Mushroom Kingdom Mafia (Game over!)

[Korts]

Actually, I don't think the primary goal for the scum would be to kill a confirmed townie anyway. Look at it like this: to scum, populartajo is now confirmed not-Peach.

[armlx]

Actually, I don't think the primary goal for the scum would be to kill a confirmed townie anyway. Look at it like this: to scum, populartajo is now confirmed not-Peach.

You make a valid point, but this sounds like something that isn't good to risk as if the scum are just going for the killing people method of winning it just lets them blow us out.

[iamausername]

Considering there was only one kill last night (which I was pretty surprised by with the way this game works), it would take them a damn long time to work through the entire town.

[armlx]

I guess. I haven't really done the math, and discussing scum strategy much further seems like poor play as it just tells them how to play correctly.

[Cream147]

i'm not sure how confirming grem confirms TSN. where does it say the feathers are sanity guaranteed?


(it's a reach, i know. but if we're considering the possibility that gimbo is scum, then why not do the same for TSN?)


i understand the star idea now. unfortunately, now the scum know not to try n kill pop anyway >.<

Insane feathers...I find it unlikely, though I suppose the possibility cannot be ruled out. I would say that's picking at straws though.

Your comparison between the situation we have with Gimbo and the situation we will have with TSN if Gremwell is confirmed innocent isn't a good one in my opinion. Gimbo is only believed innocent because of the item he was holding. TSN would be believed innocent because of an investigation, which holds up a little better in my opinion.

Yes, the scum know not to nightkill popular, but let's not open a whole WIFOM argument about whether or not popular should bother getting the star and should instead just get a feather.

Mod: You probably won't be able to answer this but if you can, are the feather's investigation results accurate?

As I said, you probably can't answer that, but it's worth giving it a go!

[Phoebus]

week without access.
catching up tomorrow.

[Gremwell]

As for the coin claim if we gave all out coins to pop they would all be safe for the night, and those who didn't give them up would be prime lynch targets, those scum who did give up their coins would have no night items aside from whatever they are currently holding or their character powers (if any), and if pop confirms me and TSN then we can take a portion of the coins and then that night we can confirm or kill 3 more people, and so on and so forth.

[Cream147]

As for the coin claim if we gave all out coins to pop they would all be safe for the night, and those who didn't give them up would be prime lynch targets, those scum who did give up their coins would have no night items aside from whatever they are currently holding or their character powers (if any), and if pop confirms me and TSN then we can take a portion of the coins and then that night we can confirm or kill 3 more people, and so on and so forth.

That actually makes sense you know. It's very easy to check if people are hiding coins as well, as we just get them to give a coin anyway, and their transaction will fail if they don't have any coins.

[Gimbo]

fan-tastic!

[Korts]

brilliant!

(hah!)

[Gimbo]

^ shut up!

"fan-tastic!"

Eccleston FTW, DW will never be the same again...

back to relevant stuff,

Give 1,000,00,000 coins to populartajo

hehe

[Flameaxe]

Hi. I'm the back-up mod. I need to catch up a bit, and I still don't have mod powers .

[Korts]

^ shut up!

"fan-tastic!"

Eccleston FTW, DW will never be the same again...

back to relevant stuff,

Give 1,000,00,000 coins to populartajo

hehe

Yeah, Eccleston's the best. But you gotta admit, Tennant's grown on me these three seasons. I'm almost sad he's going. Well, I say sad, but I mean a bit uneasy. Well, I say uneasy... [/offtopic]

[Korts]

On topic, though: that was my only coin I gave to populartajo. Proving it will be easy, I'll just wait until the first coin gets through.

[Gimbo]

Tennant's okay but you can't beat Eccleston


BACK TO TOPIC: lets do a headcount of who gave coins and who didn't.

[Alabaska J]

So no one is going to investigate anyone tonight or protect themselves from a nightkill or kill someone other than pop? Um…don't like this very much, especially with there being something pop hasn't told us.

[Gimbo]

Ok, according to my role/item PM, pop is not hiding anything. However, its possible that the shroom secretly changes alignment or something (known only to pop), I have no idea..so pop isn't as confirmed as you might think.

P.S. Journey's End blows some serious monkey scrotum

[Cream147]

So no one is going to investigate anyone tonight or protect themselves from a nightkill or kill someone other than pop? Um…don't like this very much, especially with there being something pop hasn't told us.

To quell your fears, why don't we force popular to say what he's got to say before everyone gives away all their coins then? I see no reason why he should be hiding anything anyway...

[armlx]

What is the count on PT's coins? I have extra to give, but its not worth it unless he needs more.

[Gremwell]

However, its possible that the shroom secretly changes alignment or something (known only to pop), I have no idea..so pop isn't as confirmed as you might think.

By that same token its also possible that the mushroom makes him supreme ruler the Philip Morris Co. and able to levy heavy tariffs on kraft dinners

I'd say that the mushroom does what it say it does, no more, no less.

I'd also venture a FOS on Alabaska J, if everyone gives up their coins you wouldn't need to protect yourself from a night kill because even the scum would be coin less, and why would you be a target without coins in such a big group?

[goborage]

Well pop has at least 8 coins already. I share Alabaska's concerns. If everyone gives all their coins then we are helping to direct NKs (ie anywhere but pop). This of course assumes that a non-item NK exists. Another danger is the previously brought up possibility of a scum coin stealing technique.

If neither of these scenarios exist then mass-coin pooling seems like a good idea. But for some reason I think the mod would have prepared measures against such a strat.

In short, I think 8 coins a day is plenty. But maybe we can shift around which players give on each day so that the same 8 aren't stuck with a chore.

[farside22]

As for the coin claim if we gave all out coins to pop they would all be safe for the night, and those who didn't give them up would be prime lynch targets, those scum who did give up their coins would have no night items aside from whatever they are currently holding or their character powers (if any), and if pop confirms me and TSN then we can take a portion of the coins and then that night we can confirm or kill 3 more people, and so on and so forth.

This has been the best suggestion so far and i agree with it. The scum will never get to kill pop with the star. He can verify someone by targeting that person. If the person lives they are town. Then some coins are transfered (if enough exist) to do more test.

[armlx]

I'd say that the mushroom does what it say it does, no more, no less.

Agree. Anything else is probably bastard moddery.

[armlx]

EBWODP: I can endorse the Star a day plan, as its actually a plan that we can prove logically works, instead of TSN's abstract concept or the cop thing that is iffy at best.

[killa seven]

how many coins does he need as of now?