Mushroom Kingdom Mafia (Game over!)

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Translation: I don't get it, but I really want to know, preferably also implicating the guy/gal who explains it. Also, it's very nice that farside exposed a non-toad.

Erm, no. Translation: I'd like someone who might be pretending to get it to have to explain what they're pretending to get.

[Korts]

Korts, Gremwell cleared TSPN with a feather last night. Gremwell's not cleared yet, but he will be tomorrow, so TSPN is not getting lynched today.

You're too confident in Gremwell's innocence, iamausername. That would deserve a vote if I didn't see some blatant wagoning just now.

unvote, vote: ashmite

Too opportunistic.

[iamausername]

I don't have any particular reason to believe that Gremwell is scum, while I do have a good reason to believe that he's town, since scum coming out with a fake feather claim would be incredibly dumb, since it's so easily testable.

[Korts]

sure I cleared a townie & because I go after some who questioned it that is scummy? If a few people are questioning it what makes them town versus scum?

It doesn't make them more likely town, but it doesn't make them more likely scum, either. It's a nulltell, and you're basing the whole wagon on it, as far as I can see.

Translation: I don't get it, but I really want to know, preferably also implicating the guy/gal who explains it. Also, it's very nice that farside exposed a non-toad.

Erm, no. Translation: I'd like someone who might be pretending to get it to have to explain what they're pretending to get.

Ok. And how do you differentiate between "gets it" and "oh yeah sure gets it completely nothing wrong here move along"? Or do you have everyone explain it?

[Korts]

I don't have any particular reason to believe that Gremwell is scum, while I do have a good reason to believe that he's town, since scum coming out with a fake feather claim would be incredibly dumb, since it's so easily testable.

That's true, but the WIFOM generated once Gremwellscum goes down is enough to make this gambit worth second thought.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Well, forcing someone to explain it can only work once.

[farside22]

sure I cleared a townie & because I go after some who questioned it that is scummy? If a few people are questioning it what makes them town versus scum?

It doesn't make them more likely town, but it doesn't make them more likely scum, either. It's a nulltell, and you're basing the whole wagon on it, as far as I can see.

Translation: I don't get it, but I really want to know, preferably also implicating the guy/gal who explains it. Also, it's very nice that farside exposed a non-toad.

Erm, no. Translation: I'd like someone who might be pretending to get it to have to explain what they're pretending to get.

Ok. And how do you differentiate between "gets it" and "oh yeah sure gets it completely nothing wrong here move along"? Or do you have everyone explain it?

Yes and lynching someone you feel is town based on their claim is a good idea too.

[Alabaska J]

unvote; vote: iamausername

Bit slow on the uptake, aren't you?

Also, RBT is a

far

superior lynch today than ssf.

[Riceballtail]

Why did I eat Gimbo? Because I still found him scummy, even if he did have that mushroom. Assuming he is on the lynch-wagon today, I will have managed to personally confirm without item that Gimbo is a townie. Alabaska is beginning to become a substantially superior lynch to iam right now. I would be more than happy to see either strung up, but Alabaska is definitely being scummy beyond belief.

UNVOTE; VOTE Alabaska J

Had it right the first time.

[Alabaska J]

Why did I eat Gimbo? Because I still found him scummy, even if he did have that mushroom. Assuming he is on the lynch-wagon today, I will have managed to personally confirm without item that Gimbo is a townie. Alabaska is beginning to become a substantially superior lynch to iam right now. I would be more than happy to see either strung up, but Alabaska is definitely being scummy beyond belief.

UNVOTE; VOTE Alabaska J

Had it right the first time.

Wow this is post is full of fail. I put forward even more evidence fora RBT to be scum and what do I get? An OMGUS vote. Should've known.

Gimbo was already essentially confirmed townie, we weren't going to lynch him definitely, and he has two votes!!!!!

And before you say anything, yes I know you couldn't have known he would have two votes today but still that choice was very anti-town. Why would you take away a vote from a confirmed townie unless you are scum?

[ashmite84]

unvote; vote: iamausername

Bit slow on the uptake, aren't you?

