BooneyToonz XIII: To Boon or Not To Boon - [END]

[Haggle]

VOTE: Bambi
Who's your top tier scum, Bambi?

-Hectic

[Bambi Jay]

I am perfectly ok with voting Bambi Jay given the mental calisthenics they just posted and yesterday's hammer without a claim plus our townblock size.

I'm doing that because of who it is. Duh.

And Why bring up the hammer now instead of at the beginning of the day?

[Haggle]

That reminds me, where's that Aaron Fucking Frost guy? It may be Burden of Proficiency, but I would've expected him to solve the game by now if he's town. Him not being the night 1 kill is suspicion on its own.

-Hectic

[Haggle]

Oh wait a second, he isn't hammered?

I GET A BIRTHDAY HAMMER.

VOTE: Romeo/Juliet

WOOHOO!

Oh no, this is a pretty scummy hammer.

-Hectic

[Titus]

I am perfectly ok with voting Bambi Jay given the mental calisthenics they just posted and yesterday's hammer without a claim plus our townblock size.

I'm doing that because of who it is. Duh.

And Why bring up the hammer now instead of at the beginning of the day?

You did see the list of shit I had to get through? Right?

AF might be scum too. This is my second game with him. We were scum partners the other time.

[Haggle]

AF might be scum too. This is my second game with him. We were scum partners the other time.

I had the privilege of being in that game. How is his play similar here?

-Hectic

[Titus]

AF might be scum too. This is my second game with him. We were scum partners the other time.

I had the privilege of being in that game. How is his play similar here?

-Hectic

I feel like me answering this question serves as confirmation bias as I haven't seen toen him.

[Haggle]

And Why bring up the hammer now instead of at the beginning of the day?

Why is that important?
Also, going offline after being asked who scum is suggests tactical lurking. Thoughts on dayvigging here, Joan?

-Hectic

[Boonskiies]

@MOD: Was the JD flip change that nerfed cops an "after night" type thing? While I appreciate the prompt reply to the PM, it should be a public answer IMO

Yup.

[Doctor Drew]

That reminds me, where's that Aaron Fucking Frost guy? It may be Burden of Proficiency, but I would've expected him to solve the game by now if he's town. Him not being the night 1 kill is suspicion on its own.

-Hectic

How so?

[Creature]

So my result didn't fail because of JD

[Titus]

@MOD: Was the JD flip change that nerfed cops an "after night" type thing? While I appreciate the prompt reply to the PM, it should be a public answer IMO

Yup.

Well ok. Looks like my interpretation was wrong.

[chkflip]

Consider me hard lurking for a bit.

Ta ta.

[Bambi Jay]

And Why bring up the hammer now instead of at the beginning of the day?

Why is that important?
Also, going offline after being asked who scum is suggests tactical lurking. Thoughts on dayvigging here, Joan?

-Hectic

Because saving up a past mistake for when it's convenient to use is weird. Like "I can lynch them now if I combine this with this" sorta thing.

You may not like my attempt to solve, Titus, but I'm atleast trying to give you both a reason why your abilities failed.

[Titus]

That means fmpov

Assuming town Creature...

Then either

A) A50 is lying scum ascetic who faked hider to cover his ascetic.

Odds: Low. ScumA50 wouldn't bait an investigation.

2) A50 is scum but not ascetic. Titus was healed/roleblocked and Creature was roleblocked.

Odds: Low. Plausible though. This requires specific actions though and me to get healed over cops.

3)A50 is town and Creature was roleblocked.

Odds: Moderate. It requires the least logistical hoops.

4) A50 is town ascetic.
Odds: Only possible in theory. Inconsistent with his play and he knows better.

[Nancy Drew 39]

Guys, let’s not rush any lynch please. We were wrong on R & J, so I want us to do everything possible to get it right this time.

[davesaz]

I can't help with interpreting your new modifier, there are too many ways it could happen to be deterministic.
I feel like Creature wouldn't make up a no result for most situations. And there are numerous ways that can happen as well.

Pedit:
5) A50 was JK'd which would interfere with both actions regardless of A50's alignment. Takes the least amount of assumptions.

[Bambi Jay]

5: Almost is actually Hider and wasn't there for your abilities to work.

Odds: Moderate.

[Haggle]

That reminds me, where's that Aaron Fucking Frost guy? It may be Burden of Proficiency, but I would've expected him to solve the game by now if he's town. Him not being the night 1 kill is suspicion on its own.

-Hectic

How so?

He's a really powerful player. I've seen him catch all 5 scum in a large game on page 10. 3 of them hadn't even posted yet.

-Hectic

[Bambi Jay]

Assuming Almost is Hider when he claimed it before, and assuming someone would Jailkeep him when he said he could check someone but instead they RB him?

I like my conclusion better.

[Venus and Mars]

That reminds me, where's that Aaron Fucking Frost guy? It may be Burden of Proficiency, but I would've expected him to solve the game by now if he's town. Him not being the night 1 kill is suspicion on its own.

-Hectic

How so?

I’m still shocked it was Expresso. Has anyone on this list played with him before?

[Haggle]

VOTE: Bambi
Who's your top tier scum, Bambi?

-Hectic

So are you townreading everyone then, Bambi? Though I appreciate the love for your fellow neighbour and faith in humanity, I'm pretty we've got some scum in our ranks.

-Hectic

[Titus]

I can't help with interpreting your new modifier, there are too many ways it could happen to be deterministic.
I feel like Creature wouldn't make up a no result for most situations. And there are numerous ways that can happen as well.

Pedit:
5) A50 was JK'd which would interfere with both actions regardless of A50's alignment. Takes the least amount of assumptions.

Jailkept people still investigate as normal.

@Bambi Jay

The odds of A50 recanting his real true role claim while claiming he could be investigated is garbage.

[Haggle]

I don't see the point in discussing this until Almo gets back.

-Hectic

[Titus]

I don't see the point in discussing this until Almo gets back.

-Hectic

Fair enough. I also discovered a 5th likely possibility in the boonbank.