go for it then.

[populartajo]

I agree with the star plan. I have zero coins and zero items.
I also dont think Gimbo is confirmed innocent. I thought he was going to die yesterday. I dont know if scum though I was Peach but the logical play (unless we have dumb scum) was to kill someone as active as him and with a powerful item.
Also, for the flavor used in the lynch, does that mean that DK is another scum group?

[Surye]

Also, for the flavor used in the lynch, does that mean that DK is another scum group?

I think that's the running assumption.

[Alabaska J]

This is wrong though, as all I believe ssf is trying to say is that Gimbo is not necessarily confirmed given the information we have about him.

I see it more as SSF trying to leave Gimbo open for accusation. There is straight up no way in my mind if the game is balanced for him to be scum.

We don't know all the items and the number of scum players!

[armlx]

We don't know all the items and the number of scum players!

Actually irrel unless the mod just wanted to make the game more random and cut the scum numbers to fit in Gimbo's role as scum.

[Alabaska J]

We don't know all the items and the number of scum players!

Actually irrel unless the mod just wanted to make the game more random and cut the scum numbers to fit in Gimbo's role as scum.

Or add more town power roles in the form of one-shots. We have a lot of potential one-shots. I think we have just seen the tip of the iceberg, really.

[armlx]

Or add more town power roles in the form of one-shots. We have a lot of potential one-shots. I think we have just seen the tip of the iceberg, really.

I don't think you fully comprehend just how powerful a scum double voter is.

[Alabaska J]

Or add more town power roles in the form of one-shots. We have a lot of potential one-shots. I think we have just seen the tip of the iceberg, really.

I don't think you fully comprehend just how powerful a scum double voter is.

I can't believe you think we wouldn't have one. Real vs. visible votecount? I'm sure there are roles already with more than one vote, and I think that scum double voter could balance out town double voters.

[Cream147]

Are we giving coins to Tajo to get him a star? Well, there's no harm in it anyway.

Give one coin to populartajo

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

I have no coins to give (any longer).

Also, I'll be out of town until the 7th.

[Cream147]

Or add more town power roles in the form of one-shots. We have a lot of potential one-shots. I think we have just seen the tip of the iceberg, really.

I don't think you fully comprehend just how powerful a scum double voter is.

I can't believe you think we wouldn't have one. Real vs. visible votecount? I'm sure there are roles already with more than one vote, and I think that scum double voter could balance out town double voters.

Oh, and shockingly, I agree with Alabaska on this. I would suggest that there are multiple members of the town who can double vote, to balance a single scum member who can double vote. Also, scum double voters in my mind seem less powerful in a game with multiple scum parties (because that means the scum group themselves has less people than average and it's not so easy for them to get themselves to a Lylo situation where the double voter can show his true power)

[Lawrencelot]

Give one coin to populartajo

Transaction succesful. farside22 loses 1 coin and populartajo gains 1 coin.

Give one coin to populartajo

Transaction succesful. Cream147 loses 1 coin and populartajo gains 1 coin.

[somestrangeflea]

Give one coin to populartajo

BANDWAGON.

Also,

Unvote

. I for got. Soz Surye. D=

[Lawrencelot]

Give one coin to populartajo

Transaction succesful. somestrangeflea loses 1 coin and populartajo gains 1 coin.

[iamausername]

I have no coins to give.

This is my situation also, in case anyone was wondering why I'm backing this plan without putting my money where my mouth is.