No, I just read the thread after all the other wagoners.

[Alabaska J]

unvote; vote: iamausername

Bit slow on the uptake, aren't you?

No, I just read the thread after all the other wagoners.

The bandwagon on iamausername died b/c of the total absence of actual evidence. It's over, sorry.

[armlx]

sure I cleared a townie & because I go after some who questioned it that is scummy? If a few people are questioning it what makes them town versus scum?

I def don't think what you did is scummy, I just think what they did is not scummy and if they are town they are FAR away from the right tree to bark up, if you catch my drift.

[Alabaska J]

sure I cleared a townie & because I go after some who questioned it that is scummy? If a few people are questioning it what makes them town versus scum?

I def don't think what you did is scummy, I just think what they did is not scummy and if they are town they are FAR away from the right tree to bark up, if you catch my drift.

Who is this quote by?

[Riceballtail]

Gimbo was already essentially confirmed townie, we weren't going to lynch him definitely, and he has two votes!!!!!

And before you say anything, yes I know you couldn't have known he would have two votes today but still that choice was very anti-town. Why would you take away a vote from a confirmed townie unless you are scum?

Because, if you actually read my claim, you would see that it only takes away votes from the swallowed victim IF THEY ARE SCUM. Your admission of things said is really asking for a lynch IMO.

[Gremwell]

Unvote: Vote Alabaska J

he was also very edgy about the coin pool idea

[Gimbo]

If Alabaska is scum, it wouldn't make sense for him to push for a lynch of a known non-Peach player (RBT), most likely scums will be pushing for the lynch of players whose roles hadn't be revealed yet to get a claim from said player.

ditto Korts and TSN on this: "I'd like someone who might be pretending to get it to have to explain what they're pretending to get. " in reference to that farside thing.

[Riceballtail]

I'm not a vanilla townie, and I understand what Farside is getting at. Therefore, I don't think any more discussion is really necessary about what she has stated.

[Riceballtail]

If Alabaska is scum, it wouldn't make sense for him to push for a lynch of a known non-Peach player (RBT), most likely scums will be pushing for the lynch of players whose roles hadn't be revealed yet to get a claim from said player.

It makes perfect sense, it's called "role-fishing". I see no reason why he would be doing it otherwise.

[farside22]

I"m going to read a few things and clear my head.

[armlx]

sure I cleared a townie & because I go after some who questioned it that is scummy? If a few people are questioning it what makes them town versus scum?

I def don't think what you did is scummy, I just think what they did is not scummy and if they are town they are FAR away from the right tree to bark up, if you catch my drift.

Who is this quote by?

Farside.

[iamausername]

If Alabaska is scum, it wouldn't make sense for him to push for a lynch of a known non-Peach player (RBT), most likely scums will be pushing for the lynch of players whose roles hadn't be revealed yet to get a claim from said player.

It makes perfect sense, it's called "role-fishing". I see no reason why he would be doing it otherwise.

How on earth is it rolefishing when you've already claimed your role??

[Alabaska J]

If Alabaska is scum, it wouldn't make sense for him to push for a lynch of a known non-Peach player (RBT), most likely scums will be pushing for the lynch of players whose roles hadn't be revealed yet to get a claim from said player.

It makes perfect sense, it's called "role-fishing". I see no reason why he would be doing it otherwise.

How on earth is it rolefishing when you've already claimed your role??

Also, why would you

try to

take the vote of a basically confirmed town if you can take a scum's vote? This seems very anti-town to me and leads me to believe you are not being truthful about you role. Also, your role has not been proven, as we don't know if Gimbo's vote counts or not yet, so stop acting like you are a confirmed townie.

Also, Gremwell, your vote seems very suspicious to me, but you'll be checked out tonight so I guess it doesn't matter anyway. Can I see some reasons please?

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Unvote, vote alabaska j.

I really don't like his OMGUSsy attitude toward, RBT, or his flippant attitude toward the iamausername wagon. I don't think either of them would be poor lynch choices.

[Gimbo]

Wait..what if Gremwell is an Investigation-Immune scum with along with TSN? It's possible.....